1st Grade - Gateway 1
Back to 1st Grade Overview
Note on review tool versions
See the series overview page to confirm the review tool version used to create this report.
- Our current review tool version is 2.0. Learn more
- Reports conducted using earlier review tools (v1.0 and v1.5) contain valuable insights but may not fully align with our current instructional priorities. Read our guide to using earlier reports and review tools
Loading navigation...
Standards and Research-Based Practices
Alignment to Standards and Research-Based Practices for Foundational Skills InstructionGateway 1 - Partially Meets Expectations | 75% |
|---|---|
Criterion 1.1: Print Concepts and Letter Recognition (Alphabet Knowledge) | 1 / 4 |
Criterion 1.2: Phonological Awareness | 8 / 12 |
Criterion 1.3: Phonics | 18 / 20 |
Criterion 1.4: Word Recognition and Word Analysis | 8 / 8 |
Criterion 1.5: Decoding Accuracy, Decoding Automaticity and Fluency | 10 / 16 |
Pathways to Reading Grade 1 materials reviewed partially meet the criteria for alignment to standards and research-based practices for foundational skills instruction. Materials provide students with letter writing opportunities; however, directions for correct letter formation are not provided.
Materials partially meet the criteria for materials provide instructional support for general concepts of print and connect learning of print concepts to books and provide cumulative review of print concepts, letter identification, and printing letters.
Materials meet the criteria for materials have frequent opportunities for students to engage in phonological awareness activities; however, instruction in distinguishing vowel sounds is limited. When distinguishing vowel sounds, practice opportunities provided in the materials focus on written words rather than spoken words. Opportunities addressing identification of long or short vowels in words are presented through written words. Students have opportunities to segment single syllable words; however graphemes are added after each phoneme.
Materials meet the criteria for materials emphasize explicit phonics instruction through systematic and repeated modeling. Materials include explicit instruction of all grade-level phonics standards through the use of the "Large Group and Small Group Manuals;" however, reading of complete words is limited to calling on students during "Large Group" instruction which may not provide opportunities for all students to read complete words. Students have frequent practice opportunities to build/manipulate/spell and encode grade-level phonics, including common and newly-taught sound and sound patterns. Materials provide explicit systematic teacher modeling and instruction for encoding of phonics from sounds to letters and words in writing tasks. Materials provide systematic instruction and opportunities for students to practice high-frequency words through "Read Word and Spelling" activities. Students are provided with 200 sight words to study over the course of the school year. Materials provide frequent practice opportunities to read and write high-frequency words in context. Explicit instruction in word analysis is provided with sample dialogue. Students have frequent opportunities to analyze word endings and syllables. Materials provide students with frequent opportunities to practice automaticity and accuracy with reading single words.
Materials partially meet the criteria for instructional opportunities are built into the materials for systematic, evidence-based, explicit instruction in fluency. Explicit instruction in rate is not included in the materials.
Materials partially meet the criteria for materials provide teacher guidance to support students as they confirm or self-correct errors and emphasize reading for purpose and understanding. On-level texts included with the program are limited to weekly spelling paragraphs. While grade-level books are referenced in the materials, the books are not included in the program.
Criterion 1.1: Print Concepts and Letter Recognition (Alphabet Knowledge)
This criterion is non-negotiable. Materials must achieve a specified minimum score in this criterion to advance to the next gateway.
Materials and instruction provide embedded support with general concepts of print, and systematic and explicit instruction and practice for letter recognition.
Pathways to Reading Grade 1 materials provide students with letter writing opportunities; however, directions for correct letter formation are not provided. Materials partially meet the criteria for materials provide instructional support for general concepts of print and connect learning of print concepts to books and provide cumulative review of print concepts, letter identification, and printing letters.
Indicator 1a
Letter Identification
Indicator 1a.iv
Materials provide explicit instruction to print and to practice forming the 26 letters (uppercase and lowercase).(K-1)
The materials reviewed for Grade 1 do not meet the criteria for materials provide explicit instruction to print and to practice the 26 letters (uppercase and lowercase).
In the Pathways to Reading, "Large Group Manual," the "Quarterly Literacy Plan" includes a "Handwriting" segment and indicates that letter formation, directionality, and spacing will be taught for the first two quarters; however, materials do not provide explicit instruction in the manuals. The materials provide students with letter writing opportunities; however, directions for correct letter formation are not provided.
Materials do not include frequent opportunities for students to practice forming all of the 26 letters (uppercase and lowercase):
- Explicit directions for forming all 26 letters are not provided.
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 2, the "Quarterly Overview" lists "Handwriting" as “15-20 minutes (three times a week), Alternate with PTR large group.” Materials do not include resources or lesson plans for teaching handwriting. In the second quarter, the recommended time for handwriting is 15 minutes daily. "Handwriting" is not listed in the third or fourth quarter divisions of instructional time.
Materials include limited opportunities for students to practice forming letters using multimodal and/or multisensory methods:
- In the Small Group Folder, page 7, the teacher introduces "Shadow Writing" to assist with imagining and learning "Vowel Town" spelling. The teacher tells students, “With your finger shadow write the letter -o on the desk (or tabletop). Say the name of the letter as you write it. That will help you remember what you write even better.” Materials do not provide directions for how to form letters.
- In the Pathways to "Spelling Manual," page 11, students “finger spell” words to enhance their visual memory of the weekly spelling words.
Indicator 1b
Materials provide instructional support for general concepts of print and connect learning of print concepts to books (K-1) and provide cumulative review of print concepts, letter identification, and printing letters. (K-early Grade 1)
The materials reviewed for Pathways to Reading Grade 1 partially meet the criteria for materials provide instructional support for general concepts of print and connect learning of print concepts to books (K-1), and provide cumulative review of print concepts, letter identification, and printing letters (K-early Grade 1).
The Grade 1 materials provide some instructional support for general concepts of print. Although decodable books and leveled books from outside sources are recommended, specific lessons providing a connection between books and print concepts are not provided. Students periodically review identification of the letters of the alphabet. Instruction in printing letters is not included in the materials; therefore, review is not evident. Ending punctuation is taught. However, students learn about using correct punctuation to match the intended meaning of the sentence rather than punctuation as a feature to distinguish a sentence within connected text. The materials provide cumulative reviews of letter identification, especially at the beginning of the year; however, they do not provide cumulative reviews of print concepts or printing letters.
Materials include limited explicit instruction for all students about the organization of print concepts (e.g., recognize features of a sentence):
- Students have limited opportunities to recognize the distinguishing features of a sentence (e.g., first word, capitalization, ending punctuation):
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 182, the teacher writes four sentences on the board: “Look at this first sentence. I like dogs. Who is sitting up straight and tall with their eyes up here and can tell us what we call this dot at the end? Tell the students it’s a period and it means we just said something, we made a statement.” The lesson continues with question marks and exclamation points.
Materials include frequent, adequate lessons, tasks, and questions for all students about the organization of print concepts (e.g., recognize features of a sentence). For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Small Group Manual," pages 181-183, the lesson focuses on ending punctuation. Students practice reading text with these various marks. “I’m going to put some punctuation marks at the end of our alphabet lines. Let’s have some fun and read the row of letters with that mark at the end. For example, what if I put a question mark at the end of this first row of letters? I would read it this way… a, b, c, d? I made my voice go up at the end.” The teacher is then instructed to, “Place various marks at the end of the a, b, c, d row and let students practice. Next, place the period, ! and ? at the end of the first three rows. On the fourth row place a comma after each letter with a period at the end. Have students practice with each other.”
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 185, students are questioned about the effect of punctuation marks when reading. Students select the emotion pop stick to correspond to the emotion conveyed by the example sentences.
- In the "Pathways to Spelling Manual," page 165, the materials reference PowerPoint 4. Slide 2 of PowerPoint 4 provides the sentence, “The work was hard for her.” which gives students two tasks. Students first “Check punctuation. Beginning and end of sentence.” The second task is to “Check phrases. Say slowly to check the spelling.”
Materials do not include a variety of physical books (teacher-guided, such as big books) that are suitable for the teaching of print concepts. No books are included in the materials.
Materials do not include sufficient and explicit instruction about the organization of print concepts (e.g., recognize features of a sentence) in the context of a book. Students practice punctuation using sentence strips.
Materials do not include opportunities for students to engage in authentic practice using print concepts in the context of student books. Student books are not included in the program:
- In the Small Group Folder, pages 3-4, student books that are recommended in Grade 1 include Power Readers, Saxon, High Noon Info-Mag, and High Noon Magic Belt Series. The recommended books are aligned to the "Read in Context" lessons for small group instruction.
