2026
Takeoff by IXL

K-2nd Grade - Gateway 2

Back to K-2nd Grade Overview
Cover for Takeoff by IXL
Note on review tool versions

See the series overview page to confirm the review tool version used to create this report.

Loading navigation...

Gateway Ratings Summary

Rigor and Mathematical Practices

Gateway 2 - Partially Meets Expectations
68%
Criterion 2.1: Rigor and Balance
7 / 8
Criterion 2.2: Standards for Mathematical Practices
4 / 8

The materials reviewed for Takeoff by IXL Kindergarten through Grade 2 partially meet expectations for rigor and balance and mathematical practices. The materials help students develop procedural skills, fluency, and application. The materials partially make meaningful connections between the Standards for Mathematical Content and the Standards for Mathematical Practice (MPs).

Criterion 2.1: Rigor and Balance

7 / 8

Information on Multilingual Learner (MLL) Supports in This Criterion

For some indicators in this criterion, we also display evidence and scores for pair MLL indicators.

While MLL indicators are scored, these scores are reported separately from core content scores. MLL scores do not currently impact core content scores at any level—whether indicator, criterion, gateway, or series.

To view all MLL evidence and scores for this grade band or grade level, select the "Multilingual Learner Supports" view from the left navigation panel.

Materials reflect the balances in the Standards and help students meet the Standards’ rigorous expectations by giving appropriate attention to: developing students’ conceptual understanding; procedural skill and fluency; and engaging applications.

The materials reviewed for Takeoff by IXL Kindergarten through Grade 2 meet expectations for rigor. The materials develop conceptual understanding of key mathematical concepts and give attention throughout the year to procedural skill and fluency. The materials partially meet expectations on spending sufficient time working with engaging applications. There is a balance of the three aspects of rigor within the grade

Indicator 2a

2 / 2

Materials support the intentional development of students’ conceptual understanding of key mathematical concepts, especially where called for in specific content standards or clusters.

The materials reviewed for Takeoff by IXL Kindergarten through Grade 2 meet expectations for supporting the intentional development of students’ conceptual understanding of key mathematical concepts, especially where called for in specific content standards or clusters.

The materials reviewed for Takeoff by IXL Kindergarten through Grade 2 include teacher-guided tasks during instruction and guided practice, as well as tasks in which students independently complete and respond to mathematical problems. During independent practice, students work in IXL Math. When students solve a question incorrectly, the platform provides a step-by-step explanation and allows students to watch a video tutorial or review a worked example before attempting the problem. 

Examples include:

  • Kindergarten, Unit 4: Introduction to addition, Lesson 4.2, Guided practice, Model and solve put together stories. Students develop conceptual understanding as they model and solve put-together stories. Teacher notes, “For #3, have students use two-color counters to model the following story: Marcus put 1 carrot on a plate and 2 carrots on another plate. How many carrots is that in all? Then have students count all the counters and write the numbers as they did in #2. For #4, have students use their own fingers to model the following story: Kenny holds up 5 fingers on one hand and 3 fingers on the other hand. How many fingers is that in all? Students should hold up their fingers to match those shown on the page. Then have students model the story with two-color counters and write the numbers.” (K.OA.1)

  • Grade 1, Unit 4: Subtraction within 20, Lesson 4.1, Independent practice, students demonstrate conceptual understanding as they model counting back to subtract within 20 using number lines and lists, and use addition to check their work. Subtract by counting back - up to 20 (M2G), “Count back to subtract. The number line shows how. 20-3= ___” (1.OA.6) 

  • Grade 2, Unit 8: Place value within 1,000, Lessons 8.1 and 8.3, students develop conceptual understanding as they represent and interpret place value to include hundreds. In Lesson 8.1, Instruction, Investigate the relationship between hundreds, tens, and ones, students use place value blocks to represent 100 as a group of ten tens. Teacher notes, “For #2, give students place value blocks and point out the hundred flats. Then have them discuss what they know about the number 100. They probably know a lot already! Here are some things they might say: ‘It comes after 99.’ ‘It's big.’ ‘It has two zeros in it.’ Once students have surfaced a wide range of things they know, transition to #3. Ask students how many ones are in 1 hundred (100). Point out that you can see all of the ones in the hundred flat; they've just been grouped together to make a hundred. Then ask how many tens are in 1 hundred (10). Point out that you can also see all of the tens in the hundred flat by looking at the columns or rows—they look like 10 ten rods laid side by side. For #4, have students compare Zoe's and Bruce's models. Surface that they both made 200, but Zoe used 2 hundreds and Bruce used 20 tens. Highlight that for each hundred that Zoe used, Bruce needed to use 10 tens.” In Lesson 8.2, students write and model three-digit numbers using place value models, sketches, and charts. In Lesson 8.3, students determine the value of a digit based on its position within a number. For example, in #10–13, students identify that a 3 in the ones place has a value of 3, while a 3 in the tens place has a value of 30, and that an 8 in the hundreds place has a value of 800, while an 8 in the tens place has a value of 80. (2.NBT.1)

Indicator 2b

2 / 2

Materials provide intentional opportunities for students to develop procedural skills and fluencies, especially where called for in specific content standards or clusters.

The materials reviewed for Takeoff by IXL Kindergarten through Grade 2 meet expectations for providing intentional opportunities for students to develop procedural skills and fluencies, especially where called for in specific content standards or clusters.

The materials reviewed for Takeoff by IXL Kindergarten through Grade 2 provide opportunities for students to develop procedural skills and fluency through teacher-guided instruction and guided practice. During independent practice, students work in IXL Math, where they solve procedural problems and receive immediate feedback. When students answer incorrectly, the platform provides step-by-step explanations and access to video tutorials or worked examples before students attempt the problem again. 

Examples include:

  • Kindergarten, Unit 6: Addition and subtraction, students develop procedural skill and fluency as they add and subtract within 5. Lesson 6.10, Instruction, Learn about related addition and subtraction facts, Teacher notes, “For #3, have students look at the top picture as you read the first part of the story: There are 3 horses standing together. Then 1 more horse joins. How many horses are there now? Have students write an addition sentence that matches the story. Then have them look at the bottom picture as you can continue the story: There are 4 horses together. Then 1 horse runs away. How many horses stay? Discuss how the first and second parts of the story are related. Surface these points: Both parts include a total of 4 horses. In the first part, 1 horse joins. In the second part, that same horse leaves. Have students write a subtraction sentence that matches the second part of the story, and discuss how the two number sentences are related. Emphasize that they use the same three numbers and that adding 1 and taking 1 away are opposites. Explain that this is another example of related facts.” Guided practice, Add and subtract within 5, Teacher notes, “For #5-6, have students add or subtract and circle each pair of related facts with a different crayon. Some students might identify the related facts first and use the relationships to find some of their answers. Students will learn more about using related facts as a strategy to add and subtract in first grade. Here, it’s okay for students to solve first and then identify related facts by looking for number sentences that use the same three numbers.” Question 5, “Add or subtract. Circle the related facts,  1+2= ____,  1+3=____, 3+1=____, 3-2=____.”  Question 6, “Add or subtract. Circle the related facts. 2+1=____, 4+1=____, 3-1=____, 5-1=____.” Lesson 6.11, Guided practice, Add and subtract within 5, Teacher notes, “For #3, have students find the sum and differences using any strategy. Encourage them to choose strategies that they can do quickly and correctly.” Question 3, “Add or subtract. 1+2=____. 3-2=____, 4-1=___, 3+1=____.” Teacher notes, “For #6, explain that bees live in hives and students must draw a line from each bee to the hive where it belongs. Add or subtract to find the number of each bee’s hive.” Question 6, “Help each bee find its home. 1+4, 5-3, 2+1, 4-2, 4-1(2,5,3).” (K.OA.5)

  • Grade 1, Unit 2: Addition and subtraction within 10, Lesson 2.9, Guided practice, Add and subtract within 10, students develop procedural skill and fluency as they add and sub within 20. Teacher notes, “For #8, have students add or subtract using any method, as in #3-6. Consider having students circle which problems, if any, they found difficult. Help students choose a strategy for those problems, or have students help each other. Consider putting problems the class finds more difficult into extra practice or a game to increase fluency.” Question 8, “Add or subtract. 7+2=____    2-0=____ 8-4=____   4+3=____  3+7=____   6-4=____” Teacher notes, “For #9, have students match the problems in the top row to problems in the bottom row with the same value. Question 9, “Match the problems with the same value. 10-3, 4+2, 3+5, 7-2; 9-3, 2+3, 1+6, 8-0.” Teacher notes, “For #10, have students add or subtract using any method. When they’re done, have them use the letters from the table to spell out the answer to the riddle.” Question 10, “Add or subtract. 5+5=____F, 8-2=,____ M, 6-1=____U, 4+0=____L, 6+2=____E, 7-4=____R, 10-8____A, 3+4=____S, 6+3=____T. Use the letters to solve the riddle. What is the best season for adding?” (1.OA.6) 

  • Grade 2, Unit 1: Addition and subtraction within 20, Lesson 1.3, Independent practice, students demonstrate procedural fluency by adding and subtracting within 20 using a range of mental strategies. In prior lessons, students practice adding doubles and near doubles, counting on, and making ten. Make ten to add (YJE), “Which shows a way to find 6+7. Now use your choice to add 6+7= ___” (2.OA.2)

Indicator 2c

1 / 2

Materials support the intentional development of students’ ability to utilize mathematical concepts and skills in engaging applications, especially where called for in specific content standards or clusters.

The materials reviewed for Takeoff by IXL Kindergarten through Grade 2 partially meet the criteria for supporting the intentional development of students’ ability to utilize mathematical concepts and skills in engaging applications, especially where called for in specific content standards or clusters.

The materials reviewed for Takeoff by IXL Kindergarten through Grade 2 provide opportunities for students to solve routine problems both with teacher guidance and independently. The materials include limited opportunities for teacher-guided nonroutine problem solving and do not provide opportunities for students to independently solve nonroutine problems. Teacher-guided nonroutine problems do not appear consistently across grade levels or within standards that emphasize application. During independent practice, students work in IXL Math. When students solve a question incorrectly, the platform provides a step-by-step explanation of how to solve the problem and allows students to watch a video tutorial or review a worked example before attempting the problem. These features introduce guided support during practice tasks and do not require students to engage in nonroutine problem solving independently.

