2017
ReadyGEN

4th Grade - Gateway 1

Back to 4th Grade Overview
Cover for ReadyGEN
Note on review tool versions

See the series overview page to confirm the review tool version used to create this report.

Loading navigation...

Gateway Ratings Summary

Text Complexity and Quality

Text Quality & Complexity
Gateway 1 - Meets Expectations
90%
Criterion 1.1: Text Quality & Complexity
18 / 20
Criterion 1.2: Alignment to the Standards with Tasks and Questions Grounded in Evidence
15 / 16
Criterion 1.3: Tasks and Questions: Foundational Skills Development
5 / 6

The Grade 4 instructional materials meet the expectations for text quality and complexity and alignment to the standards. Most tasks and questions are grounded in evidence. The instructional materials include texts that are worthy of students' time and attention and provide many opportunities for rich and rigorous evidence-based discussions and writing about texts to build strong literacy skills.Materials address foundational skills to build comprehension and provide questions and tasks that guide students to read with purpose and understanding, making connections between acquisition of foundationalskills and making meaning during reading. Materials also provide opportunity to increase oral and silent reading fluency across the grade level.Overall, appropriately complex grade-level texts are are accompanied by quality tasks aligned to the standards of reading, writing, speaking, listening, and language to build foundational skills and strengthen literacy skills.

Criterion 1.1: Text Quality & Complexity

18 / 20

Texts are worthy of students' time and attention: texts are of quality and are rigorous, meeting the text complexity criteria for each grade. Materials support students' advancing toward independent reading.

The instructional materials meet expectations for text quality and complexity. Central texts are of publishable quality and address topics of interests to Grade 4 students. The instructional materials include a mixture of both literary and informational texts. The level of complexity of most texts is appropriate for Grade 4. The instructional materials include a text complexity analysis with rubrics and rationales for their purposes and placement.The materials support students increasing literacy skills over the year and provide students with many opportunities to engage in a range and volume of reading throughout each unit and module through anchor texts, supporting texts, and leveled libraries.

Indicator 1a

4 / 4

Anchor texts are of publishable quality and worthy of especially careful reading and consider a range of student interests.

The instructional materials reviewed for Grade 4 meet the expectations for anchor texts being of publishable quality and worth of careful reading and consider a range of interests. Texts are examined multiple times for multiple purposes and are used to expand big ideas, build academic vocabulary, and facilitate access to future similar texts. Most texts are engaging, build knowledge, and facilitate access to future text while building towards independent grade-level reading.

Unit 1 Topic: Science Integration: Becoming Researchers

  • Unit 1, Module A: Porpoises in Peril by Gwendolyn Hooks builds knowledge of a challenging concept using scientific facts and terms. The text is engaging and facilitates access to other texts in the module’s text set.
  • Unit 1, Module B: Skeletons Inside and Out by Claire Daniel has straightforward explanations and contains domain-specific vocabulary words that are defined both within the text and in a glossary to expand on the modules big idea.

Unit 2 Topic: Social Studies Integration: Exploring Culture and Nature

  • Unit 2, Module A: Why the Sea is Salty by Dot McHarry engages students in a story of chronological events while including academic vocabulary and other challenging terms.
  • Unit 2, Module B: The Longest Night by Jacqueline Guest is a narrative of a Native American boy and his rite of passage. The text builds knowledge of cultures that may be different than that of students.

Unit 3 Topic: Science Integration: Exploring Impact and Effect

  • Unit 3, Module A: Earthquakes by award winning author Seymour Simon has both stories about real life earthquakes as well as facts about what causes earthquakes. There is a balance of text features and text to help students understand earthquakes to build knowledge and understanding that will help them access future texts.
  • Unit 3, Module B: Anatomy of a Volcanic Eruption by Amy Leavitt contains chapters that include academic vocabulary as well as domain-specific words that have been defined to support students' knowledge of volcanoes and build toward the big idea of understanding the impact and effect of nature on people.

Unit 4 Topic: Social Studies Integration: Creating Innovative Solutions

  • Unit 4, Module A: Lunch Money by Andrew Clements has a challenging theme organized in a series of titled chapters. Students must be able to follow and understand the frequent use of dialogue between characters to build knowledge and determine the theme of the text.
  • Unit 4, Module B: Using Money contains a series of subtopics with graphics to support the building of knowledge with the text. There are domain-specific vocabulary and topics that include the origins and purposes of money and banking. This text supports the big idea of the module and helps to build students ability to access future text in the module.

Supplementary texts included in each module’s text set also encompass the Unit themes and help to integrate content areas while expanding big ideas and academic vocabulary.

Indicator 1b

4 / 4

Materials reflect the distribution of text types and genres required by the standards at each grade level.

The instructional materials reviewed for Grade 4 meet the expectations for reflecting the distribution of text types and genres required by the standards.