Materials contain limited periodic cumulative review opportunities during which the teacher reminds students about previously learned grade-level print concepts, and letter identification. Materials do not contain periodic cumulative review of letter formation:
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 77, teachers are instructed to use the consonant review activities as necessary. The lesson objective is that “Students can give the letter name, letter sound and speech action for the newest set of consonants: m, n, ng, and l, r.” The teacher is told to “Play the High-Low or Wild Horses game or another favorite game for review purposes. Determine if this type of practice is needed. "Segment and Write" teaches students to use sound/letter associations within the context of a word and may be sufficient practice.”
Materials include students’ practice of previously learned letter identification:
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 10, teachers are provided with instructions for using the "ABC Point and Sing" routine. Teachers are told to use the chart in the following three situations, “1. Ask a student to find a letter in a group of letters. If the student is not able to identify the letter have him/her sing to it on the ABC chart. 2. Ask a student for the name of a letter. If the student doesn’t know the name of the letter have him/her sing to it on the ABC chart. 3. Assist a group of delayed students to learn letter names.”
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 45, students perform the "ABC Point and Sing" activity with the alphabet chart and review specific letter/sounds for p, b, t, d, c, k, g, f, v, and th.
Criterion 1.2: Phonological Awareness
Materials emphasize explicit, systematic instruction of research-based and/or evidence-based phonological awareness.
Pathways to Reading Grade 1 meet the criteria for materials have frequent opportunities for students to engage in phonological awareness activities; however, instruction in distinguishing vowel sounds is limited. When distinguishing vowel sounds, practice opportunities provided in the materials focus on written words rather than spoken words. Opportunities addressing identification of long or short vowels in words are presented through written words. Students have opportunities to segment single syllable words; however graphemes are added after each phoneme.
Indicator 1c
Materials have frequent opportunities for students to engage in phonological awareness activities during Kindergarten and early Grade 1.
The materials reviewed for Pathways to Reading Grade 1 meet the criteria for materials have frequent opportunities for students to engage in phonological awareness activities through Kindergarten and early Grade 1.
The "Flip and Assist" manual provides the teacher with a variety of phonological awareness activities to use with students. "Flip and Assist" activities are incorporated throughout the "Small Group and Large Group Manuals." "Phonological Awareness" activities located in the "Flip and Assist Manual," and the "Advanced Oral PA Development Manual" provide students with frequent opportunities in phonological awareness practice in both small and whole group activities with frequency.
Materials include a variety of activities for phonological awareness. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Small Group Manual," page vi, the Table of Contents provides a list of multisyllable lessons which include: "Count and Identify Syllables (using fingers in a palm to count syllables)."
- In "Advanced Oral PA Development," Lesson 1," Two Syllable Compound Words Blend," the routine is as follows:
- "Teacher: Say...hot (R = response) Say dog (R).
- Teacher: Put hot and dog together. The new word is___.”
- In "Advanced Oral PA Development," Lesson 22, "Substitute 2nd C in cCvc Word," the following routine follows:
- "Teacher: Say (slip) (R).
- Teacher: Say (slip), but change the (l) to (k). What’s the new word?"
- In the "Flip and Assist Manual," page 5, the "Freeze and Match" activity provides students practice repeating vowel sounds after the teacher. For example, “Now I’ll say the next 3: /ae/, /a/, /u/. (Hand under chin.) You say them.”
There are daily opportunities for students to practice phonological awareness. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 43, students complete the "Freeze and Match" activity. “Now let’s freeze and match in sets. I’ll say a set of sounds and you say them. I’ll say them first. Are you ready? (Place your hand under your chin and say:) /ee/, /i/, /e/. You say them. (R)"
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 30, "Advanced Oral PA Development" is described for all 4 levels of lesson plans. “Provide Advanced Oral PA development during various times of the day- 5 minutes for each small group. Follow Advanced Oral PA booklet directions.”
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 52, "Vowel Practice," students complete the "Freeze and Match" activity. “Let’s Freeze and Match. I’ll say the first smile sound. I’ll freeze my mouth in that shape, you say the sound after me and freeze your mouth. Ready? Eyes up here.” Students continue to "Freeze and Match" with numerous vowel sounds including /ee/, /i/, /e/, /ae/, /a/, and /u/.
- In the "Small Group Folder," "Start Up" page 2, the materials state, "Advanced Oral PA is to be used to practice on Days 1-6 either in small group or at another time for a minimum of five minutes."
Indicator 1d
Materials provide explicit instruction in phonological awareness through systematic modeling across the K-1 grade band.
The materials reviewed for Pathways to Reading Grade 1 partially meet the criteria for materials provide explicit instruction in phonological awareness through systematic modeling across the K-1 grade band.
Grade 1 materials provide activities with explicit instruction for phonological awareness activities in the "Large Group Manual," the "Flip and Assist Manual," and the "Advanced Oral PA Development Manual." Teacher instructions include a script that the teacher can read aloud to students to model new activities. The teacher is provided with examples of each skill and word lists to use when completing activities with students. However, instruction in distinguishing vowel sounds is limited. When distinguishing vowel sounds, practice opportunities provided in the materials focus on written words rather than spoken words.
Materials provide the teacher with systematic, explicit modeling for instruction in syllables, sounds (phonemes), and spoken words. For example, the following is noted:
- Materials include explicit instruction for students to distinguish long from short vowel sounds in spoken single-syllable words. Practice distinguishing between short and long vowel sounds could only be found in association with written words, for example, the following is noted:
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 89, during the "Segment and Write" lesson, students give all of the sounds they hear in the word gate. When they arrive at the vowel sound, if they give the sound /a/, the teacher is to tell them to review "Vowel Town" to spot the correct way to spell the sound if it is a long vowel.
- In the "Flip and Assist Manual," page 12, “I’m going to show you words. I don’t need you to read the word to me. I want you to spot the vowel and say its sound as quickly as you can. Be careful because many vowel sounds are spelled with two letters. Ready?”
- In the Pathways to Reading Video “Old Word/New Word,” the teacher models changing the word Jake into Jack.
- Materials include explicit instruction for students to orally produce single-syllable words by blending sounds (phonemes), including consonant blends:
- In the "Advanced Oral PA Development Manual," page 58, the teacher is given a dialogue which asks students to say cub and count the sounds in the word. The teacher asks students to add /l/ after the /k/ sound. Finally, the teacher models, “The new word is…(say the slowly as run finger under squares) /kl...u...b/.”
- In the Pathways to Reading Video "Word Reading Lists Modeled with a First Grader," when the student is struggling with a word, the teacher asks, “Can you squeeze those sounds together?”
- Materials include explicit instruction for students to isolate and pronounce initial, medial vowel, and final sounds (phonemes) in spoken single-syllable words:
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 31, during the "Segment and Write" lesson the teacher is prompted to state, “We are going to practice finding the little sounds in words. Scientists call these sounds phonemes. For example, the word bag has 3 sounds /b/ /a/ /g/, /bag/.”
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 89, during the "Segment and Write" lesson for gate, the teacher is to, “Call a sound leader to the board. There are three sounds in the word gate. (Sound leader’s name) what’s the first sound in gate?” The teacher is to continue this process until all of the sounds are identified. After each sound, the teacher helps students spell the sound.
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 81, the "Segment and Write" lesson focuses on the word path. “Think about the word path. (Student’s name) there are three sounds in the word path. What’s the first sound in path? (R)" Students continue to identify the remaining two sounds in the word path.
- Materials include explicit instruction for students to segment spoken single-syllable words into their complete sequence of individual sounds (phonemes):
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 93, the teacher is given instructions for helping students segment the word gate. “T: (Student name), be our sound leader. There are three sounds in the word gate. What’s the first sound in gate? St: /g/ T: What’s the next sound in the word gate? (R) T: How do we spell the /ae/ sound? (R) T: Is /ae/ one sound or two sounds? (R) T: So will a-e need two sound dots or one? (R) (Students place -a-e on one sound dot.) T: What’s the last sound? (R) T: Spell it.”
- In the "Flip and Assist Manual," page 14, during "Segment and Write" the teacher is prompted to ask, “How many sounds do you think are in the word (bit)? Show me with your fingers. There are three sounds in the word (bit). (Student name) what’s the (first) sound?” The teacher continues asking all of the sounds in the word.
- In the "Flip and Assist Manual," page 20, during the "Old Word/New Word" activity the teacher is prompted to tell students, “Let’s find the sound in some words. (Student name) be our sound leader. Our word is (bit). What is the first sound? What is the next sound in the word (bit)?” The student continues to name all of the sounds in the word. Students then change the old word to a new word, for example, bit into the new word bat.