For example:

  • Kindergarten, Unit 4: Introduction to addition, Lesson 4.2, Instruction: Learn to Model and Solve Put Together Stories, students use counters to model and solve put-together addition stories with teacher support. Teacher notes, “For this lesson, each student will need 10 two-color counters. For #1, explain that you can use two-color counters to show addition stories. Distribute the counters and read the following story: Mia has 2 star cookies. She has 3 heart cookies. How many cookies does Mia have in all? Have students model the story using a different color for each group. Then have students trace the numbers 2 and 3 to represent the groups. Ask students how they can find how many cookies Mia has in all. Surface that the star cookies and the heart cookies together make up all the cookies, so students can count all the counters together. Guide students to count the cookies in the picture to confirm their answers. Read the completed sentence aloud, ‘2 and 3 is 5’, and have students repeat it along with you. Explain that, as in the previous lesson, two groups are added together.” Question 1 states, “Show the story. Write the numbers. ____ and ____ is ____.” Independent Practice, Build cube trains to solve addition word problems - sums up to 10(3B6), “Read the story. A bike shop sold 7 bikes. Then, the shop sold 1 more. Show the story with cubes. In all, how many bikes did the shop sell?” (K.OA.2)

  • Grade 1, Unit 3: Addition within 20, Lesson 3.5, Guided Practice, Add Three Numbers, students solve addition problems with teacher support involving three addends and choose two numbers to add first. Teacher notes, “For 11 - 12, there are many correct solutions. Consider asking some students to share their strategies for finding numbers that worked for each problem. For example, in #11, students could start by adding any doubles. Then they can find the remaining addend by counting on from that sum to 17.” Question 11 states, “Nico adds 3 numbers that make 17. He adds doubles first. What could his numbers be? ____ + ____ + ____ = 17.” Question 12 states, “Nico adds 3 different numbers that make 17. He makes 10 first. What could his numbers be? ____ + ____ + ____ = 17.” Students complete independent practice using the skill set “Write number sentences for word problems without comparisons—up to 20 (T9A),” which requires solving routine problems. “Read the story. Mike's apple tree had 17 apples. Then, Mike picked 8 of them. How many apples are left on the tree? Write a number sentence to match the story. Use the ? for the unknown number. How many apples are left on the tree? ___ apples” (1.OA.1)

  • Grade 2, Unit 6: Measuring Length, Lesson 6.10, Guided Practice, Model and Solve Word Problems in Centimeters and Meters, students solve length problems with teacher support. Question 8 states, “Zoe likes to build tracks for her toy cars. She got a new set of track pieces for her birthday. The table lists the length of each type of piece. Color — Length, Orange — 5 centimeters, Blue — 8 centimeters, Green — 20 centimeters, Purple — 28 centimeters Zoe links one blue piece and two orange pieces together to make a track. How long is the track? Zoe links some pieces together until they are the same length as 1 purple piece. What pieces could Zoe have put together? Can you find more than one answer? Show or explain your work.” Independent practice, Metric units of length: word problems (KJ5), “Emily's nail is 4 centimeters long. Connor's nail is 1 centimeter shorter than Emily's. Shelley's nail is 3 centimeters longer than Emily's. Who has the longest nail? Connor Shelley Emily” (2.MD.5)

Indicator 2d

2 / 2

The three aspects of rigor are not always treated together and are not always treated separately. There is a balance of the three aspects of rigor within the grade as reflected by the standards.

The materials reviewed for Takeoff by IXL Kindergarten through Grade 2 meet expectations in that the three aspects of rigor are not always treated together and are not always treated separately. There is a balance of the three aspects of rigor within the grade as reflected by the standards.

Multiple aspects of rigor are engaged simultaneously across the materials to develop students' mathematical understanding of individual lessons. Each lesson within the curriculum supports a variety of instructional approaches that incorporate conceptual understanding, procedural fluency, and application in a balanced way. According to Additional resources, Instructional design, A balanced approach to rigor, “Takeoff by IXL elevates students’ math learning using a balanced approach to mathematical rigor. With lessons thoughtfully crafted to develop students’ conceptual understanding, procedural fluency, and ability to tackle real-world applications, Takeoff not only provides in-depth exploration into each element of rigor but also intertwines the elements for a richer, more well-rounded understanding of math concepts.”

For example:

  • Kindergarten, Unit 6: Addition and subtraction, Lesson 6.1, Instruction, Add numbers using pictures, students develop procedural skill and conceptual understanding by using pictures to add two numbers with sums up to 10. Teacher notes, “For #2, read the addition sentence aloud as a question: What is 3 plus 2? Guide students to count the number of birds in each group to see that the picture matches the addition sentence. Consider having them circle each group. Then have students find the total by counting all the birds. Explain that the total in an addition sentence is called the sum. After writing the sum, lead students in reading the completed addition sentence aloud: ‘3 plus 2 equals 5.’ Ask students how pictures can help them find sums. Students should recognize that they can count all the objects to find the sum. Repeat the process for #3. Begin by reading the addition sentence as a question (‘What is 4 plus 1?’). Then have students count the birds in each group, find the sum, and say the completed addition sentence aloud (‘4 plus 1 equals 5’).” Question 2, Add. Count the birds to help. 3+2=____. Question 3, Add. Count the birds to help. 4+1=____.” (K.CC.4)

  • Grade 1, Unit 2: Addition and subtraction within 10, Lesson 2.7, Guided practice, Add and subtract with 0, students develop procedural skill and conceptual understanding by solving a word problem that involves adding zero. Teacher notes, “For #10-11, have students fill in each number sentence to match the story and complete the sentence to answer the question.” Question 10 states, “Tess has no coins. Then her brother gives her 9 coins. How many coins does Tess have now? Write a number sentence. ____\bigcirc____\bigcirc____ Tess has ____ coins now.” Question 11 states, “There are 5 crabs on the beach. All 5 crabs leave. How many crabs are still on the beach? Write a number sentence. ____\bigcirc____\bigcirc____ There are ____ crabs still on the beach.” Teacher notes, “For #12, have students solve using any method.” Question 12. states, “There are 6 kids at the playground. It starts to rain, but 0 kids leave. How many kids are at the playground in the rain? ____ kids.” (1.OA.6)

  • Grade 2, Unit 9: Addition and subtraction within 1,000, Lesson 9.4, students demonstrate procedural skill and conceptual understanding by using place value strategies to add three-digit numbers, breaking numbers apart and adding hundreds with hundreds, tens with tens, and ones with ones. Student book, Question 12 states, “On Thursday, the space museum sold 251 child tickets and 345 adult tickets. In all, how many tickets did the museum sell on Thursday?” Students use expanded form to solve. (2.NBT.7)

Criterion 2.2: Standards for Mathematical Practices

4 / 8

Information on Multilingual Learner (MLL) Supports in This Criterion

For some indicators in this criterion, we also display evidence and scores for pair MLL indicators.

While MLL indicators are scored, these scores are reported separately from core content scores. MLL scores do not currently impact core content scores at any level—whether indicator, criterion, gateway, or series.

To view all MLL evidence and scores for this grade band or grade level, select the "Multilingual Learner Supports" view from the left navigation panel.

Materials meaningfully connect the Standards for Mathematical Content and Standards for Mathematical Practice (MPs).

The materials reviewed for Takeoff by IXL Kindergarten through Grade 2 partially meet expectations for mathematical practices. The materials inconsistently meaningfully connect the Standards for Mathematical Content and the Standards for Mathematical Practice (MPs).

Indicator 2e

0 / 1

Materials support the intentional development of MP1: Make sense of problems and persevere in solving them, for students, in connection to the grade-level content standards, as expected by the mathematical practice standards.

The materials reviewed for Takeoff by IXL Grades Kindergarten through Grade 2 do not meet expectations for supporting the intentional development of MP1: Make sense of problems and persevere in solving them, in connection to the grade-level content standards, as expected by the mathematical practice standards.

In Grade 2, MP1 is identified across the year. Teachers receive guidance in the Teacher’s Guide, and each unit includes a Unit Overview with Math Practices guidance that highlights examples of the Mathematical Practices addressed within that unit. In addition, the Mathematical Practices are identified in the overview of each lesson.

In Grade 2, students engage in open-ended tasks that support key components of MP1, including sense-making, strategy development, and perseverance. These tasks prompt them to make sense of mathematical situations, develop and revise strategies, and persist through challenges. They are encouraged to analyze problems by engaging with the information and questions presented, using strategies that make sense to them, monitoring and evaluating their progress, determining whether their answers are reasonable, reflecting on and revising their approaches, and increasingly devising strategies independently. 

For example: 

  • Grade 2, Unit 10: Money and time, Lesson 10.7, Instruction, Learn to solve word problems involving money, students solve real-world problems involving money. Students make sense of the problems and use previously learned strategies to help them solve these problems. Teacher notes state, “For each problem in the lesson, encourage students to identify the information they know, what they need to find, and any other hidden questions they need to answer along the way. Students may solve each problem mentally or model it using strip models, equations, or drawings of bills or coins. Encourage students to pick the model that works best for the strategy they are using to solve the problem. For #2, help students identify that, while this problem does involve money, it is otherwise similar to other two-step word problems they've solved this year. Then ask students what they will find first. The question hints at a good first step: find how much Cameron and Dana have together. Have students use a strip model or an equation to show how much money Cameron and Dana have altogether, and point out that you can add these amounts because they have the same units (dollars). Next, have students finish the problem by finding how much more money Cameron and Dana need to buy the game system together. Some students may notice that you could also solve this problem by subtracting the amount of money Cameron or Dana has from 25 and then subtracting again. If it comes up, validate this solution and point out that it results in the same answer, but there's no need to surface it otherwise. Throughout this lesson, encourage students to evaluate the reasonableness of their results in each step. For example, in #2, since Cameron and Dana need more money to buy the game system, it makes sense that together they have less than 25.” Student book states, “2. Cameron and Dana go to the yard sale. They find an old video game system that costs 25. Dana has 11, and Cameron has $10. If they put their money together, how much more money will they need to buy the game system? What will you find first? What do you need to find next? They need ____ more to buy the game system.” Unit Outline, Math practices state, “Across Unit 10, students make sense of problems involving money and time. Be sure to draw connections between these new problems and students' prior learning, which can help students identify entry points to solving the problems. Lesson 10.7 is a good opportunity to emphasize that what students already know about addition and subtraction word problems applies equally well in contexts involving adding to, putting together, taking from, taking apart, or comparing money amounts—students can continue to use the same strategies from earlier in the year to solve these problems. Encourage students to break up problems into steps and create a plan to solve them. Have them discuss different approaches they took to solving each problem. When students take different approaches, have them analyze each other's work to see if someone else's approach might be easier to understand or more efficient to execute.”

Kindergarten and Grade 1 do not meet the full intent of MP1. Although MP1 is identified across the year in Kindergarten and Grade 1 materials, lesson evidence does not show students making sense of problems, independently devising strategies, monitoring and evaluating their progress, determining whether their answers make sense, or reflecting on and revising their strategies. Teacher guidance does not include problems that require students to make sense of a situation or choose an approach, and it does not include probing or clarifying questions or opportunities for student reflection as outlined in the criteria.