There is an overall balance of informational and literary texts within the anchor texts and supporting texts. Of the 8 anchor texts, four are informational texts and four are literary. There are also 17 supporting texts. Of these supporting texts, 9 texts are literary and 8 are informational. There is an overall balance of informational and literary texts, including both science and social studies topics.

Examples representing the balance of text types and genres include the following:

  • Anchor Text - Porpoises in Peril (Literary, Adventure)
  • Supporting Text -A Girl Who Cracked Open the World (Informational)
  • Supporting Text - Fragile Frogs (Informational)
  • Anchor Text - Skeletons Inside and Out (Informational)
  • Supporting Text - Movers and Shapers (Informational)
  • Supporting Text - King of the Parking Lot (Informational)
  • Anchor Text - Why the Sea is Salty (Literary, Tale)
  • Supporting Text - How the Stars Fell into the Sky (Literary, Legend)
  • Supporting Text - Pecos Bill and John Henry from American Tall Tales (Literary, Folktale)
  • Anchor Text - The Longest Night (Literary, Narrative Fiction)
  • Supporting Text - Northwest Coast Peoples from Kids Discover (Informational)
  • Supporting Text - Three Native Nations: Of the Woodlands, Plains, and Desert (Informational )

Poetry is included in the supporting texts (4-6 poems) and is listed in the Implementation Guide. A drama is included in Unit 4.

Indicator 1c

4 / 4

Texts have the appropriate level of complexity for the grade according to quantitative analysis, qualitative analysis, and relationship to their associated student task.

The instructional materials reviewed for Grade 4 meet expectations for text complexity, according to quantitative and qualitative analysis and relationship to their associated student task(s).

The materials include quantitative, qualitative, and reader and task information in the Teacher Resources section. Most texts are aligned to the complexity requirements outlined in the Common Core Standards with text complexity rubrics appearing at the back of each ReadyGEN Teacher’s Guide.

  • Unit 1 Module A Porpoises in Peril by Gwendolyn Hooks 850L (Literary): This text contains a challenging concept with scientific facts and terms. It is a narrative fiction told with some sarcasm by an omniscient narrator. Topics include endangered species, mining, and snorkeling.
  • Unit 1 Module B Skeletons Inside and Out by Claire Daniel 740L (Informational): This text has a straightforward explanation and contains domain–specific vocabulary. There is a glossary and index at the end.
  • Unit 2 Module A Why the Sea is Salty by Dot McHarry 720L (Literary): This text has accessible folk talk, chronological events, some challenging vocabulary, and compound and complex sentences with some simple sentences.
  • Unit 2 Module B The Longest Night by Jacqueline Guest 780L (Literary): This narrative about a Native American boy and his rite of passage is a chronological story that includes Native American terms. Students need background awareness of Native American culture.
  • Unit 3 Module B Anatomy of a Volcanic Eruption by Amy Leavitt 890L (Informational): This text contains a straightforward explanation, an introductory example, and domain–specific vocabulary.
  • Unit 4 Module A Lunch Money by Andrew Clements 840L (Literary) : This text has a challenging theme, a series of titled chapters, frequent dialogue, some advanced vocabulary, and occasional sarcasm.
  • Unit 4 Module B Using Money by 920L (Informational): This text contains a series of subtopics with graphics to support the text. There are topics that include the origins and purposes of money and banking and domain-specific vocabulary.

Of the texts that are not within the grade-level stretch band, a qualitative feature analysis gives additional insight as to the appropriateness of their placement in the curriculum. The following text has a Lexile level above the grade level stretch band, yet the qualitative and reader and task components make the text accessible for fourth grade readers.

  • Unit 4, Module A Earthquakes by Seymour Simon (Informational, 1010L): Even though the Lexile is above the grade level stretch band, the level of meaning is straightforward. Vocabulary is defined. Examples, photos, and diagrams reinforce the details. To help Grade 4 students with background knowledge, the teacher can pre-teach earthquake related terms. The qualitative and reader and task features makes this text accessible for Grade 4 students.

Every text in the close reading materials (Sleuth) is within the Lexile band outlined in the standards.

The Leveled Text Library includes readers for each unit. The books in the library begin at the Lexile band at 270L (The Hoover Dam by John Manos) and go slightly above the Lexile band to 1130L (Birds Take Flight by Lillian Duggan).

Indicator 1d

2 / 4

Materials support students' increasing literacy skills over the course of the school year. (Series of texts should be at a variety of complexity levels appropriate for the grade band.)

The instructional materials reviewed for Grade 4 partially meet expectations for supporting students' ability to access texts with increasing text complexity across the year. Over the course of the school year, students engage with texts that are within the appropriate levels of text complexity, but there is not a clear organizational strategy of text placement from beginning of the year to the end. While the rigor of text is appropriate in aggregate over the course of the school year, students will engage with texts at varying levels Unit to Unit and quarter to quarter in a structure that may not provide support for accelerating their literacy growth.