Materials provide the teacher with examples for instruction in syllables, sounds (phonemes), and spoken words called for in grade-level standards. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Advanced Oral PA Development Manual," page 8, provides teachers with examples for instruction in syllables and sounds. Directions included for the teacher to introduce the lesson routine state, “Say...hotdog, but don't say dog. What’s left?” Several lists of words to use for the lesson are provided.
- In the "Advanced Oral PA Development Manual," page 30, the teacher gives the word nail and tells students to add s. “If we say s first we get s...nail.” The teacher is given the starter, “Say...lye. But say f first. What’s the new word?” Several lists of words to use for the lesson are provided.
- In "Advanced Oral PA Development Manual," page 58, the teacher instructions on blending c to form CCVC words:
- "Teacher: Say…(cub) (R).
- Teacher: Say…(cub), but after (k) say (l). What’s the new word?"
Indicator 1e
Materials provide practice of each newly taught sound (phoneme) and sound pattern across the K-1 band.
The materials reviewed for Pathways to Reading Grade 1 partially meet the criteria for materials provide practice of each newly taught sound (phoneme) and sound pattern across the K-1 band.
Materials provide a variety of practice opportunities to build students’ phonological awareness. Segmenting sounds and identifying sounds in words is evident in the program. There are blending lessons in the "Advanced Oral PA Development Manual." Opportunities to identify short and long vowels in spoken words are not evident. Opportunities addressing identification of long or short vowels in words are presented through written words. Students have opportunities to segment single syllable words. However, graphemes are added after each phoneme. Students are provided with multisensory tools such as visuals when learning phonological awareness concepts.
Materials provide opportunities for students to practice each new sound and sound pattern called for in grade level standards. For example, the following items are noted:
- Students have opportunities to distinguish long from short vowel sounds in spoken single-syllable words:
- There were no examples of spoken single-syllable words where students distinguished vowel sounds. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 176, students are shown a chart with words with long vowel sounds ending in -tion and words with short vowel sounds ending in -tion. The teacher explains why some of these words have short and long vowel sounds, “When the vowel is followed by just one consonant it usually wears its name hat.”
- Students have opportunities to orally produce single-syllable words by blending sounds (phonemes), including consonant blends:
- In the "Advanced Oral PA Development Manual," page 58, students blend to form CCVC words such as adding /l/ to /k/ sound to create club. There are twelve additional lists provided to practice the blending.
- Students have opportunities to isolate and pronounce initial, medial vowel, and final sounds (phonemes) in spoken single-syllable words:
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 88, the "Segment and Write" lesson focuses on the word chop. The teacher guides students in completing the activity by asking questions such as, “What’s the last sound in chop?”
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 93, the "Segment and Write" lesson focuses on e. The teacher guides students in completing the activity by asking questions such as, “What’s the first sound in gate? What’s the next sound in the word gate?”
- Students have opportunities to segment spoken single-syllable words into their complete sequence of individual sounds (phonemes) with letter associations after each sound is identified:
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 105, the teacher tells students there are three sounds in the word fly. The students are asked to produce the first sound, then spell the letter, the next sound, then spell the letter, the last sound in the word and then spell the letter.
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 99, students complete the "Segment and Write" routine with the word whip. The teacher guides students through the process, asking questions such as, “T: (Student’s name) there are three sounds in the word whip. What’s the first sound? (R: /w/) T: We’ll come back and spell that sound in a second. What’s the second sound in whip? R) T: Put /i/ on the second sound dot. (Student places letter -i) T: What’s the last sound? (R) T: Put /p/ on the next sound dot. (R)"
Materials include a variety of multimodal/multisensory activities for student practice of phonological awareness. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 27, students feel the air from their mouth as they make consonant sounds such as /k/, /g/, /f/, /v/, and /c/.
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 76, students “Look at this picture for the /l/ sound. Is the tongue up in the front of the mouth or in the back?” When learning about letter sounds, the teacher uses visuals of the way the mouth should look when making the sound.
- In the "Flip and Assist Manual," page 3, students participate in "Freeze and Match." Students learn to make their mouth in the correct shape based on the vowel sound.
Criterion 1.3: Phonics
This criterion is non-negotiable. Materials must achieve a specified minimum score in this criterion to advance to the next gateway.
Materials emphasize explicit, systematic instruction of research-based and/or evidence-based phonics.
Pathways to Reading Grade 1 meet the criteria for materials emphasize explicit phonics instruction through systematic and repeated modeling. Materials include explicit instruction of all grade-level phonics standards through the use of the "Large Group," and "Small Group" manuals; however, reading of complete words is limited to calling on students during "Large Group" instruction which may not provide opportunities for all students to read complete words. Students have frequent practice opportunities to build/manipulate/spell, and encode grade-level phonics, including common and newly-taught sound and sound patterns. Materials provide explicit systematic teacher modeling and instruction for encoding of phonics from sounds, to letters and words in writing tasks.
Indicator 1f
Materials emphasize explicit phonics instruction through systematic and repeated modeling.
The materials reviewed for Pathways to Reading Grade 1 meet the criteria for materials emphasize explicit phonics instruction through systematic and repeated modeling.
Grade 1 materials provide teachers with sample dialogue to present explicit phonics instruction to students. Teachers are provided with instructions for teaching phonics and students have multiple practice opportunities with skills. Teacher Manuals continue to provide dialogue samples for repeated lessons or refer the teacher back to the introductory lesson. The online video library is referenced as a resource for teacher modeling in applicable lessons.
Materials contain explicit instructions for systematic and repeated teacher modeling of all grade level phonics standards. For example, the following is noted:
- Know the spelling-sound correspondences for common consonant digraphs:
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 50, the teacher explains a trick students can use to remember the th spelling. “/th/ is spelled with two letters. Here’s a trick to help you remember. Look at the -t. Think of the little line at the top as the letter sticking out its tongue the way we have to stick out our tongue to say the /th/ sound. There are four sounds that are spelled with two letters and the second letter is an -h. We can think of these as the -h brothers. -t-h is the rude brother that is always sticking out his what?.....(R)”
- In the "Large Group Manual," pages 66-67, the teacher is given the following sample dialogue for the lesson steps, “Make the sound: /ch/. Feel the air. Does it explode or squeeze out of the mouth?”..../ch/ is a neat sound. It’s spelled with two letters -ch (show the letters). It’s one of the -h brothers. We have the -th brother sticking out his tongue. The -sh brother says ‘/sh.../ don’t wake the snake’. -ch is the sneezy brother. He’s always sneezing:/ch/, /ch/, /choo/.” The teacher is advised to trace the c quickly every time /ch/ is said.
- Decode regularly spelled one-syllable words:
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 146-148, the teacher shows how to decode words using the following steps:
- "ID the vowel sound.
- Blend the vowel to the end.
- Start again.
- Identify the word.
- Map (spell) the portion of the word requested.
- Read the phrase or short sentence."
- In the "Flip and Assist Manual," page 14, the teacher states, “How many sounds do you think are in the word (bit)? Show me with your fingers. There are (three) sounds in the word (bit). (Student name) what’s the (first) sound?” The teacher is to respond to and fix errors, if necessary. Modeling is provided to ask about the remainder of the sounds in the word bit. In step two, “You heard the sound. Now you can spell it.” Students spell the word with magnetic letters on sound dots.
- Know final -e and common vowel team conventions for representing long vowel sounds:
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 51, the teacher reviews -e at the end. “T: Hold up the letter -a. Place the letter -e after it. So if the letter -e comes up to this vowel what does he ask? (R: What’s your name.) T: What’s the name of this letter? (R: -a) T: So it would have to answer and say, “my name is /ae/.”
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 129, the teacher instructs on ea, ai, ay, oa. The teacher states, “Look at the e-a. They’re walking together. The first one gets to do the talking. See. His mouth is open and the other vowel is listening. What does the first vowel say?”
- Use knowledge that every syllable must have a vowel sound to determine the number of syllables in a printed word:
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 145, during the multisyllable lesson “Eyeball Vowel Bump, Circle and Read”, the teacher is prompted to count and identify syllables in two words. The teacher tells students to "eyeball" vowels in the word. The teacher is directed to write faster on the board. “In your mind make the first vowel do the ‘vowel bump’. Did it bump into one or two consonants? Can your vowel have one of those consonants? Imagine you have a red pencil and you are drawing a circle around the first syllable.”
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 199, the teacher explains the importance of vowels in syllables. “Every word in the English language has a vowel sound in it. If there is just one vowel sound like in the word stay the word has just one syllable. A word with more than one vowel sound has more than one syllable. We call these words multi (write this on the board as you say it), syllable (write this as it is said.) words. Multi means more than one. So a multisyllable word is a word with more than one syllable. Just like every word has a vowel sound, every syllable will have a vowel sound.” The teacher then has students practice tapping out the number of syllables in words such as shadow and music. The teacher is provided with additional lists of two- and three-syllable words.