For example:

  • Kindergarten, Unit 3: Two-dimensional shapes, Lesson 3.9 does not meet the full intent of MP1 because students do not analyze and make sense of problems, use a variety of strategies that make sense to solve problems, monitor and evaluate their progress, determine if their answers make sense, reflect on and revise their problem-solving strategy, or devise strategies independently. The student tasks require students to join pattern blocks to match a provided outline, which does not present a problem for students to understand or interpret. Because the task already dictates the goal and the method, students do not select approaches on their own or determine how to represent the situation. The lesson does not provide opportunities for students to monitor progress or evaluate whether their completed shapes make sense. Students also do not engage in reflection or revision, as the activity focuses on producing a single assembled shape. The teacher materials do not guide teachers to pose rich problems, provide time for students to make sense of problems, offer opportunities for genuine problem solving, ask clarifying and probing questions, or create reflection opportunities. 

  • Kindergarten, Unit 5: Introduction to subtraction, Lesson 5.5 does not meet the full intent of MP1 because students are not engaged in analyzing and making sense of problems, using a variety of strategies that make sense, monitoring and evaluating their progress, determining if their answers make sense, reflecting on and revising their problem-solving strategy, or devising strategies independently. In each example, the teacher provides the story, the model to use, and the steps students must follow, such as placing counters, flipping counters, coloring circles, or drawing lines to show groups. Students do not interpret a problem or determine what information is needed; instead, they follow a prescribed procedure for representing parts of a total. Because students do not choose their own strategies, the tasks do not encourage variety in approaches. There is no expectation that students monitor or evaluate their progress or reflect on whether their answers make sense within the story context. The teacher materials direct students step by step rather than posing rich problems or prompting students to make sense of a situation on their own. The materials do not guide teachers to provide opportunities for genuine problem solving, ask clarifying or probing questions that extend student thinking, or create opportunities for students to reflect on and revise strategies. 

  • Kindergarten, Unit 7: Classify and sort data, Lessons 7.2 and 7.3 do not meet the full intent of MP1 because students do not engage in analyzing and making sense of problems, using a variety of strategies that make sense, monitoring and evaluating their progress, determining if their answers make sense, reflecting on and revising their problem-solving strategy, or devising strategies independently. The tasks require students to sort objects or shapes into given categories, count the objects, and write numbers to show how many are in each group. These directions present no problem for students to understand or interpret, and the sorting attribute is predetermined, leaving no opportunity for students to decide on an approach or develop their own strategies. Students follow a fixed sequence of steps and are not asked to monitor their progress or determine whether their counts or comparisons make sense. The tasks do not include opportunities for reflection or revision of strategies. The teacher materials guide teachers to manage the sorting activities, but do not direct them to pose rich problems, provide time for students to make sense of problems, offer opportunities for problem solving, ask clarifying and probing questions that extend student thinking, or create reflection opportunities. 

  • Grade 1, Unit 5: More addition and subtraction stories, Lesson 5.4 does not meet the full intent of MP1. Students do not analyze and make sense of problems, use a variety of strategies that make sense to them, monitor or evaluate their progress, determine whether their answers make sense, reflect on or revise their strategy, or devise strategies independently. The tasks direct students to complete pre-drawn strip models and write number sentences, which predetermine the method instead of requiring students to understand or interpret a problem. Students follow teacher-directed steps, such as placing question marks in the model, building and breaking linked-cube trains, or applying given number facts. Students do not select representations or strategies, and the work does not ask them to check the reasonableness of their answers. The materials also do not guide teachers to pose rich problems, allow time for students to make sense of situations, create opportunities for problem solving, ask clarifying or probing questions, or provide structured opportunities for student reflection.

  • Grade 1, Unit 8: Data, Lesson 8.5 does not meet the full intent of MP1 because students do not analyze and make sense of problems, use a variety of strategies that make sense, monitor and evaluate their progress, determine if their answers make sense, reflect on and revise their problem-solving strategy, or devise strategies independently. Students answer comparison questions using a tally chart that the teacher directs them to interpret and update. The teacher directs students to add tally marks and subtract to find differences, so students do not determine what information is needed or select a method for solving the problem. The tasks do not ask students to check the reasonableness of their answers or evaluate their progress, and the teacher materials do not pose rich problems, prompt sense-making, offer opportunities for problem solving, ask clarifying and probing questions, or create reflection opportunities.

  • Grade 1, Unit 12: Geometry, Lessons 12.5 and 12.12 do not meet the full intent of MP1 because students do not analyze and make sense of problems, use a variety of strategies that make sense, monitor and evaluate their progress, determine if their answers make sense, reflect on and revise their problem-solving strategy, or devise strategies independently. The activities ask students to match cut-out shapes or wooden blocks to outlines and pictures, which provides the goal and method, and does not require students to make sense of a problem. Students replicate shapes, count blocks, or arrange pieces in a prescribed way, and they do not evaluate their progress or reflect on their approaches. Teacher materials describe how to help students match corners or turn shapes, but do not pose rich problems, provide time for sense-making, offer opportunities for problem solving, ask clarifying and probing questions, or create reflection opportunities.

Indicator 2f

0 / 1

Materials support the intentional development of MP2: Reason abstractly and quantitatively, for students, in connection to the grade-level content standards, as expected by the mathematical practice standards.

The materials reviewed for Takeoff by IXL for Kindergarten through Grade 2 do not meet expectations for supporting the intentional development of MP2: Reason abstractly and quantitatively, for students, in connection to the grade-level content standards, as expected by the mathematical practice standards. 

In Grades 1 and 2, MP2 is identified across the year. Teachers receive guidance in the Teacher’s Guide, and each unit includes a Unit Overview with Math Practices guidance that highlights examples of the Mathematical Practices addressed within that unit. In addition, the Mathematical Practices are identified in the overview of each lesson.

Across Grades 1 and 2, students participate in tasks that support key components of MP2, including reasoning with quantities, representing situations symbolically, and interpreting the meaning of numbers and symbols in context. These tasks encourage students to consider the units involved in a problem, analyze the relationships between quantities, and connect real-world scenarios to mathematical representations. Teachers are guided to support this development by modeling the use of mathematical notation, asking clarifying and probing questions, and facilitating conversations that help students make connections between multiple representations. 

For example:

  • Grade 1, Unit 5: More addition and subtraction stories, Lesson 5.6, Instruction, Learn to solve compare word problems, students connect the story context to comparative relationships and determine which quantity is greater or less using the terms more than and fewer than. Teacher notes state, “For #2, point out that this story is comparing two amounts. Ask students what language in the story tells them this story is comparing two amounts. (Julie has 3 more shells than Lucy.) Then ask students who has more shells. (Julie does, because the story says she has more than Lucy.) Guide students to complete the strip model to represent the story. Point out that in strip models for stories that compare two amounts, the strips represent the amounts being compared, and the line represents the difference between them. Because Julie has more shells, the larger strip represents her shells, and the smaller strip represents Lucy's shells. Have students label the strips Lucy and Julie, and then mark what else they know: Lucy has 5 shells (her strip) and Julie has 3 more than that (the difference). They don't know how many shells Julie has, so they can use a ? to mark this. Then have students write a number sentence to match the strip model and solve the problem. Ask them whether their answer makes sense, knowing that Julie should have more shells. In #3, ask students what language tells them this story is comparing two amounts. Since there are fewer bags than chairs, the smaller strip represents the bags, and the bigger strip represents the chairs. Have students label the strips, chairs, and bags. Then have students mark what they know (there are 12 chairs, and the difference between the number of bags and the number of chairs is 7) and use a ? to mark what they don't know (the number of bags). Then have students write and solve a number sentence to represent the story. The subtraction sentence 12-7= ? is a natural choice, but students can also write other number sentences, such as ?+7=12?. Consider having students compare #2 and #3. Highlight the following points: In #2, the bigger amount was unknown, so students added. In #3, the smaller amount was unknown, so they subtracted. In #2, addition was used to represent 3 more than 5. In #3, subtraction was used to represent 7 fewer than 12.” Student book states, “2. Lucy has 5 shells. Julie has 3 more shells than Lucy. How many shells does Julie have? Who has more shells? Julie, Lucy. Show the story. Write the number sentence. ____ shells. 3. There are 7 fewer bags than chairs. There are 12 chairs. How many bags are there? Show the story. Write the number sentence. ____ bags.” Unit outline, Math practices state, “In Unit 5, students use models and equations to make sense of addition and subtraction word problems. Encourage them to explain how each part of their model or equation connects to the problem, helping them move between real-world situations and abstract representations. This skill allows students to more easily identify the unknown in add to, take from, put together, and take apart stories (Lessons 5.1–5.5), as well as in compare stories (Lesson 5.6). Remind students to check their math by considering the context of each problem.”

  • Grade 2, Unit 5: Addition and subtraction problems within 100, Lesson 5.7, Instruction: Solve one- and two-step addition and subtraction word problems, students think abstractly as they interpret the information in the word problem, determine the necessary computations, and apply those calculations to solve the problem. Teacher notes state, “For #2, help students identify that this problem requires two steps and ask them what step they should perform first. Some students may choose to add the number of fish tacos and the number of chicken tacos, and others may choose to subtract one of those numbers from the total number of tacos. Both are valid first steps. Have students perform the first step they identified, showing their work with an equation, a strip model, or both. Then ask students what information they know and what they will need to do to finish the problem (either subtract the sum they found in the first step or subtract the number of tacos they didn't subtract in the first step). Again, ask them to show their work with an equation, a strip model, or both. Be on the lookout for students who write equations such as 70+?=86 and get stuck. Remind them that they can use a related equation, such as 86-70=?, to help.” Student book states, “2. Tyler is a chef at Zesty Tacos. He made 46 fish tacos, 24 chicken tacos, and some veggie tacos. Altogether, he made 86 tacos. How many veggie tacos did Tyler make?” Guided practice: Solve one- and two-step addition and subtraction word problems. Teacher notes state, “For #9, consider prompting students with these questions: What does the equation 19+23=42 represent? (It shows the number of oatmeal cookies and sugar cookies baked altogether.) What does the equation 47-42=5 represent? (It shows the difference between the number of chocolate chip cookies baked and the number of oatmeal cookies and sugar cookies baked altogether.) What question was Tina wondering about? (How many more chocolate chip cookies than oatmeal and sugar cookies did I bake?).” Student book states, “9. Tina had a question about the cookies she baked. She wrote this work to answer her question: 19+23=42, 47-42=5, 5 cookies. What question did Tina have?” Unit outline, Math practices state, “In Unit 5, students reason quantitatively as they interpret real-world scenarios and represent them with models and equations. In Lesson 5.5, they solve one-step word problems. Ask questions that help them identify the knowns and unknowns and see how those quantities are related. (What information is missing? Are you comparing two amounts or finding a total?) Once students grasp the context, encourage them to represent the situation with strip models and equations. Remind them to check that their models reflect the relationships in the problem. In Lesson 5.7, students tackle both one- and two-step word problems. Emphasize the importance of checking whether answers make sense in the context, especially for multi-step problems, where it's easy to overlook part of the task.”