- Decode two-syllable words following basic patterns by breaking the words into syllables:
- In the "Small Group Manual," pages 205-206, the teacher writes the word frozen (written as fro zen) on the board. The teacher explains that the word has two syllables. The teacher puts a space between the syllables. The teacher instructs students to read each syllable and then blend the syllables.
- In the "Flip and Assist Manual," page 28, the teacher asks students, “What will you ask yourself first to help you figure out this word? (R: How many vowels.) What should you do next? (R: Do the ‘vowel bump’. Say each syllable. Look for instant syllables.) What will you ask yourself last? (R) Is it a word I know?”
- Read words with inflectional endings:
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 157, the teacher writes the word shouting, “Look at each word in this list. Can you instantly find the ending -ing?” The teacher is prompted to have students notice double consonants. Words used in the lesson include dropping, grabbing, strapping, filling, plodding, and dragging.
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 224, the teacher shows students how to read words with -er. The teacher reviews the endings -ing, -y, -ly. The teacher puts up runner, supper, flutter, spatter, and dinner and asks students what they see in the words. The teacher asks what students know about the ending.
Lessons provide teachers with systematic and repeated instruction for students to hear, say, encode, and read each newly taught grade-level phonics pattern. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 47, teachers “Review the concept of ‘What’s your name, -e as demonstrated in steps 4-6 on page 37.” Page 37 provided the teacher with sample dialogue, “Today we’re going to talk about how to spell these words. What are the names of the vowel letters in our alphabet?” “The letter -e is put at the end of vowels to make a vowel letter have a sound like its name.” The teacher reviews all of the long vowel sounds in the lesson and places letters next to each sound on the "Vowel Town Hill."
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 159, teachers are provided with strategies to use to help students practice reading multisyllable words, “Review multisyllable strategies for a couple of minutes each day. Find several decodable multisyllable words, double consonant words and words with the -ing ending from the "Think Aloud" or "Shared Reading" materials. Write these on the board. Think aloud to decode one from each category…..Apply this strategy to all reading materials encountered; social studies, magazines, leveled books, poetry, etc.”
- In the "Small Group Manual," pages 133-134, the teacher says the word stray. The teacher goes through the sounds in the word and teaches there are three ways to spell /ae/. During "Segment and Write," the teacher helps students write the word stray.
Indicator 1g
Materials include frequent practice opportunities for students to decode words that consist of common and newly-taught sound and spelling patterns and provide opportunities for students to review previously taught phonics skills.
The materials reviewed for Pathways to Reading Grade 1 partially meet the criteria for materials include frequent practice opportunities for students to decode words that consist of common and newly-taught sound and spelling patterns and provide opportunities for students to review previously taught phonics skills.
The materials provide opportunities to practice decoding skills over the course of the instructional sequence during "Small Group" instruction for students' current level of foundational skills instruction; however, during "Large Group" instruction of grade-level decoding skills, all students may not be provided the opportunity to practice applying phonics skills. Since a student may be working in a small group that is not at grade-level, there is no guarantee that all students will have opportunities to apply grade-level phonics skills.
When learning about vowel sounds, students had frequent opportunities to practice reading words with new vowel patterns. Vowel sounds and spelling patterns were also frequently reviewed over the course of the school year. Activities and games students learn are repeated consistently throughout the manual and allow students to practice and apply what they are learning.
Lessons provide students with some daily opportunities to decode (phonemes, onset and rime, and/or syllables) phonetically spelled words. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Large Group Manual," pages 132-133, in a vowel review lesson on the rule, “Two Vowels Go Walking”, students practice reading words with this rule such as braid, faint, and say.
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 147, students engage in "Read Single Words" using multisyllable practice in two or three syllable words. Word lists are provided or words can be from content areas such as math, science or social studies.
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 149, the teacher reviews a word reading strategy with students and students practice reading from word lists. In applying the strategy, the student will “1. Tell us the vowel sound. 2. Tell us the rime. What part of the word is the rime? (R) 3. Tell us the onset. What part is the onset? (R) 4. Tell us the word.” (Later in the lesson, the teacher eliminates step 1.)
Lessons provide students with daily opportunities for some students to read complete words by saying the entire word as a unit using newly taught phonics skills during "Small Group" instruction; however, not all students read complete words during "Large Group" instruction. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 162, when teaching the -ed ending, the teacher is instructed to call on students to practice reading words with this ending. Some of the words students read include played, scooted, hooked, and hauled.
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 166, when learning about the -er ending, students practice reading words such as ruler, driver, spider, and diner.
- In the "Small Group Folder," "First Up Lesson Plan" documentation template (green) for Level 3, students Read Words using "SNAP" and "Map" cards for practice. Words contain phonics skills such as sh, ch, and long vowels such as ae, ee, ie, oe, and ue. Days 1, 2, and 3 reference "Read Words."
Materials contain daily opportunities for students to review previously learned grade-level phonics. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 70, the materials include "Vowel Ladder" sets for practice: short vowels, long vowels with e, "Two Vowels Walking," "Vowel Buddies," "R Vowels," and "Ladder 6," and all vowels.
- In the "Flip and Assist Manual," page 12, "Spot the Vowel," students practice quickly identifying the vowel sound in a word. “I’m going to show you some words. I don’t need you to read the word to me. I want you to spot the vowel and say its sound as quickly as you can. Be careful because many vowel sounds are spelled with two letters. Ready?”
Materials contain a variety of methods to promote students’ practice of previously taught grade-level phonics. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 147, the "Multisyllable Review" lists activities that can be utilized such as students tapping out syllables, doing "Vowel Bump," "Circle and Read," or "eyeball" (looking for vowels), and reading the words.
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 179, students practice multisyllabic words. The teacher is prompted to “Place multisyllable words chosen from "Think Aloud" or non-fiction books. Find words with the -ture ending and other instant syllables learned to date. Call on students to identify the tricky ending then read the word. Be prepared to provide multisyllable Student Assists. Image and write the endings in the air. Add to lists on the word wall.”
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 51-71, "Vowel Practice" exercises are listed: "Say on Own/Cover It," "Find it," "Cross the River," "Write Across the River," "Spot the Vowel with Spot with the Vowel Flashcards," and "Spot the Vowel with Ladders."
Indicator 1h
Materials provide frequent opportunities for students to practice decoding phonetically regular words in a sentence.
The materials reviewed for Grade 1 meet the criteria for materials promote frequent opportunities for students to practice decoding phonetically regular words in a sentence.
Pathways to Reading materials provide students with opportunities to practice decoding phonetically regular words in a sentence during "Small Group Read in Context" lessons and through "Pathway to Spelling" lessons. Students read sentences each week on Day 2 of the spelling routine. The "Read in Context" routine provides students with frequent opportunities to read complete sentences. "Read in Context" sentences contain both decodable words and high-frequency words. Students complete a sentence strip reading center on a regular basis.
Materials provide explicit, systematic practice for decoding phonetically regular words in a sentence. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Small Group Manual," pages 178-180, in Lesson 4 "Phrasing and Practice with Sentence Strips," the teacher models reading the way they talk. The teacher gives the students a new sentence strip to read. Students read it to themselves first and place a paper clip on words they are unsure of. “Use the word reading strategy: What’s the vowel sound? Blend sounds into a word. Is that a word you know?” The teacher is told to, “Refer to Flip and Assist” to help students with decoding errors reading words.
- In the "Spelling Manual," page 24, the teacher instructs on how to decode the spelling words. The teacher reads the first sentence of students Spelling Lesson 1, Day 2. The teacher informs students there are four spelling words in the sentence.
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 187, the teacher guides students to complete a word sort activity with sentence strips. Students sort words from the sentence strips into two categories, “You have two categories of words. Screech words - words that aren’t spelled the way they sound, and one-letter vowel words.” The sentences that students sort words from are, “1. The pig got the cob from Ted.” and “The cat has a big cut. It has to go to the vet.”
Lessons provide students with frequent opportunities to decode words in a sentence. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Small Group Manual," pages 170-197, materials outline the activities that students engage in to “read in context” during small group instruction using sentence strips:
- "1. Imagery-Students read the sentences and draw pictures or write descriptions about what they see.
- 2. Phrasing-Students highlight or cut sentences into phrases and practice reading the phrases.
- 3. Prosody with punctuation marks-Students read to each other using various punctuation.
- 4. Prosody with emotions-Students read sentence strips conveying different emotions.
- 5. Words Sort-Students choose a sentence strip and sort the words according to different phonics patterns."
- In the "Spelling Manual," page 16, the teacher is to, “1) Read new spelling words and sentences. 2) Segment and spell words using PowerPoint Lesson 1 Take Home page. 3) Tape ‘Screech’ words to classroom door entry.” The teacher uses the sentence strips, “The big man had a fat cat,” and “His hand got cut on the can.”
- In the "Reproducibles," there are 88 sentence strips provided for students’ weekly practice reading words in sentences. The words are aligned to the scope and sequence for the phonics continuum found in the "Large Group Manual."
- In the "Reproducibles, the sentence strips correspond to the targeted phonics for the week. For example, sentences 55-64 focus on -r vowels. Sentences include: 56. "The girl wore her blue dress to church,” and 59. "I saw a lark up in the tree at the park,” and 62. "Norm got a sharp thorn in his leg.”
Indicator 1i
Materials include frequent practice opportunities for students to build/manipulate/spell and encode grade-level phonics, including common and newly-taught sound and sound patterns.
The materials reviewed for Pathways to Reading Grade 1 meet the criteria for materials include frequent practice opportunities for students to build/manipulate/spell, and encode grade-level phonics, including common and newly-taught sound and sound patterns.
Students have frequent opportunities over the course of the school year to write and build new words. Phonics practice is completed in the "Small Group, Large Group, and Spelling Manuals." Students write words using markers or magnetic letters on their whiteboards. Teacher instructions for these routines are clear. Instructional routines are consistent throughout the school year.
The materials contain teacher-level instruction/modeling for building/manipulating/spelling, and encoding words using common and newly-taught sound and spelling patterns of phonics. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 114, "Segment and Write" lesson 14 c/e, i, y, the teacher places the letters c, e, n, t in random order. The sample dialogue for the lesson prompts the teacher to say, “There are four sounds in the word cent. The word that I’m thinking of means one penny or cent. (Sound leader’s name) what’s the first sound in cent?” Once the student responds, the teacher says, “(Speller’s name) you hear the sound. Look at the letters you have for the word cent. Which letter to you think you’ll use? That’s right. We’ll use the letter -c.”
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 83, during a "Segment and Write" lesson that focuses on the word deck, the teacher explains how to spell /k/ at the end of a word. “When the /k/ is at the end of a word, right after a one letter vowel the letter -c is added. Some students like to think of the letter -c as a defender. It comes to defend little one letter vowels. We’ll think of it as defender -c.” Students write deck on their boards.
- In the "Small Group Manual," pages 142-143, during "Old/Word/New Word," students use magnetic letters to build bit, big, bag, bog.
Lessons provide students with daily opportunities to build/manipulate/spell, and encode words in isolation based on common and newly-taught phonics patterns. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Large Group Manual," pages 128-130, in the "Segment and Write" lesson, students are introduced to "Two Vowels Go Walking" alternatives of ea, ai, ay, and oa for the sounds /ee/, /ae/, and /oe/. Days 2-5 on page 132 review "Two Vowels Go Walking" (ea, ai, ay, oa) with the "Screech" poster.
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 90-92, students complete the "Segment and Write" routine for the words song and sang. After discussing the sounds in each word, students use a white board and marker to write the words.
Indicator 1j
Materials provide application and encoding of phonics in activities and tasks. (mid K-Grade 2)
The materials reviewed for Pathways to Reading Grade 1 meet the criteria for materials promote application and encoding of phonics in activities and tasks. (mid K-Grade 2)
Materials provide explicit systematic teacher modeling and instruction for encoding of phonics from sounds to letters and words in writing tasks. Students practice writing individual words using "Segment and Write." The materials provide opportunities to apply phonics skills to encode words in sentences or phrases in Pathways to Spelling lessons.
Materials include explicit, systematic teacher-level instruction of teacher modeling that demonstrates the use of phonics to encode sounds to letters and words in writing tasks. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 114, students complete the "Segment and Write" routine for the word cent. As part of the lesson, the teacher tells students, “Screech has a big time cool thing to let you know about -c. He found the secret to when -c gets to sound like /s/. When the letter -c is followed by the vowel letters -e, -i or -y (point to these on the poster) the letter -c will always, always stand for the /s/ sound. Cool huh?”
- In the "Large Group Manual," pages 148-149, materials provide explicit instruction to help students encode sounds in words. “Place the letters -g, -e, -m, -s in random order above the sound dots...say, ‘There are four sounds in the word gems. What’s the first sound in gems? You heard the sound. Look at the letters you laid out for the word gems. Which letter do you think you’ll use?’ … ‘The letter -g is a lot like the letter -c. It can stand for two sounds. Here’s our Screech poster. (Hold up the g/e, i y poster. Point to the -g with the /g/ at the end.) The sound we usually think of for it is the /g/ sound. However, it can also stand for the /j/ sound. (Point to the -g with the /j/ at the end.)” Students continue by generating a list of /j/ words into two columns: g = /j/ and j =/j/.
- In the "Flip and Assist Manual," page 14, during "Segment and Write" in Step 2, the teacher tells students they have heard the sounds in bit, now they can spell it. If there is no response, the teacher is to tell the student, “You spell /b/ with a -b.” If the vowel is incorrect the teacher is to ask, “Can you picture where /e/ is on the Vowel Hill? Can you picture how it is spelled?”
Lessons provide students with frequent activities and tasks to promote application of phonics as they encode words in sentences or in phrases based on common and newly taught phonics patterns. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Spelling Manual," pages 8-11, during the weekly spelling routine students are provided with opportunities to encode words in sentences and phrases:
- Day 1-Students read phrases that contain the week’s cheater words and then trace the cheater words.
- Day 2-Students complete a writing activity using the week’s sentences, 1) Copy each sentence, 2) Circle the spelling words in it, 3) Draw an image of the sentence, and 4) Write another sentence to describe what could happen next.
- Day 3-Instructions are provided for a "Picture My Sentence" activity. They generate a sentence using a spelling word or complete a starter sentence. They try to think of what they are seeing in their minds and then to use imagery words to describe it.
- In the "Spelling Manual," pages 93-94, students echo-read two sentences and then copy them into their "Screech and Me" workbooks. Students extend by adding another sentence.
- In the "Spelling Manual," page 117, the teacher reminds students that -qu and -x are "Copycat" spellings using the sentence, “The queen wore her cape and crown.” The teacher asks students to show how many sounds are in queen, has the class or a student segment the word, and tells the class or a student to spell the sound. The teacher is then to “Tell students to write -q,-u on the first two lines for the sounds of /k/ and /w/.”
Criterion 1.4: Word Recognition and Word Analysis
Materials and instruction support students in learning and practicing regularly and irregularly spelled high-frequency words.
Pathways to Reading Grade 1 materials provide systematic instruction and opportunities for students to practice high-frequency words through "Read Word and Spelling" activities. Students are provided with 200 sight words to study over the course of the school year. Materials provide frequent practice opportunities to read and write high-frequency words in context. Explicit instruction in word analysis is provided with sample dialogue. Students have frequent opportunities to analyze word endings and syllables.
Indicator 1k
Materials include systematic instruction of high-frequency words and opportunities to practice reading of high-frequency words to develop automaticity.
The materials reviewed for Grade 1 meet the criteria for materials include systematic instruction of high-frequency words and practice opportunities of high-frequency words to develop automaticity.
The Pathways to Reading materials contain consistent and explicit instructions for introducing and teaching the words to students. In addition to the practice students complete in the "Spelling Manual," students practice reading sight words through the "Sight Word Olympics" routine and during class when coming and going from the classroom with words posted on the doorframe. Students are provided with 200 sight words to study over the course of the school year. The materials provide systematic instruction and opportunities for students to practice high-frequency words through "Read, Word and Spelling" activities.
Materials include systematic and explicit instruction of irregularly spelled words. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 14, teachers “Choose a few ‘cheater’ words to focus on each week. Preview materials to be read to the class. After doing a Think Aloud tell the students they are to help you find the sight words which they will study for several weeks. Have highlighting tape available to highlight the words as they are located. Pieces of highlighting tape may be made available and students can search in books on their own for the week’s sight words. Post the words on the frame to the classroom door. Read the words to the students as they enter and leave the room. Eventually ask students to read them for you.”
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 153, students are taken through the “Screech words (non-phonetic words)”, and practice identifying them. “This word has a Screech in the corner, do you know why? Well, Screech always shows up when we need some help with words. These words are tricky because one of the sounds in the word isn’t spelled the way you would think it should be...This word is ‘said’...what is the first sound in ‘said’? How is /s/ spelled? Look at this word. Is that how the first sound is spelled? What’s the 2nd sound in the word “said”? How is /e/ spelled? Is /e/ spelled with an -ed in the word, ‘said’? That’s the ‘cheater”’ part of this word. It isn’t spelled the way it should be. So it makes it harder for us to learn the word. What is this word again?”