Kindergarten does not meet the full intent of MP2 because the materials do not provide consistent opportunities for students to reason with quantities, represent situations symbolically, or interpret the meaning of numbers and symbols in context. Tasks focus primarily on counting, identifying numbers, and working with objects at a concrete level, without prompting students to consider units, analyze quantitative relationships, or connect real-world situations to mathematical representations in a meaningful way. Teacher guidance does not consistently model mathematical notation, pose clarifying or probing questions that support quantitative reasoning, or facilitate discussions that help students connect multiple representations. 

For example:

  • Kindergarten, Unit 2: Numbers to 10, Lesson 2.12 does not meet the full intent of MP2 because the lesson does not ask students to consider units involved in a problem and attend to the meaning of quantities, represent situations symbolically, explain or discuss what the numbers represent, or understand relationships between problem scenarios and mathematical representations. The student tasks focus on counting objects, writing numerals, and circling whether one number is greater than, less than, or equal to another (“have students count each group and write the number… circle the greater number and underline the number that is less”), but these tasks do not require students to connect quantities to a scenario or explain the meaning of the numbers. Teacher guidance directs students to “count each group and write the numbers,” “circle either the green checkmark or the red X,” and “draw dots to show a number that is greater,” but it does not instruct teachers to ensure students make connections between mathematical representations and scenarios, ask clarifying and probing questions, model the use of mathematical symbols and notation, support students in analyzing quantities and their relationships, or facilitate connections between multiple representations.

  • Kindergarten, Unit 4: Introduction to addition, Lesson 4.1 does not meet the full intent of MP2 because the lesson does not engage students in considering units or the meaning of quantities, representing situations symbolically, explaining what numbers represent, or understanding relationships between story contexts and mathematical representations. Students act out teacher-provided stories, make cube trains, count objects, and trace or write numbers (“point to the kids who are playing at the start and trace the number 3… trace the number 2… count all the cubes and write the numbers”), but these actions do not require them to connect the quantities in the story to the mathematical representations or discuss what the numbers in the sentences mean. Teacher guidance directs students to act out the story, model with cubes, count, and fill in the “__ and is ” sentences, but it does not guide teachers to ensure students make connections between representations and scenarios, ask clarifying or probing questions about the quantities, model mathematical notation in context, support analysis of the relationships among the quantities, or facilitate connections across multiple representations. 

  • Kindergarten, Unit 9: Numbers to 100, Lesson 9.2 does not meet the full intent of MP2 because the lesson does not ask students to consider units involved in a problem and attend to the meaning of quantities, represent situations symbolically, explain or discuss what numbers or symbols represent, or understand relationships between problem scenarios and mathematical representations. Student tasks in Lesson 9.2 focus on counting pictured objects, reading numbers, circling numbers on a chart, identifying the number heard in a short statement, and writing numerals (e.g., counting cookies in #1, saying or circling numbers in #3–4, identifying a heard number in #7–9, and writing missing numerals in #10–11). These tasks do not require students to relate quantities to a scenario or explain what the numbers represent. Teacher directions instruct students to “count,” “say the number,” “circle the numbers,” “listen and write,” and “write the numbers,” but they do not guide teachers to ensure students make connections between mathematical representations and scenarios, ask clarifying and probing questions, model the use of mathematical symbols and notation in context, support students in analyzing quantities and their relationships, or facilitate connections between multiple representations. The lesson provides counting and numeral-identification activities only and does not include symbolic representations of situations or multiple representations that students connect.

Indicator 2g

1 / 1

Materials support the intentional development of MP3: Construct viable arguments and critique the reasoning of others, in connection to the grade-level content standards, as expected by the mathematical practice standards.

The materials reviewed for Takeoff by IXL for Kindergarten through Grade 2 meet expectations for supporting the intentional development of MP3: Construct viable arguments and critique the reasoning of others, for students, in connection to the grade-level content standards, as expected by the mathematical practice standards. 

In Grades K-2, MP3 is identified across the year. Teachers receive guidance in the Teacher’s Guide, and each unit includes a Unit Overview with Math Practices guidance that highlights examples of the Mathematical Practices addressed within that unit. In addition, the Mathematical Practices are identified in the overview of each lesson.

Across the grades, students participate in tasks that support key components of MP3. These include constructing mathematical arguments, analyzing errors in sample student work, and explaining or justifying their thinking orally or in writing using concrete models, drawings, numbers, or actions. Students are encouraged to listen to or read the arguments of others, evaluate their reasoning, and ask clarifying questions to strengthen or improve the argument. They also have opportunities to make and test conjectures as they solve problems. Teachers are guided to support this development by providing opportunities for students to engage in mathematical discourse, set clear expectations for explanation and justification, and compare different strategies or solutions. Teachers are prompted to ask clarifying and probing questions, support students in presenting their solutions as arguments, and facilitate discussions that help students reflect on and refine their reasoning.

Examples include: 

  • Kindergarten, Unit 2: Numbers to 10, Lesson 2.7, Instruction, Correct mistakes: Up to 10, students critique the counting in the lesson and construct viable arguments explaining why the counts are incorrect. Teaching notes state, “Show students a page from Correct mistakes in counting: Up to 10. Introduce the fictional characters Dan and Emma, two kids who are learning to count (just like Beth and Max, who they met in Unit 1). Explain that Dan and Emma sometimes make mistakes. The class is going to help them fix the counting mistakes. Remind the class that it's okay to make mistakes, because fixing them helps us learn. For each group of objects, demonstrate how one of the characters counts, sometimes counting correctly, sometimes making a mistake. Point to the objects and count aloud. Include the following errors as you count: For #1, have Dan count the top bumper car twice, once at the start and once at the end. Keep a finger on the top car to make the mistake more apparent. For #2, have Emma count the apples correctly. For #3, have Emma miss counting the center tent. For #4, have Dan miss a number as he counts (e.g. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9). For #5, have Dan count the ice cream correctly. For #6, have Emma repeat a number or two as she counts (e.g. 1, 2, 3, 3, 4, 5, 6, 6, 7, 8). After counting a group, ask students what they noticed. Have them say whether the counting was correct. If the counting was incorrect, have students explain what went wrong and how to fix it. Help the class celebrate when Dan or Emma counts correctly, and help the class encourage Dan or Emma to keep trying when they make mistakes.” Unit Overview, Math practices state, “Collaborative conversations in this unit give students a chance to reflect on their thinking and develop a deeper understanding of counting concepts. For example, in Lesson 2.7, students look for errors in Dan's and Emma's counting. Use this exercise to highlight common mistakes, such as skipping an object or repeating a number. Encourage students to explain why these errors might happen and how to correct them. As students discuss, prompt them to use what they know about the number sequence to support and communicate their ideas.” Students and teachers also have access to a worksheet, "Correct mistakes in counting: Up to 10," where the above mistakes are highlighted. 

  • Grade 1, Unit 4: Subtraction within 20, Lesson 4.1, Instruction: Learn to subtract within 20 by counting back. Students examine two subtraction solutions, identify which one is correct, and critique the incorrect work. Teacher notes state, “For #6, students should recognize that Kelly is correct. Emphasize that when you subtract by counting back, you count back from the starting number—you shouldn't include it in the amount you count back. Steve wrote 3 numbers, but he only counted back by 2, which is incorrect. Ask students about other ways they can determine who is correct. Surface that they can subtract by counting back using another method (fingers or a number line) or use addition to check Kelly's and Steve's work.” Student book states, “6. Steve and Kelly both counted back to find 17-3. Who is correct? How do you know?” Students see both students’ work. Steve counts back using 17 as one of the three numbers, which makes his solution incorrect. Students have another opportunity to formulate a viable argument about which problem is easier to solve using the counting-back strategy. Guided Practice, Subtract within 20 by counting back states, “For #15, students should count back to find each difference. Have them circle the easier one and explain their reasoning.” Student book states, “15. Subtract. Which one was easier to find by counting back? 14-8=, 14-3=, Why do you think that was?” Unit Outline, Math practices state, “As students explore subtraction strategies within 20, they have multiple opportunities to construct arguments. For example, in #15 from Lesson 4.1, students explain which problem is easier to solve by counting back, reinforcing that it is more efficient to count back by smaller numbers. Similarly, in #9 from Lesson 4.7, students are asked to identify and explain which problem cannot be solved by making 10, promoting a deeper understanding of subtraction strategies. These activities provide students with practice in constructing written arguments while strengthening their conceptual understanding of subtraction. Students also critique others' reasoning during error analysis problems. In #13 from Lesson 4.4, students identify and correct Grace's mistake using a number line for subtraction. Encourage students to articulate Grace's error to help them strengthen their critical thinking skills.” 

  • Grade 2, Unit 9: Addition and subtraction within 1,000, Lesson 9.4, Instruction, Learning to add by breaking apart both addends, students form viable arguments about which strategy works best for them when solving a multi-digit addition problem, and conduct error analysis of others’ work. Teacher notes state, “For #5, have students discuss whose method they think will work and why. Surface that all three of the approaches will result in the correct sum, though starting with the hundreds or ones is generally more organized. Then have students find the sum. Consider splitting the class into three groups and having each group use a different approach, starting with hundreds, tens, or ones. Then compare answers to show that no matter which place you start with, the sum is the same.” Student book states, “5. Anna, Leo, and Owen want to find 154+532. They all have different ideas for how to start. Anna: I will start by adding the hundreds, since they’re the biggest. Leo: I will start by adding the ones. Owen: I will start by adding the tens. I want to see if it works. Whose method will work? What is the sum?” Students see the problem in standard algorithm form and in expanded form. Later in the lesson, students conduct error analysis of another student’s work using the expanded form strategy. Guided Practice, Add using expanded form, Teacher notes state, “For #14, have students describe Jade's mistake. Then have them show how to fix the mistake by finding the correct sum.” Student book states, “14. Jade tried to find 571+416 using expanded form. What mistake did Jade make? Find the correct sum.” Unit Outline, Math practices state, “As students critique the reasoning of others in Unit 9, they learn to recognize and correct common mistakes made when dealing with larger numbers. For example, in #14 from Lesson 9.3, students examine a common place value error—Aaron confused the tens and ones in 304. Encourage students to explain the mistake and to suggest ways to avoid such mistakes in the future. Students also build their ability to construct arguments by comparing strategies for adding and subtracting within 1,000. Highlight opportunities to discuss different approaches, such as when breaking apart numbers to add (Lesson 9.4) and using number lines to subtract (Lesson 9.9). Ask students to justify the use of a particular strategy and why it might be more efficient than another. Encourage them to listen to each other's reasoning, ask clarifying questions, and respond with their own ideas.” 