- In the "Spelling Manual," page 37, students follow a consistent routine when learning new words. Using a PowerPoint presentation, the teacher introduces the word. Students count the number of sounds, segment/spell the sounds in the word, and write the word. Finally, the teacher is instructed to have the “Class say slowly, image and write in picture box.”
- In the "Flip and Assist Manual," page 27, the teacher is given the sample dialogue, “You read that word just the way the letters should be read. But this word has a cheater part. The (a-i) doesn’t make the (/ae/) sound like you’d expect it to. The word is pronounced (/sed/). Let’s add that to the list of cheater words you’re learning.” The teacher is provided with the prompt, “Can you make the leap to the real words by thinking about how it’s used in the sentence?”
Materials include frequent opportunities for the teacher to model the spelling and reading of irregularly spelled words in isolation. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Spelling Manual," page 109, the teacher is instructed in the PowerPoint: “Teacher read words. Teacher read sentences. Students echo read.” The PowerPoint corresponds with the spelling lesson in which the teacher reads the words he, be, she, go, no, sold, find, and most.
- In the "Spelling Manual," pages 66-68, Days 1-5 include high frequency words what, who, which, and when. The lesson begins with the teacher asking students two ways to spell the /w/ sound (/w/ and /wh/). Students segment and write the word list. Then students analyze the ‘cheater’ part of the words in the list, for example the /u/ for a in what.
- In the "Spelling Manual," page 67, the teacher models how to segment and spell irregular words:
- "Click for meaning of the word. See sentences on PP notes.
- Class tells how many sounds in the word (PP click to C or C).
- Class (or sound leader) says the first sound. (segmenting practice).
- Class (or student) spells.
- Class writes spelling on sound dots. (PP click).
- Class says the word slowly and writes in the ‘picture box.’ (PP click)"
Students practice identifying and reading irregularly spelled words in isolation. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 154, student pairs work together through sets of Screech words:
- The “teacher” covers the small phonetic word on front. Ask the “student” to read the word without seeing the phonetic spelling.
- Then, the “teacher” uncovers the phonetic spelling and the “teacher” and “student” must agree that the word was read correctly.
- The “teacher” then covers the word and asks the mapping questions on the back.
- The “teacher” uncovers the word and the “teacher” and “student” check if the spelling provided was correct.
- The “student” then reads the phrase on the back.
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 157, students play "Slow and Go" to independently read several "SNAP" words. Students flip over words (3-4) and think about the onset/rime strategy to read the word. If they think it’s read correctly, they place it on the “Green for Go” circle. If they aren’t sure, they place it on the “Yellow for Slow” circle, and the teacher provides assistance. The teacher takes notes on students progress.
- In the Reproducibles, "Sight Word Olympics," students practice sight words at home with parents, and at school with a partner. Students work towards reading their lists quickly and earn “medals” as they master each list.
Materials include a sufficient quantity of new grade-appropriate irregularly spelled words for students to make reading progress. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Large Group Manual," Teacher Preparation Tab, pages 44-45, resources for "Single Word Reading" practice include a set of 200 high-frequency words ("SNAP" and "Map" cards). The words are sorted into sound pools: Pool 1-Short Vowels and Digraphs; Pool 2-Long Vowels; Pool 3 Buddy Vowels; Pool 4 -r Vowels; Pool 5-2 Vowels Walking; Multisyllables; Non-Phonetic.
- In the Reproducibles, "Sight Word Olympics," students study 50 words each quarter to total 200 words over the course of the school year.
Indicator 1l
Materials provide frequent practice opportunities to read and write high-frequency words in context (sentences).
The materials reviewed for Grade 1 meet the criteria for materials provide frequent practice opportunities to read and write high-frequency words in context (sentences).
In Pathways to Reading, students have frequent opportunities over the course of the school year to read and write high-frequency words. High-frequency words are included on every weekly spelling test. Students practice writing high-frequency words both in isolation and in a sentence each week. Students have the opportunity to practice reading high-frequency words on the sentence strips that are used in different activities.
Lessons provide students with frequent opportunities to read grade level irregularly spelled words in a sentence. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Small Group Manual," pages 187-188, students find words in sentence strips and organize them into two categories of words: "Screech" words-words that aren’t spelled the way they sound, and one-letter vowel words. The sentences students use to complete this activity are, “The pig got the cob from Ted,” and “The cat has a big cut. It has to go to the vet.”
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 189, the teacher is prompted to “Each week place the directions to one of the Sentence Strip activities in the station. Rotate these activities every week, or every three days, as desired. “
Lessons provide students with frequent opportunities to write grade-level, irregularly spelled words in tasks (such as sentences) in order to promote automaticity in writing grade level irregularly spelled words. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Spelling Manual," pages 66-68, students work with high-frequency words which, when, what, and who. Students practice their words for the week. The practice sentences are “What can I get when I shop?” and “Who can rush and shut the pen?”
- In the "Spelling Manual," page 95, when the words come and some are part of the list, students practice writing the words along with the rest of their spelling words. As part of the spelling practice, the teacher dictates the following two sentences, “Take some cake to the three men,” and “Will the lost cats come home?” The sentences for dictation are in PowerPoint Lesson 8, Day 3, Slide 3.
- In the "Spelling Manual," pages 109-110, students practice one letter long vowels “he, be, she, go , no, sold,” and "Cheater" words “find, and most”:
- Whole group:
- "Spell mystery word ‘told' and review one-letter long vowels.
- Echo read the sentences and words for the week.
- Co-create mental imagery related to one or both sentences.
- 'On the Spot' reading and spelling-Students read or spell Screech words as they enter or exit the classroom."
- Independent:
- "Copy sentences and circle spelling words.
- Add a sentence with an additional thought to one of the week’s sentences.
- Illustrate their images."
Materials provide repeated, explicit instruction in how to use student-friendly reference materials and resources, and reading irregularly spelled words (e.g., word cards, word lists, word ladders, student dictionaries). For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Spelling Manual," Appendix B, pages 40-41, "Take Home" Lesson 18, students practice their weekly words (girl, first, shirt, bird, third, twirl, write, change) using the repeated pattern:
- "Students read the word in the list.
- Spell each word by first identifying the number of 'sound dots' used by the word.
- After students spell the word, the parent asks, 'Did you spell it right?' and has students self-correct.
- If the word has a yellow letter (a tricky part) then the prompt is, 'This word has a tricky part. The word is _______. Picture the word in your mind and spell it for me.'
- Additional: Read or spell each sentence and explain what the sentence means and the image it creates in the student's mind."
- In the "Spelling Manual," pages 56-62, teachers are provided with high-frequency word flashcards. The teacher is instructed to, “Laminate and cut out. The cards are labeled by weeks. They are taped to the classroom doorway. Use the cards as directed each week.”
- In the "Reproducibles," "Sight Word Olympics Word Lists," students are provided with sight word lists to study for each quarter.
Indicator 1m
Materials explicitly teach word analysis strategies (e.g., phoneme/grapheme recognition, syllabication, morpheme analysis) based on the requirements of the standards and provide students with frequent practice opportunities to apply word analysis strategies.
The materials reviewed for Grade 1 meet the criteria for materials explicitly teach word analysis strategies (phoneme/grapheme recognition, syllabication, morpheme analysis) based on the requirements of the standards and provide frequent practice opportunities for students to apply word analysis strategies.
In Pathways to Reading, explicit instruction in word analysis is provided with sample dialogue. Students have frequent opportunities to analyze word endings and syllables.
Materials contain frequent explicit instruction of word analysis strategies (phoneme/grapheme recognition, syllabication, morpheme analysis). For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 137, students play the "Name Hat Sound Hat" game to isolate and say each syllable in a two- or three-syllable word. “In multisyllable words if a vowel is spelled with one letter it gets to wear two hats. It might wear its sound hat like it usually does, or it might wear its special fancy name hat. When it wears its name hat, it doesn’t need an -e or another vowel to walk with it. Which hat is -o wearing in the word stony?”
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 160, -ed is introduced on Day 2 and practiced on Days 3, 4, and 5.
- In the "Large Group Manual," pages 174-176, students are introduced to the suffix -tion. “The /sh/ sound is spelled with -t-i. The /e/ sound is spelled with -o.”
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 200, students practice counting and identifying the syllables in two- and three-syllable words. The teacher asks students questions such as, “T: Tap the syllables in the word____. (R) T: How many syllables are there? (R)” and, “T: If there are (two) syllables how many vowel sounds are there?”
Materials contain frequent explicit instruction of word solving strategies to decode unfamiliar words. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Large Group Manual," pages 151-153, students learn the sound /j/ at the end of a word is -dge when preceded by a short vowel. “But Screech found that we can protect the one letter vowel by putting in a defender. (Place the letter -d in front of the -ge on the same sound dot.).”
- In the "Large Group Manual," page 183, teachers review how to “make the leap” with multisyllable “cheater” words:
- "First step: Read the way it looks.
- Second step: Search our brains to think what words have some of the same parts. What could the word really be?
- Third step: Think about how the word is used in a sentence or story."
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 147, the teacher introduces a word reading strategy to students, “1) Identify the vowel. 2) Read the vowel to the end. We call that the rime. 3) Start again. We go to the beginning of the word and add any consonants.”
Multiple and varied opportunities are provided over the course of the year for students to learn, practice, and apply word analysis strategies. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 222, students practice reading words with the instant syllables -y and -ly such as: plainly, burly, envy, and shady.
- In the "Small Group Manual," page v, "Read Words" lessons are provided and practiced. The lessons include: "Reading Strategy with SNAP and Map Words," "Word Reading" lists, "Independent Word Reading" practice, "Vocabulary from Text Word Reading Practice," "Read and Hand Back," and the "Slow and Go Practice Routine."
- In the "Spelling Manual," page 208, students study two syllable words. Students practice dividing words into syllables. Words students study include: number, after, under, over, paper, never, mother, and water.
Criterion 1.5: Decoding Accuracy, Decoding Automaticity and Fluency
This criterion is non-negotiable. Materials must achieve a specified minimum score in this criterion to advance to the next gateway.
Materials provide systematic and explicit instruction and practice in fluency by focusing on accuracy and automaticity in decoding in K and 1, and rate, expression, and accuracy in mid-to-late 1st and 2nd grade. Materials for 2nd grade fluency practice should vary (decodables and grade-level texts).
Pathways to Reading Grade 1 materials provide students with frequent opportunities to practice automaticity and accuracy with reading single words. Materials partially meet the criteria for instructional opportunities are built into the materials for systematic, evidence-based, explicit instruction in fluency. Explicit instruction in rate is not included in the materials.
Materials partially meet the criteria for materials provide teacher guidance to support students as they confirm or self-correct errors and emphasize reading for purpose and understanding. On-level texts included with the program are limited to weekly spelling paragraphs. While grade-level books are referenced in the materials, the books are not included in the program.
Indicator 1n
Materials provide opportunities for students to engage in decoding practice focused on accuracy and automaticity in K and Grade 1.
The materials reviewed for Grade 1 meet the criteria for materials provide opportunities for students to engage in decoding practice focused on accuracy and automaticity in K and Grade 1.
In Pathways to Reading materials, students have frequent opportunities to practice automaticity and accuracy with reading single words. The teacher is provided with clear, explicit instructions in the "Flip and Assist Manual" for helping students with different errors they may make while reading words. The "Small Group Manual" contains a variety of activities for word reading practice. "Read in Context" lessons during "Large Group" instruction and "Small Group" instruction use sentence strips that include the daily/weekly phonics focus. Pathways to Spelling lessons include phonetic words, "Fry" words, and "Screech" words. Materials provide explicit modeling provided by the teacher and peer-to-peer feedback on accuracy to build towards automaticity.
Materials provide systematic and explicit instruction and practice in fluency by focusing on accuracy and automaticity in decoding. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Small Group Manual," pages 146-148, the teacher is provided with instructions for helping students read word lists. At the start of practice, students read the lists following the steps, “ID the vowel sound, read the rime, read the onset, read the word.” By the end of the lesson students are simply instructed to, “read the word.” The teacher provides specific feedback to each student to ensure accuracy.
- In the "Small Group Manual," pages 176-177, the teacher models reading the way we talk using sentence strip 1 “The pig got the cob from Ted.” The teacher explains, “When we read the way we talk we clump groups of words together and say them a little faster.” The teacher uses a paper clip to create phrases. The teacher models reading in phrases, and students echo read. Students practice in the "Reading Club" using a paperclip to create phrases and read the sentence strip several times to a partner until they, “Then read it the way we talk.”
- In the "Small Group Manual," pages 178-180, the teacher reviews the concept of reading the way we talk. The teacher reads some sentences with, and some without, phrasing, and the students respond by nodding either yes or no to indicate whether phrasing has been used correctly.
Materials provide opportunities for students in Kindergarten and Grade 1 to engage in decoding practice focused on accuracy and automaticity. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 151, students practice reading word lists with a partner. Students take turns being the teacher and the student. The “teacher” asks, “1) What’s the vowel? 2) What’s the rime? 3) What’s the word?” As part of the lesson the teacher is instructed to, “Tell the students that they are going to practice together to read words correctly. Their goal is to learn to read lists of words accurately and quickly. They will test themselves by trying to read their list in less than one second per word.”
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 153, students engage in paired learning with "SNAP" and "Map" words by practicing with sets of words to develop accurate and automatic reading.
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 156, students learn the "SNAP Read and Hand Back Practice Routine." In this routine students practice reading words quickly. Initially, students say the rime and then the word. Students progress to "eyeballing" the word and reading the whole word out loud.
- In the Small Group Folder, students complete "Read Words" practice in small groups: Level 2 Days 4, 5 and 6 and in Level 3, Days 1-6.
Indicator 1o
Instructional opportunities are built into the materials for systematic, evidence-based, explicit instruction in fluency. (Grades 1-2)
The materials reviewed for Grade 1 partially meet the criteria for instructional opportunities are built into the materials for systematic, evidence-based, explicit instruction in fluency (Grades 1-2).
The Pathways to Reading materials provide explicit instruction in some aspects of fluency through the "Small Group" instruction and the "Pathways to Spelling." Fluency lessons focus on accuracy, phrasing, prosody, punctuation, and emotions through activities such as choral reading, echo reading, and "Reading Club" activities. Lessons and activities are limited to nine repeated lessons during "Small Groups" that rely on decodable texts, two sentences and a weekly paragraph in Pathways to Spelling, and sentence strips.
Materials include some opportunities for explicit, systematic instruction in fluency elements using grade-level text. Instruction in rate is missing.
For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 164, Objective 1 for "Read in Context" lessons is: Develop decoding accuracy, phrasing, expression, and fluency:
- Students decode orally with 98% accuracy.
- Teacher provides error assists and prompts for decoding accuracy.
- Teacher models phrasing and expression.
- Students re-read to demonstrate fluency, phrasing, and expression.
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 171, the teacher demonstrates phrasing verbally and then uses two colors of highlighter to show the phrases on the sentence strip. “Let’s read it that way together. Are you ready?” Students choral read. A selected student reads the sentence again for the 5th round.
- In the "Small Group Manual," pages 181-183, students echo read to practice prosody while focusing on punctuation marks. “I’m going to read this sentence again. Tell me if at the end my voice goes up (make the voice go higher when saying up) or if it goes down (make the voice go lower when saying down.).”
Materials provide opportunities for students to hear fluent reading of grade-level text by a model reader. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Spelling Manual," page 9, Day 2 of each week includes the routine, “Teacher following the teacher’s manual and using the PowerPoint, has students ‘echo’ read the two sentences for the week. The teacher reads the sentence phrase by phrase with expression. The group echoes each phrase after it is read.”
- In the "Spelling Manual," page 32, when completing the weekly Day 4 spelling paragraph, the teacher is instructed to, “Read each sentence. Students echo read (repeat after teacher.). Have students read and image the paragraph sentence by sentence.”
Materials include some resources for explicit instruction in fluency. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Small Group Manual," pages 192-194, students read decodable texts using “imaging, phrasing, making our reading voices show where commas, periods, and question marks are and the emotions of the writer and so forth, during small group instruction."
- In the "Small Group Manual," pages 195-197, the teacher is directed to use a decodable book to develop listening and reading skills through context reading. The teacher reads, and students echo read with proper phrasing, “Now that we’ve figured out the words, let’s practice reading in phrases.”
- In the "Spelling Manual," page 171, the teacher reads the weekly words. Then, the teacher reads the two weekly sentences. Students echo read. The process of echo reading the spelling sentences is repeated on Day 2 of weekly spelling lessons during large group instruction.
Indicator 1p
Varied and frequent opportunities are built into the materials for students to engage in supported practice to gain oral reading fluency beginning in mid-Grade 1 and through Grade 2 (once accuracy is secure).
The materials reviewed for Pathways to Reading Grade 1 partially meet the criteria for varied and frequent opportunities are built into the materials for students to engage in supported practice to gain oral reading fluency beginning in mid-Grade 1 and through Grade 2 (once accuracy is secure).
The Pathways to Reading materials provide opportunities to engage in supported practice to gain oral fluency through small group lessons, "Reading Club," and "Pathways to Spelling" lessons. Variety is limited as materials only include sentence strips for small group activities and paragraph readings in "Pathways to Spelling" lessons.