Indicator 2h

1 / 1

Materials support the intentional development of MP4: Model with mathematics, for students, in connection to the grade-level content standards, as expected by the mathematical practice standards.

The materials reviewed for Takeoff by IXL for Kindergarten through Grade 2 meet expectations for supporting the intentional development of MP4: Model with mathematics, for students, in connection to the grade-level content standards, as expected by the mathematical practice standards. 

In Grades K-2, MP4 is identified across the year. Teachers receive guidance in the Teacher’s Guide, and each unit includes a Unit Overview with Math Practices guidance that highlights examples of the Mathematical Practices addressed within that unit. In addition, the Mathematical Practices are identified at the overview of each lesson.

Across the grades, students participate in tasks that support the intentional development of MP4, including putting problems or situations in their own words and identifying important information, using the math they know to solve problems and everyday situations, modeling the situation with appropriate representations and strategies, describing how their model relates to the problem situation, and checking whether their answer makes sense, revising the model when necessary.

Examples include: 

  • Kindergarten, Unit 10: Three-dimensional shapes, Lesson 10.10, Instruction: Describe objects in a scene, students model real-world objects with three-dimensional shapes and describe the objects using the shapes that compose them. Teacher notes state, “For #2, put students in small groups and have them take turns giving clues about an object for the rest of the group to identify. Like #1, students could simply point to the object that matches the clues if they don't know its name. The student giving clues should use the shape name and at least one position word. For example, here are some things students could say: This is shaped like a cube. It is behind the truck. (The house.) This is shaped like a sphere. It is below the moon. (The streetlight.) This is shaped like a cylinder. It is next to something shaped like a cone. (The water tank on the truck or the trashcan.) Find something that's shaped like a cone and is in front of the house. (The traffic cone or the light from the streetlight.)” Students see a city scene with a rectangular house and identify the shapes that compose the different real-life items. Unit Outline, Math practices state, “Students begin to see how geometric solids can represent objects in the real world in this unit. In Lesson 10.7, they match familiar objects to the solids they most closely resemble, such as a can to a cylinder or a box to a rectangular prism. Emphasize that real-world objects aren't perfect geometric shapes, but they can still be described and understood using shape names. In Lesson 10.10, students apply this reasoning to describe scenes, using solid names and spatial language to explain where and how objects appear in relation to one another. Through this work, students lay the foundation for using geometry to interpret and represent the world around them.”

  • Grade 1, Unit 11: Addition and subtraction within 100, Lesson 11.10, Instruction: Represent and solve addition and subtraction stories within 100, students solve real-world problems using strategies such as the strip model to connect the mathematics to the situation. Teacher notes state, “For #2, have students read the story and identify what they know and what they need to find. Guide students to think about the strip model in the same way that they did for smaller numbers: it represents a whole (which you write on the line above) and can be split into parts. They know the two parts (the 21 kids in class and the 7 kids who join). They need to find the whole (the total number of kids in Ms. Joy's class). Have students discuss whether they need to add or subtract to solve the problem. They should understand that they need to put together two parts to find a whole, so they should add. Then have them write an equation using a ? for the unknown total. Students may write any related equation, but discuss how 21+7=? models the story well and makes it clear what operation to use to solve the problem. After students have written the equation, have them add using any strategy. After students find the sum, have them revisit the story and check whether their answer makes sense. Because more kids join Ms. Joy's art class, the sum should be greater than the starting number.” Student book states, “2. There are 21 kids in Ms. Joy’s art class. Then, 7 more kids join. How many kids are in Ms. Joy’s class now? Show the story. Write an equation.” Students use a strip model to solve the problem. Later in Lesson 11.10, students continue to model strategies to solve real-world problems. Teacher notes state, “In #4, students are given the whole (80 glue sticks) and one of the parts (30 glue sticks). Students should use a single-strip model and subtract to find the missing part. Students will likely use a place value sketch or subtract tens from tens. In #5, students are given two parts (35 boxes of crayons and 27 boxes of markers) and are asked to find the whole. Again, they will use a single-strip model, but this time they will add the parts to find the whole. Have students add using any strategy and record their work. Some good choices for this problem include using a place value sketch or adding tens to tens and ones to ones. After solving each problem, have students reread the problem and make sure their answer is reasonable. For example, in #4, the number of glue sticks left should be less than the number of glue sticks Ms. Joy started with because some were thrown away.” Student book states, “4. Ms. Joy has 80 glue sticks. She throws 30 of them away because they are dried out. How many glue sticks are left? Write an equation. 5. Ms. Joy has 35 boxes of crayons and 27 boxes of markers. How many boxes of crayons and markers does she have in all? Write an equation.” Unit outline, Math practices state, “Students model with mathematics in Lesson 11.10 as they solve story problems involving either addition or subtraction. As in Unit 5, encourage students to begin by using strip models to represent the relationships in each story. Visual models support students in identifying what's happening in the story and what they need to find. Reinforce the connection between models, equations, and stories by prompting students to explain how each part of a model relates to the numbers in an equation and the context of a story.”

  • Grade 2, Unit 2: Equal groups, Lesson 2.3, Instruction: Learn to represent equal groups with repeated addition, students draw pictures to represent real-world problems involving equal groups. Teacher notes state, “For #2, guide students to draw an equal groups model. Students could draw four popsicle sticks three times and then circle each group. They could also draw a circle to represent each frame and then draw four popsicle sticks in each circle. Finally, guide students in completing the sentences. Have students count to find the total number of popsicle sticks. They may notice that they could also add three 4s or skip-count by 4s to find the total. If so, use these strategies to transition to the next problem. For #3, have students draw three circles to represent the three frames. Then have them draw five dots in each circle to represent the stickers. Point out that you can count every dot, skip-count by 5s, or add three 5s to find the total number of stickers. The repeated addition sentence relates to the strategy of adding three 5s. Explain how each addend represents the number of stickers in one group, and the sum represents the total number of stickers. Remind students that in order to add three numbers, they can find the sum of the first two addends, then add on the third addend.” Student book states, “2. Levi is making 3 picture frames. He needs 4 popsicle sticks for each frame. Draw to show how many popsicle sticks Levi needs in all. Complete the sentences. There will be ____ frames. Levi needs ____ popsicle sticks for each frame. Levi needs ____ popsicle sticks in all. 3. Next Levi needs 5 stickers for each of his 3 frames. Draw to show how many stickers Levi needs in all. Complete the sentences. There are ____ frames. Levi needs ____ stickers for each frame. Levi needs ____ stickers in all. Complete the repeated addition sentence. ____+ ____+ ____=_____” Later in Lesson 2.3, students complete a similar problem on their own. Guided Practice, Represent equal groups with repeated addition, Teacher notes state, “For #10, have students draw an equal groups model and write a repeated addition sentence, as in #3.” Student book states, “10. Eric is making 4 bookmarks. He needs 3 star stickers for each bookmark. Draw to show how many star stickers Eric needs in all. Write a repeated addition sentence.” Space is provided in all problems for students to draw pictures and equations as needed. Unit outline, Math practices state, “Throughout Unit 2, students model equal groups situations using drawings, arrays, and repeated addition equations. In Lessons 2.3, 2.5, and 2.6, make sure students use problem contexts to create equal groups of the correct size and write repeated addition equations that match their models. Highlight how different models can represent the same situation, and discuss which ones are most helpful in specific contexts. For example, in #3 of Lesson 2.5, Luca arranges muffins in rows and columns, so an array is a natural way to represent the situation. Encourage students to choose models strategically and explain how their models reflect the structure of the problem.”

Indicator 2i

0 / 1

Materials support the intentional development of MP5: Choose tools strategically, for students, in connection to the grade-level content standards, as expected by the mathematical practice standards.

The materials reviewed for Takeoff by IXL for Kindergarten through Grade 2 do not meet expectations for supporting the intentional development of MP5: Use appropriate tools strategically, in connection with grade-level content standards, as expected by the mathematical practice standards.

In Grades 1 and 2, MP5 is identified across the year. Teachers receive guidance in the Teacher’s Guide, and each unit includes a Unit Overview with Math Practices guidance that highlights examples of the Mathematical Practices addressed within that unit. In addition, the Mathematical Practices are identified in the overview of each lesson.

Across Grades 1 and 2, students participate in tasks that support key components of MP5. These include selecting and using appropriate tools and strategies to explore mathematical ideas, solve problems, and communicate their thinking. Students are encouraged to consider the advantages and limitations of various tools such as manipulatives, drawings, measuring devices, and digital technologies, and to choose tools that best support their understanding and reasoning. They have opportunities to use tools flexibly for investigation, calculation, representation, and sense-making. Teachers are guided to support this development by making a variety of tools available, modeling their effective use, and encouraging students to make strategic decisions about when and how to use tools. Teacher materials prompt opportunities for student choice in tool selection, promote discussion around tool effectiveness, and support the comparison of multiple tools or representations. Teachers are also encouraged to highlight how different tools can yield different insights and to help students reflect on their tool choices as part of the problem-solving process.

Examples include: 

  • Grade 1, Unit 2: Addition and subtraction within 10, Lesson 2.9, Instruction: Pick strategies to add and subtract. Students use different strategies and determine which is most efficient for each problem. Teacher notes state, “For #2, discuss the similarities and differences between the three strategies. Highlight the following points: All of the students found that the difference of 9 and 6 is 3. Caden and Jill used a number line to model the problem. Caden's work shows counting back to subtract. Jill's work shows counting on to subtract. Alan's work shows using a related addition fact to subtract. Ask students which way they would prefer to find 9–6 and why. Explain that while different strategies can work, sometimes one way is easier or faster. In this case, 9 and 6 are close together, so counting on to subtract is faster than counting back. Using a known related fact may be easier if you know the right math facts from memory. Emphasize that students can use any method that works for them to get the correct answer. For #3–6, make sure students notice which operation they need to perform in each problem. Throughout the lesson, consider having them trace the operation symbols, + or –, before adding or subtracting. Discuss a variety of ways to solve each problem. Highlight the following strategies for finding the missing values: For #3, students might count back to subtract because they only have to count back 2 times. For #4, students might count on to subtract because 5 and 8 are close to each other. For #5, students might recognize that 4 and 6 make 10 and know the sum from memory, or they might count on to add. For #6, students might use the fact that a number minus itself is always zero, or they might count back to subtract. Also, for #3–6 and throughout the guided practice, allow students to use the most comfortable strategy, but encourage them to push themselves to use mental strategies, such as recalling facts from memory or using known related facts to solve. Solving these problems efficiently will come with practice.” Student book states, “2. Caden, Jill, and Alan each find 9-6. What is the same about their work? What is different?” Cadan and Jill use number lines, while Alan applies a related addition fact. “Add or subtract. 3. 9-2=, 4. 8-5=, 5. 4+6=, 6. 3-3=” Unit outline, Math practices state, “By the end of the unit, students add and subtract within 10 using their choice of tools and strategies. Frequently encourage students to think about which tools are most helpful and why. For example, in #4 from Lesson 2.4, discuss how a number list—or counting back mentally—can be more efficient than a number line. Similarly, in #2 from Lesson 2.9, have students explore three ways to find 9-66: counting back, counting on, and using a related addition fact. Help them see that counting back by a larger number is less efficient than counting on or using related facts. These conversations support students in choosing tools and strategies thoughtfully and flexibly.” 