Opportunities are provided over the course of the year in core materials for students to gain oral reading fluency. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Spelling Manual," page 9, Day 2 of each week includes the following routine, “Teacher following the teacher’s manual and using the PowerPoint has students ‘echo’ read the two sentences for the week. The teacher reads the sentence phrase-by-phrase with expression. The group ‘echoes’ each phrase after it is read.”
- In the "Spelling Manual," page 32, Day 4 of each week when completing the weekly spelling paragraph, the teacher is instructed to, “Read each sentence. Students echo read (repeat after teacher). Have students read and image the paragraph, sentence by sentence.”
- In the "Spelling Manual," page 120, students read and image the paragraph in their "Screech and Me Student Book" for Lesson 11 Day 4. Students re-read the paragraph independently, or to a partner.
- In the Small Group Folder, page 8, "First UP-Materials" and "Start Up" outlines the "Reading Plan" for Level 2 small group instruction during "Reading Clubs:"
- "Day 4 - Reading Club assignment - Co-read to a play focusing on phrasing and expression. Choose a part to read to the group demonstrating good phrasing and expression.
- Day 5 - Reading Club assignment - Co-read to a pal focusing on imagery. Choose a section with favorite imagery to share back with the group."
Materials contain opportunities for students to participate in repeated readings of a grade-level text to practice oral reading fluency:
- In the "Small Group Manual," pages 176-177, the teacher models reading the way we talk using sentence strip 1, "The pig got the cob from Ted." The teacher explains, “When we read the way we talk we clump groups of words together and say them a little faster.” The teacher uses a paper clip to create phrases. The teacher models, and students echo read as they read in phrases. Students practice in the Reading Club with Sentence Strip 5 using the paperclip to create phrases and read the sentence strip several times to a partner until they, “Then read it the way we talk.” Students are told they will be able to show off their practice during the next small group session.
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 197, the teacher can “Continue with the decodable book of choice.” At the end of the lesson, students “Re-read the story with a partner or alone. Choose a favorite page and practice it until the words are easy and you can work on phrasing. Write one of the sentences on a piece of paper and put a colored mark after each phrase. Come to reading group ready to show off!”
- In the Small Group Folder, page 8, the lesson references a grade-level book that is not included in the materials. The "First UP Materials" and "Start Up" lesson outlines the "Reading Plan" for Level 2 small group instruction:
- "Day 4-Cold Read-focus = accuracy: transfer decoding skills, light questioning of vocabulary and story line; teacher responds to student errors and questions images for key vocabulary.
- Day 5-Reread-focus = meaning and phrasing: how does the meaning influence the phrasing? Discuss imagery, emotions, predictions, inferences, summarize. What does the book lend itself to?
- Day 6-Final Read-focus = application: students pair up and read to each other in paired learning. 1) Students stop each other and ask questions; 2) If needed, they help to correct each other; 3) Students prepare to read with the teacher. The teacher listens to a student read aloud a portion of the book/passage. The teacher responds to errors and assists as needed."
Materials include minimal guidance and feedback suggestions to the teacher for supporting students’ gains in oral reading fluency. Materials include feedback at the word level. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Flip and Assist Manual", pages 23-27, materials provide 11 assists for reading one-syllable words including:
- Pauses at a word
- Student starts to read the word by segmenting
- Incorrect vowel sound
- Sound is omitted
- Sound is added
- Sound is replaced
- Sounds out of order
- A phonics guide is incorrect
- A phonics guide is correct
- Letter reversal
- A cheater word
Indicator 1q
Materials provide teacher guidance to support students as they confirm or self-correct errors (Grades 1-2) and emphasize reading for purpose and understanding.
The materials reviewed for Grade 1 partially meet the criteria for materials provide teacher guidance to support students as they confirm or self-correct errors and emphasize reading for purpose and understanding.
In Pathways to Reading, the Flip and Assist Manual and "Pathways to Spelling" lessons provide teachers with guidance concerning how to assist students with confirming reading or self-correcting errors. Imagery is a consistent focus of reading for understanding. Materials include detailed think alouds to use when discussing imagery. On-level texts included with the program are limited to weekly spelling paragraphs. While grade-level books are referenced in the materials, the books are not included in the program. Materials include limited opportunities for students to read grade-level text with purpose and understanding.
Materials provide explicit lessons for the teacher in confirming and self-correcting errors in fluency. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 179, the teacher responds to questions the student may have about a word from the sentence strip after a silent reading with the word reading strategy, “What’s the vowel in the word? Blend sounds into a word. Is that a word you know?”
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 238, students learn how to “make the leap” when reading words, “Sometimes we read a word the way it looks like it should be read, but it doesn’t sound quite right. That’s because some words aren’t said the way they look. When we read, we should always expect a word to sound right and make sense. If it doesn’t we may need to search in our minds for a word that it might be. You can think of this as making the leap to a read word.”
- In the "Flip and Assist Manual," pages 28-31, materials outline the process for assisting students to read multisyllabic words. "Leveled Assists" are provided to help students confirm or self-correct errors. The following is an example for when students replace a sound:
- "Most assistance:
- When you say (____) what’s the (first) syllable?
- What’s the (first sound in /le/)?
- Look at the syllable. Do you see the (/l/ sound first)?
- Moderate assistance:
- Check the (first) sound in the (first) syllable.
- Least assistance:
- Part of your word isn’t matching. Can you fix it?
- What part did you fix?"
- For all errors-the “final support-release of responsibility” includes the following prompts:
- “I saw you stop to figure out that word. What was going on in your head? How did you do that?”
- “You read that word incorrectly and then you fixed it. Good job. How did you know to fix it?”
- “I noticed that you read those words easily. You didn’t seem to need any time at all to figure them out. That’s good. That’s what good readers are trying to do.”
Materials provide opportunities for students to practice using confirmation or self-correction of errors. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 179, the teacher prompts students to self-identify challenge when presented with a new sentence: “I see you have a question about a word. Is your question how to read the word or what it means?” If the student is struggling to read a word, prompt as follows: “What’s the vowel sound? Blend sounds into a word. Is that a word you know?”
- In the "Small Group Manual," pages 181-182, the teacher models reading questions and has the students echo read them. The teacher tells a student, “(Student name) let’s hear you read this question sentence. (affirm or assist student to use voice to indicate a question.” At the end of the lesson the students practice using sticky notes with punctuation marks on them, place them on the "ABC" chart, and practice reading it with a partner. The teacher tells the students, “At our next small group meeting you’ll get to perform!”
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 239, students practice “Making the Leap.” “This word isn’t read the way it looks. How did you figure it out or how did you know the word? What went through your mind?” The steps in “making the leap” are to, “1. Read the word the way it looks. 2. Do a mental search to “make the leap” to the correct pronunciation. 3. Read the sentence with the word. 4. Ask the teacher, an adult or a friend or check the dictionary.” The teacher is provided with numerous words to have students practice including again, answer, mountain, and country.
Some opportunities are provided over the course of the year for students to read on-level texts (Grades 1-2) for purpose and understanding. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 197, during "Reading Club," students learn how to ask each other questions about the stories that they are reading.
- Page 4: “What do you think it means when the words say, ‘They can hop on top? What is meant by on top? On top of the grass, the water? A tree?’”
- Page 5: “Why do you think they are hot? Is it only the sun that would make them hot? What have they been doing? Would that make you hot?”
- In the "Spelling Manual," page 55-56, students read and image a paragraph in the "Screech and Me Student Book," sentence by sentence. The teacher is to “Help students to summarize the paragraph.” The teacher asks who the characters are and what is important in the paragraph. Students write a summary of the paragraph for independent work.
Materials contain explicit directions and/or think-alouds for the teacher to model how to engage with a text to emphasize reading for purpose and understanding. For example, the following is noted:
- In the "Small Group Manual," page 179, the teacher helps students make meaning from the sentence, “The ducks pick and peck at Beth:”
- “How did you see the words, ‘pick and peck’?"
- “What do you imagine or see for the background? If Beth looks around what do you imagine she’d see? Would she be looking at city streets and buildings?”
- Then, students mark phrases to more fluently read the sentence.
- In the "Spelling Manual," page 32, students summarize the weekly paragraph provided in their "Screech and Me Student Book." The teacher helps students summarize the paragraph. The teacher asks the questions, “Who are the characters? What did we learn about them that’s important? This paragraph is about a man with a special cat.”
- In the "Spelling Manual," page 64, students “Read and Image,” a paragraph. The teacher is provided with guiding questions to use to help students in the process. In this lesson, for example, questions the teacher asks include, “What do you see in your mind for ‘men’ and ‘hut’?” and, “How do you see ‘the sun has set?'”