  • Grade 2, Unit 6: Measuring length, Lesson 6.5, Instruction, Introduction to yardsticks and measuring tapes, students determine the most appropriate measuring tool for each item. Teacher notes state, “For #5, show students a yardstick, a retractable measuring tape, and a flexible measuring tape. Point out the 0, inch, and foot markings on each tool. Discuss some objects that would be easy to measure with each tool. Here are some examples and generalizations that might arise: Yardsticks are useful when measuring objects that aren't very long (roughly 1–6 feet) and are relatively straight and flat (e.g., a plank of wood). Yardsticks are commonly used for sewing and in workshops, but they are less common in everyday use. Retractable measuring tapes are easier to carry around and are useful when measuring longer distances (e.g., the length of a room). Measuring tapes can be easier to use with a partner since it can be hard to get them to lie flat. Measuring tapes are much more common for everyday use. Flexible measuring tapes are useful when measuring around something (e.g., the waist of a pair of pants). Note that even though retractable measuring tapes are a valuable tool, they can be challenging for young students to use. Students are not expected to measure with retractable measuring tapes in this lesson, but you can demonstrate how to use a retractable measuring tape for them.” Student book states, “5. A ruler isn’t the only tool we can use to measure length. Here are some other common tools. What are some objects that are easy to measure with each tool?” Students examine a yardstick and measuring tapes and later select the appropriate tool to measure a range of items. Guided practice: Choose the best measuring tool. Teacher notes state, “For #9–12, have students choose the best tool to measure real-life objects. Then have them measure the objects to the nearest inch, foot, or yard. For #9, have students measure the longest board in the classroom. Look for opportunities to discuss where student answers differ. For example, it's reasonable to measure the height of the chair with a yardstick or a measuring tape.” Student book states, “Circle the tool you will use to measure each object. Then measure. 9. Length of a board in yards. 10. Height of a water bottle in inches, 11. Height of a chair in feet, 12. Distance around your wrist in inches.” Students choose either a ruler, yardstick, or measuring tape for each problem and record the resulting approximate measurement. Unit outline, Math practices state, “In Unit 6, students shift from using inch tiles to using more formal tools—rulers, meter sticks, and measuring tapes—to measure inches, feet, centimeters, and meters. In Lessons 6.2–6.4, model how to use these tools accurately. Prompt students to consider different strategies for measuring greater lengths, such as using a single ruler by marking and shifting it, laying multiple rulers end to end, or using a measuring tape. Encourage students to reflect on the most appropriate tools and methods for different contexts in Lessons 6.5 and 6.9. For instance, they may find a ruler works well for measuring short objects, while a measuring tape is more practical for measuring longer items. (Laying multiple rulers end to end or repeatedly shifting a single ruler might lead to less accurate measurements.)”

Across the year, Kindergarten does not meet the full intent of MP5 because strategic tool use is not intentionally developed across units. While isolated lessons in Unit 6 provide opportunities for students to choose among counters, drawings, and finger models, Lessons 2.13 and 7.5 (along with the majority of lessons throughout the grade) script tool use and do not guide students to make deliberate tool choices, recognize strengths and limitations of tools, or determine whether tools are needed. Teacher materials do not consistently support offering varied tools, demonstrating strategic use, or prompting students to select and justify tools based on the mathematical task. As a result, MP5 is not intentionally developed or connected to the grade-level mathematical content across the full year.

Examples include: 

  • Kindergarten, Unit 2: Numbers to 10, Lesson 2.13 does not meet the full intent of MP5 because students do not choose appropriate tools or strategies, determine whether tools are necessary, compare the usefulness of different tools, or recognize limitations of tools. The lesson directs students to use drawings and the counting sequence to compare numbers. Teacher notes tell students exactly how to represent each comparison, such as “draw dots” and “write and label a sequence,” and instructional steps specify circling and underlining numbers. Students do not select from a variety of tools, do not choose tools strategically, and do not engage in determining whether another tool might be more efficient. The teacher materials do not guide teachers to make a variety of tools available, allow students choice when selecting tools, demonstrate the use of tools effectively (including benefits and limitations), or encourage the use of multiple tools for communication, calculation, investigation, or sense-making. Students follow fixed procedures and representations and are not expected to decide whether to use tools, which tools to use, or how tools support their mathematical understanding.

  • Kindergarten, Unit 7: Classify and sort data, Lesson 7.5 does not meet the full intent of MP5. Students do not choose appropriate tools or strategies, determine whether tools are necessary, recognize limitations of tools, or compare tools. The lesson provides one predetermined tool, the Venn diagram, and students work only with that tool. Teacher instructions tell teachers to “show students the Venn diagram” and “explain that we can show two ways of sorting in one graph called a Venn diagram,” rather than allowing students to choose among tools. Students do not determine how to represent the data because the diagram is already “the Venn diagram showing the same objects and attributes.” The lesson directs students to follow fixed steps such as “sort them into two categories,” “glue the cards to the page,” “count the objects in the circle labeled ‘Animals,’” and “draw lines to show where each shape should go,” but does not expect students to evaluate whether a Venn diagram, table, picture graph, or another representation would better support understanding. Teacher directions focus on describing the tool’s structure, “the circles overlap in the middle” and “the dragonfly and bird are in the overlapping section” and guiding students to place items, rather than prompting tool selection or comparison. Students follow fixed steps such as sorting with cut-out cards, gluing items, reading the provided Venn diagram, counting objects, and drawing lines to place shapes, and are not expected to decide whether to use tools, which tools to use, or how tools support their mathematical understanding.

Indicator 2j

1 / 1

Materials support the intentional development of MP6: Attend to precision, for students, in connection to the grade-level content standards, as expected by the mathematical practice standards.

The materials reviewed for Takeoff by IXL for Kindergarten through Grade 2 meet expectations for supporting the intentional development of MP6: Attend to precision, for students, in connection to the grade-level content standards, as expected by the mathematical practice standards. 

In Grades K-2, MP6 is identified across the year. Teachers receive guidance in the Teacher’s Guide, and each unit includes a Unit Overview with Math Practices guidance that highlights examples of the Mathematical Practices addressed within that unit. In addition, the Mathematical Practices are identified in the overview of each lesson.

Across the grades, students engage in tasks that support key components of MP6. These include formulating clear explanations, using grade-level appropriate vocabulary and conventions, applying definitions and symbols accurately, calculating efficiently, and specifying units of measure. Students are also expected to label tables, graphs, and other representations appropriately, and to use precise language and notation when presenting mathematical ideas. Teachers support this development by modeling accurate mathematical language, ensuring students understand and apply precise definitions, and providing feedback on usage. Lessons include opportunities for students to clarify the meaning of symbols, evaluate the accuracy of their own and others’ work, and refine their communication. Teachers are encouraged to facilitate discussions and structure tasks that promote attention to detail in both reasoning and representation.

Examples include: 

  • Kindergarten, Unit 3: Two-dimensional shapes, Lesson 3.5, Instruction: Describe squares. Students use precise mathematical terminology to identify two-dimensional shapes throughout the unit, including squares in this lesson. Teacher notes state, “For #4, have students look at the squares and discuss what they have in common. Highlight the following attributes of a square: Four straight, equal sides, Four square corners, No curved parts, Being flat (two-dimensional), Being closed, Review that size, color, and fill don't determine whether a shape is a square. Also, turning a shape doesn't make it a different shape. For #5, discuss how both shapes are rectangles because they have four straight sides and four square corners. The first shape is also a square because it has four equal sides. Explain that all squares are special rectangles. Have students circle the square.” In problem 4, students see several squares in different colors, locations, and orientations. In problem 5, students see a square and a rectangle. Later in Lesson 3.7, students use what they have learned about shapes to draw several shapes with the required attributes. Lesson 3.7, Instruction, Build and draw shapes, Teachers notes state, “For #4, have students build a shape with three straight sides. Ask them what shape they made (a triangle). Then have students draw their triangles on the dot grid. Have students share their different triangles and their strategies for building and drawing them. Some students may trace the triangle they built if it fits in the space. Others may draw freehand or with a ruler, or they may use the dots as vertices or to help draw straight lines. For #5, have students describe the attributes of a square. They should recall that squares have four equal sides and four square corners. Have students build a square and then draw it on the dot grid. Discuss how dot grids can help them draw equal sides. (Equal sides go through the same number of dots.) Then discuss how dot grids can be used to draw square corners. (A line that goes side to side through the dots and a line that goes up and down through the dots will form a square corner.) For #6, have students build a shape with 6 vertices and then draw it. Have students share a variety of correct shapes and strategies for building and drawing them.” Unit outline, Math practices state, “Throughout Unit 3, students practice using mathematical language to name and describe two-dimensional shapes. In Lessons 3.1–3.6, they learn to identify circles, triangles, rectangles, squares, and hexagons by attending to defining attributes, such as whether a shape has square corners, how many sides it has, and whether the sides are straight or curved. Encourage students to explain how they know a shape fits a category, and to use terms like sides, vertices, and square corners when supporting their reasoning. Make sure they also understand that attributes like size and color aren't useful for identifying shapes. Lessons 3.7 and 3.8 offer more opportunities to attend to precision as students build, draw, and compare shapes with specific attributes.”

  • Grade 1, Unit 7: Measurement, Lesson 7.3, Instruction, Learn to measure length, students learn precise mathematical terms such as measure and unit and attend to precision when using smaller objects to measure the length of longer objects. Teacher notes state, “For #2, discuss what it means to measure length (to find how long something is). Explain that you can measure an item's length by lining up smaller same-sized items from one end to the other with no gaps or overlaps. The item you use to measure is called a unit. Let students know that today they'll use paper clips as units, but they can use other items as units as long as they're all the same length. Discuss the correct way to measure the length of the paint. Ask students to identify the error in each of the incorrect answer choices. Emphasize that to measure correctly, the paper clips must be lined up from one end of the tube to the other with no gaps or overlaps. Highlight that the paint is about the same length as 3 paper clips, so the paint is about 3 paper clips long. Explain that every measurement should include a number (3) and a unit (paper clips).” Students see four paint tubes, only one of which is measured correctly with 3 paper clips placed end to end beneath the tube. Later in Lesson 7.3, students review another student’s work to identify the mistake the student made while measuring. Guided practice, Measure length, Teacher notes state, “For #7, make sure students understand that John's measurement is incorrect because the keys aren't all turned the same way. They should see that this is problematic because the key isn't the same length on all sides. Relate this to measuring with paper clips, and highlight that all the paper clips need to be turned the same way. Next, give each student a copy of Measure with paper clips. Have students measure the length or height of each item, as they did in #3–6. As students work, make sure they are lining up the paper clips without gaps or overlaps.” Students see a picture of a pair of scissors measured with four keys, but the keys are not placed end to end beneath the scissors. Unit outline, Math practices state, “Throughout Unit 7, students develop precision in their language, tools, and representations while working with measurement, time, and money. When introducing new vocabulary—for example, comparison words such as shorter, longer, shortest, and longest (Lesson 7.1) or time expressions like o'clock (Lesson 7.5) and half past (Lesson 7.7)—model the terms clearly and encourage students to use them in conversation. Students learn that measuring length accurately requires them to line up units carefully, without gaps or overlaps. Use hands-on measurement activities to help them practice this skill, and discuss common measuring mistakes, like the ones shown in #7 from Lesson 7.3 and #4 from Lesson 7.4. The unit concludes with students identifying coins and representing their values using the cent symbol (Lesson 7.8). Emphasize how to correctly read and write money amounts to support clear, precise communication.”

Grade 2, Unit 6: Measuring length, Lesson 6.1, Instruction, Warm up, students measure with precision to find accurate solutions to real-world problems. Teacher notes state, “For #1, have students identify the error and discuss how to correctly measure the fork. (David should have lined up his paper clips end to end with no gaps or overlaps in order to get the most accurate measurement.)” Student book states, “1. David said this fork is 4 paper clips long. What mistake did he make? How could he fix it?” The paper clips are not placed end-to-end in the picture. Introduction to inch tiles, Teacher notes state, “For #4–5, have students measure the objects using their inch tiles. Make sure students line the tiles up with one end of the objects and make sure there are no gaps or overlaps between the tiles.” Student book states, “How long is each object? Use inch tiles to measure.” Students see a chopstick in problem 4 that is six inches long, and a piece of pasta in problem 5 that is two inches long. Unit outline, Math practices state, “Students' precision with measuring tools in Unit 6 directly affects their accuracy. In Lesson 6.1, when using inch tiles, emphasize the importance of placing them end to end without gaps or overlaps. As students transition to using rulers (Lessons 6.2, 6.3, and 6.8), model how to align the zero mark with the end of an object and how to read its length to the nearest whole unit. Regardless of the tool, prompt students to be mindful of how the measurement marks align with the object to ensure accurate measurements. Throughout the unit, reinforce the importance of recording measurements with correct units. Remind students that omitting units makes a measurement's meaning unclear and that using incorrect units can lead others to misinterpret an object's size. Being precise during both measurement and communication helps ensure that their results are understood by others.”

Indicator 2k

1 / 1

Materials support the intentional development of MP7: Look for and make use of structure, for students, in connection to the grade-level content standards, as expected by the mathematical practice standards.

The materials reviewed for Takeoff by IXL for Kindergarten through Grade 2 meet expectations for supporting the intentional development of MP7: Look for and make use of structure, for students, in connection to the grade-level content standards, as expected by the mathematical practice standards. 

In Grades K-2, MP7 is identified across the year. Teachers receive guidance in the Teacher’s Guide, and each unit includes a Unit Overview with Math Practices guidance that highlights examples of the Mathematical Practices addressed within that unit. In addition, the Mathematical Practices are identified in the overview of each lesson.

Across the grades, students engage in tasks that support key components of MP7. These include looking for and describing patterns, identifying structure within mathematical representations, and decomposing complex problems into simpler, more manageable parts. Students are encouraged to analyze problems for underlying structure and to consider multiple solution strategies. They make generalizations based on repeated reasoning and use those generalizations to solve problems efficiently. Teachers support this development by selecting tasks that highlight mathematical structure and prompting students to attend to and describe patterns they notice. Lessons provide opportunities for students to compare approaches, justify their reasoning, and reflect on how structure helps deepen their understanding. Teachers are encouraged to facilitate discussions and structure lessons in ways that promote the recognition and use of patterns and structure in problem-solving.

Examples include: 

  • Kindergarten, Unit 6: Addition and subtraction, Lesson 6.10, Instruction: Learn about related addition facts. Students look for patterns and structure as they use counting to solve addition problems. They also notice that the order of the addends does not change the sum. Teacher notes state, “For #1, guide students to make a linked-cube model that matches the top picture and have them write the corresponding addition sentence: 2+1=3. Then have students flip their model to match the bottom picture and write the reverse addition fact: 1+2=3. Point out that flipping the model didn't change its size. Similarly, changing the order of 1 and 2 didn't change the total. Discuss how the addition sentences are similar (they use the same numbers and 3 is the sum of both) and how they are different (the numbers are added in a different order). Explain that these are called related addition facts.” Students see three connecting cubes and space to write two equations for the same number of cubes. Instruction, Learn about related addition and subtraction facts. Teacher notes state, “For #3, have students look at the top picture as you read the first part of the story: There are 3 horses standing together. Then 1 more horse joins. How many horses are there now? Have students write an addition sentence that matches the story. Then have them look at the bottom picture as you continue the story: There are 4 horses together. Then 1 horse runs away. How many horses stay? Discuss how the first and second parts of the story are related. Surface these points: Both parts include a total of 4 horses. In the first part, 1 horse joins. In the second part, that same horse leaves. Have students write a subtraction sentence that matches the second part of the story, and discuss how the two number sentences are related. Emphasize that they use the same three numbers and that adding 1 and taking 1 away are opposites. Explain that this is another example of related facts.” Students see a picture of three horses in a field with one running toward them and another picture of three horses in the field with one running away. Unit outline, Math practices state, “Students rely on the structure of our number system to add and subtract efficiently in Unit 6. Show them how the counting sequence supports quicker addition and subtraction strategies in Lessons 6.3 and 6.9—for example, counting on from the larger number instead of counting the total when one addend is small. Students can apply a similar principle as they decompose numbers in Lessons 6.4–6.6. Point out that once they break apart numbers in one way, they can adjust each part by one to find new decompositions. Throughout the unit, highlight how recognizing the structure of numbers leads to efficient problem solving. Students also begin to see the structure in the relationship between addition and subtraction. In Lesson 6.10, emphasize that related facts use the same three numbers. While students aren't expected to use related facts to add and subtract yet, understanding fact family relationships lays a foundation for fluency in first grade.”

  • Grade 1, Unit 2: Addition and subtraction within 10, Lesson 2.5, Instruction: Relate addition and subtraction. Students look for patterns and structure in fact families to solve addition and subtraction problems within 10. Teacher notes state, “For #2, explain that a set of four related addition and subtraction sentences makes a fact family, just like related people make a family. Have students look again at the number sentences in #1 and ask them what they notice about them. Make sure that students understand what it means to notice something. Highlight the following ways the number sentences are related: All four number sentences use the same three numbers. The addition sentences show that you can add in any order. (This is a review from Lesson 2.1.) The sum of the addition sentences is the same as the first number in the subtraction sentences. It is also the largest number. Point out that students could have used the same cube train to show all four sentences of the fact family. Consider having some students show one of their cube trains from #1 and demonstrate how it shows the fact family. For #4, have students complete the model by finding the sum. Remind students that they can think of 4 and 5 as the two parts of the whole, 9. Then have students use the strip model to write the four number sentences in the fact family. Highlight the following points: The addition sentences describe what happens when you put the parts together. The subtraction sentences describe what happens when you take one of the parts away from the whole. Explain that when you know one fact, you can find all its related facts because they will use the same three numbers. For #6–7, have students complete the related number sentence using the given fact. Encourage them to use the part/whole relationships between the numbers in the given fact to determine the missing number in the related fact. Explain that you can solve some addition or subtraction problems more quickly by starting with a related fact that you know or can easily find.” Student book states, “2. The number sentences above form a fact family. What do you notice about them? 4. Complete the model.” Students see a representation of 4 plus 5 equaling 9 and space to complete the four problems in the fact family. “Complete each related fact. 10-4=6, 6+4=____. 7. 4+4=8, 8-4=____” Unit outline, Math practices state, “Students make use of structure as they develop efficient strategies for adding and subtracting within 10. Reinforce the importance of the number sequence in counting on (Lesson 2.2) and counting back (Lesson 2.4). Use tools such as number lines or number lists to make this structure visible—model how one addend is the starting point, the second addend is the number of jumps (or numbers listed), and the sum is the landing point (or final number). Use fact families (Lesson 2.5) to explicitly draw students' attention to the inverse relationship between addition and subtraction. Highlight how knowing one fact can help uncover others within the same family. Support students in applying this understanding to find missing addends (Lesson 2.3) and to subtract by counting on (Lesson 2.6). Encourage them to consider the numbers in a problem when choosing between counting on or counting back to subtract. In Lesson 2.8, introduce and model number pairs that make 10. Emphasize 10 as a natural benchmark for simplifying calculations. Because 10 is central to our place value system and the structure of teen numbers, the making 10 strategy will become especially useful in students' continued work with addition and subtraction.”

Grade 2, Unit 4: Subtraction within 100, Lesson 4.7, Instruction: Learning to model subtraction with regrouping. Students use the structure of place value to solve subtraction problems within 100. Teacher notes state, “For #2, have students model the problem using place value blocks. Then demonstrate how to draw a place value sketch to show the work you did with the place value blocks. Consider using two different colors in your sketch and providing each student with two different colored pencils to use in their own sketches. Help students see that 2 tens and 6 ones remain in the sketch. Students may be tempted to say that there are 3 tens remaining since only 2 tens were crossed out initially. Be sure to point out that another ten was used when we regrouped it into 10 ones. For #3, have students model the problem using place value blocks, then draw a place value sketch to show their work, as they did in #2. Again, help students to see that there are 3 tens and 4 ones remaining, so the answer is 34. For #5, discuss Ann's method. She first determined if she needed to regroup by looking at the ones. Since there are more ones in 27 than 62, Ann regrouped one of the tens from 62 into 10 ones before she started subtracting. Then she subtracted tens from tens and ones from ones. Guide students to use Ann's way to find 76-4949. Since there are more ones in 49 than there are in 76, you will need to regroup. Throughout, encourage students to evaluate the reasonableness of their results in each step. For example, it makes sense that 7 tens and 6 ones can be regrouped as 6 tens and 16 ones because 60+16=76.” Student book states, “2. Find 51-25. Use place value blocks to solve. Draw a place value sketch to show your work. There are ____ tens and ____ ones left over. 51/25=. 3. Find 52-18. Use place value blocks to solve. Draw a place value sketch to show your work. 52-12=. 5. Ann is trying to find 62-47. She has an idea for a faster way to record her work. Ann: First, I can check if I need to regroup. Then I can regroup before I start subtracting. Use Ann’s way to find 76-49.” Students see that Ann has set up a place-value problem that shows taking one ten and adding ten ones to the ones place. Unit outline, Math practices state, “Throughout Unit 4, students rely on the structure of the base-ten number system to understand subtraction. They break numbers into tens and ones (Lessons 4.2 and 4.6), subtract with place value blocks (Lessons 4.7 and 4.8), and organize work in place value charts (Lesson 4.8). Highlight how these methods are supported by the structure of the base-ten system. They all rely on subtracting like units—tens from tens and ones from ones—whether with models, written work, or mental math. Students also learn strategies for subtraction that leverage the relationship between addition and subtraction. This includes compensation in Lesson 4.3 and counting on to subtract in Lesson 4.4. Encourage students to use addition to gain confidence in their answers. For example, even if counting on to subtract isn't a student's preferred strategy, they can use it to check the answer they found with another strategy.”

Indicator 2l

0 / 1

Materials support the intentional development of MP8: Look for and express regularity in repeated reasoning, for students, in connection to the grade-level content standards, as expected by the mathematical practice standards.

The materials reviewed for Takeoff by IXL for Kindergarten through Grade 2 do not meet expectations for supporting the intentional development of MP8: Look for and express regularity in repeated reasoning, for students, in connection to the grade-level content standards, as expected by the mathematical practice standards. 

In Grade 1, MP8 is identified across the year. Teachers receive guidance in the Teacher’s Guide, and each unit includes a Unit Overview with Math Practices guidance that highlights examples of the Mathematical Practices addressed within that unit. In addition, the Mathematical Practices are identified in the overview of each lesson.

Across Grade 1, students engage in tasks that support key components of MP8. These include notice and use repeated reasoning to make sense of problems, recognize patterns, and develop efficient, mathematically sound strategies. Students are encouraged to create, describe, and explain general methods, formulas, or processes based on patterns they identify. Lessons provide opportunities for students to evaluate the reasonableness of their answers and refine their approaches through discussion and reflection. Teachers support this development by structuring tasks that highlight repeated reasoning, prompting students to make generalizations, and guiding them to build conceptual understanding, distinct from relying on memorized tricks. Instructional guidance also encourages teachers to model and elicit strategies that build toward formal algorithms or representations through consistent reasoning.

Examples include: 

  • Grade 1, Unit 11: Addition and subtraction within 100, Lesson 11.1, Instruction, Learn to add and subtract 10, students use repeated reasoning to find patterns when adding or subtracting 10 from a number. Teacher notes state, “For #2, have students show 25 with place value blocks. Then have them add 10 by adding a ten rod and record the result. Ask students what they observe. Surface that the number of tens in the sum is 1 more than in the starting number, but the number of ones stayed the same. Be sure to connect this observation back to the model. (Adding a ten rod increases the number of tens by 1 but doesn't change the number of ones.) Then have students start at 25 again and subtract 10 by removing a ten rod. This time, students should notice that the number of tens in the difference is 1 less than in the starting number. Again, the number of ones remains the same. Have students repeat this process for the other numbers. Each time they add and subtract 10, have them confirm the patterns they observed for 25 are true. Highlight that the patterns here are the same as the patterns in #1. This is because adding 10 to a number is the same as finding 10 more, and subtracting 10 is the same as finding 10 less. For #3, encourage students to apply the patterns they discussed in #1–2 to add or subtract 10. Point out that some equations use addition and some use subtraction, so students need to look closely at each operation symbol. Also, remind them they can add in either order (e.g., they can think about 10+79 as 79+10 if that's easier).” Student book states, “2. Show each number with place value blocks. Then add and subtract 10. 3. Add or subtract 10. 32+10=, 54-10=, 91-10=, 10+79=” Unit outline, Math practices state, “In Unit 11, students develop strategies for adding and subtracting within 100 by recognizing patterns in their calculations. In Lesson 11.1, they connect adding or subtracting 10 to changes in the tens place. Repeated practice helps them see that adding 10 increases the tens digit by 1, while subtracting 10 decreases it by 1. By Lesson 11.8, students begin to see that they can apply similar reasoning to solve two-digit addition problems by adding tens and ones separately. Though mental calculations, especially with regrouping, are not expected, these patterns will support an understanding of the standard algorithm in later grades.”

Across Kindergarten and Grade 2, the lessons do not meet the full intent of MP8 because students do not use repeated calculations to understand algorithms and make generalizations, do not create or describe efficient, mathematically sound shortcuts, and do not evaluate the reasonableness of their thinking. The tasks guide students through fixed procedures such as modeling, counting, shading equal groups, measuring, or adding tens and hundreds. Teacher materials provide the patterns and conclusions, rather than prompting students to use repeated reasoning as a tool or to generalize from several examples. Lessons do not provide situations in which students can use a strategy to develop understanding of a concept, do not provide a variety of examples that explicitly focus on patterns and repeated reasoning, and do not prompt students to make generalizations.

Examples include: 

  • Kindergarten, Unit 6: Addition and subtraction, Lesson 6.13 does not meet the full intent of MP8 because students do not use repeated calculations to develop general methods, create mathematically sound shortcuts, evaluate the reasonableness of their answers, or make generalizations. The tasks require students to model subtracting all or subtracting zero using pictures, linked cubes, or acting out stories, and then record the result. Students complete individual equations such as “3-3,” “4+0,” and “2-0” without using repeated reasoning to understand a process or create a method. Students follow a fixed sequence to model, count, and write the number, and are not expected to justify a general property. The teacher materials direct students to notice that “the answer to these types of problems is always 0,” that “adding 0 doesn’t change a number,” and that “subtracting 0 doesn’t change a number,” but they do not provide varied examples that focus on repeated reasoning or prompt students to make generalizations.

  • Kindergarten, Unit 8: Numbers to 20, Lessons 8.7 and 8.8 do not meet the full intent of MP8 because the teacher materials do not engage students in using repeated calculations to develop general methods, create efficient shortcuts, evaluate the reasonableness of their answers, or form generalizations. The teacher notes direct students to count dots, “point to the full ten frame, say ‘ten,’ and then continue counting the dots on the second ten frame,” and to “model the problem by placing counters on ten frames.” Students follow counting-on steps and complete sentences such as “10 and 5 more is 15” and “10 plus four equals fourteen.” The materials prompt students to notice that “a full ten frame always represents 10” and that “the number of ones and the second digit of the teen number are always the same,” but they do not provide repeated examples that support students in constructing a general method or explaining why the pattern holds. Students complete tasks by counting, modeling with ten frames, and filling in addition sentences, but the lessons do not guide them to analyze repeated reasoning or apply a general process beyond the provided steps.

  • Kindergarten, Unit 9: Numbers to 100, Lesson 9.5 does not meet the full intent of MP8 because the lesson does not engage students in repeated reasoning to develop general methods, create efficient shortcuts, or make generalizations based on patterns. The teacher materials direct students to “count by 10s to find the total number” and to notice that numbers such as 10, 20, and 30 “are all stacked on top of each other” and “end in 0.” Students skip count by 10s as they point to numbers on trays, a number chart, and collections of objects. In #3, the teacher highlights that “each number is 10 more than the number before it” and has students count aloud from 10 to 100. Across the lesson, students follow teacher-directed counting sequences, color numbers on the chart, and practice skip counting to identify totals. Students do not use repeated calculations to construct a general method, describe or explain a process, or evaluate the reasonableness of their thinking. The teacher materials do not prompt students to analyze repeated examples, compare strategies, or make generalizations about counting by tens; instead, they guide students through the pattern and tell them how to count.

  • Grade 2, Unit 2: Equal groups, Lesson 2.2 does not meet the full intent of MP8 because the lesson does not engage students in using repeated calculations to understand algorithms, make generalizations, or create efficient, mathematically sound shortcuts. Students add doubles in #1–4 and shade equal rows in #6–7, but these tasks focus on identifying the sums of doubles and showing equal groups. The teacher notes state that “the sums in #1–4 are all even” and that students “should notice that both numbers are even because they make equal groups.” In #8–10, students shade squares, classify numbers as even or odd, and write doubles or near-doubles facts such as “9=4+4+1” and “4=2+2.” The materials guide students to follow steps, shade, count, label, and write an addition sentence, and the teacher notes explain that “you can write a doubles fact for an even number” and “cannot write a doubles fact for an odd number.” The lesson does not provide varied examples that focus on repeated reasoning, prompt students to form generalizations about even and odd numbers, or ask students to evaluate the reasonableness of their thinking or use repeated reasoning as a tool.

  • Grade 2, Unit 6: Measuring length, Lesson 6.6 does not meet the full intent of MP8 because the lesson does not engage students in using repeated reasoning to develop general methods, create efficient strategies, or form generalizations about measurement. Students repeatedly measure objects in inches and feet in Problems #2–5 and record the measurements, but the teacher materials state for #6 that “students should notice that it took more inches than feet to measure the length of each object” and then explain that “inches are smaller than feet, so it will always take more inches than feet to span the same length.” In #7, students fill in blanks using “more” or “fewer,” and the materials summarize the relationship rather than prompting students to analyze repeated cases or use repeated reasoning as a tool. Across the lesson, students follow a sequence of measuring, recording, and comparing values, and the materials do not provide varied examples or teacher prompts that support students in developing general strategies or expressing rules based on repeated reasoning.

  • Grade 2, Unit 9: Addition and subtraction within 1,000, Lesson 9.1 does not meet the full intent of MP8 because students do not use repeated calculations to develop general methods, create efficient, mathematically sound shortcuts, evaluate the reasonableness of their answers and thinking, or make generalizations. In this lesson, students model numbers with place value blocks in #4 and add 10 or 100 by adding a ten rod or a hundred flat. The teacher materials state that “adding 10 changes the digit in the tens place” and that “the hundreds digit increases by 1” when adding 100, and they explain the regrouping that occurs when adding 10 to 591. Students complete fixed steps, model the number, add a ten or hundred, record the new number, and then apply the same pattern in #5–10 by increasing the tens or hundreds digit. The materials do not provide a sequence of varied examples that focus on repeated reasoning or prompt students to create or describe a general formula, process, or method, and students are not asked to use repeated reasoning as a tool to justify or generalize these place-value patterns.