Some representative examples of how the program partially meets this indicator are shown by examining these texts examples:

  • In Unit 1, Module A, students read the literary text Porpoises in Peril. This text has a quantitative measure of 850 Lexile and is 48 pages, which is appropriate for its challenging content and tone. This is followed in Module B by the informational text Skeletons Inside and Out. The text has a quantitative measure of 740 Lexile and is 153 pages long and includes domain-specific vocabulary.
  • In Unit 2, Module A, students read the literary folk tale, Why the Sea is Salty, which has a quantitative measure of 720 Lexile and is 40 pages long. Module B includes the literary text The Longest Night, which has a quantitative measure of 780 Lexile and is 48 pages long. Over the course of the first two Units, students are engaging with rich texts, but the consistency of the texts' rigor may not support students' accelerating and growing reading skills.
  • In Unit 3, there are texts that are considerably more challenging, such as the literary text "Earthshaker's Bad Day," which has a quantitative measure of 740 but includes much dialogue and allusions as well as mythology connections. This text is in the same Unit as the mythology text "The Monster Beneath the Sea," which has a quantitative measure of 780, and the informational text A Tsunami Unfolds, which measures at 890 Lexile.
  • Unit 4 includes texts that have consistent quantitative measures as well, such as Lunch Money in Module A, a literary text that has rich content and rigorous vocabulary about advertising and entrepreneurship, that has a quantitative measure of 840 Lexile and is 222 pages long. Module B includes the informational text Using Money, which has a higher Lexile of 920 and includes different text features such as charts and graphs.

While the second half of the year presents students with more rigorous readings overall, the first part of the year offers students a consistent level of challenge that may not support their readiness to fully engage with the subsequent texts.

Indicator 1e

2 / 2

Anchor texts and series of texts connected to them are accompanied by a text complexity analysis and rationale for purpose and placement in the grade level.

The instructional materials reviewed for Grade 4 meet the expectation that anchor texts and series of connected texts are accompanied by a text complexity analysis and rationale for educational purpose and placement in the grade level.

The anchor texts and supporting texts have a "Text Complexity Rubric" page in the Teacher Resources section that covers quantitative, qualitative, and reader and task measures.

Quantitative metrics are provided for each anchor text in four categories: Lexile Level, Average Sentence Length, Word Frequency and Page or Word Count. Qualitative measures are provided for each anchor text and supporting text in four categories: levels of meaning, structure, language conventionality and clarity, and theme and knowledge demands. Metrics provided for qualitative measures are in list form. Reader and Task Suggestions are in narrative form and provide teachers with suggestions for preparing all students to read the text as well as leveled tasks. For example, the following contains the Text Complexity Rubric for the supporting text Max Malone Makes a Million (Unit 4, Module A):

  • Quantitative Measures- Lexile: 810L; Average Sentence Length: 11.47; Word Frequency: 3.62; Page Count: 20
  • Qualitative Measures- Levels of Meaning: accessible theme (boys learn by trial and error that making money is not so easy as it seems; Structure: conventional sequence of events; Language Conventionality and Clarity: simple vocabulary; some complex sentences; Theme and Knowledge Demands: basic knowledge of business planning
  • Reader and Task Suggestions: Preparing to Read the Text: Discuss with students why planning is important before starting a business; Leveled Tasks: Divide students into small groups and have them create a business proposal with detailed descriptions of supplies, tasks, and anticipated profit

At the beginning of each Module, teachers are provided with a Lexile and genre reminder about the upcoming text set. Lexiles and genres are listed for the anchor text and supporting texts. Lexiles are provided for the Sleuth texts and the Leveled Text Library. Following the Text Set information, teachers are also provided with more information about vocabulary in a section called Vocabulary to Unlock Text. This provides the teacher with Benchmark Vocabulary and Tier II and Tier III Words for the anchor text and supporting texts.

Within each unit and module, the texts are focused on a theme, which provides some rationale as to why the text was chosen.

Indicator 1f

2 / 2

Anchor text(s), including support materials, provide opportunities for students to engage in a range and volume of reading to achieve grade level reading.

The instructional materials for Grade 4 meet the expectations of indicator 1f. The instructional materials provide opportunities for students to engage in a range and volume of reading, and there are supports to build students’ comprehension of grade level texts in oral and silent reading.

Resources are provided to offer students texts to engage in a range and volume of reading. The eText Library includes leveled readers. The database is searchable by Lexile, Guided Reading, DRA, and Reading Maturity Matrix for initial search. Then, as a secondary search, texts can be chosen by grade level, language, comprehension skill, text feature, genre, and content area. Each unit has trade books which are authentic literary and informational texts. These trade books are available in digital format. In addition to texts, there are independent reading activities that students can access online.

Structures are built within the day to provide students with opportunities to practice silent and oral reading. Each day students engage in independent reading with a specific focus including building stamina and becoming independent readers. In addition, small group instruction each day either focuses on vocabulary, fluency, critical thinking or comprehension (Implementation Guide). Comprehension and vocabulary instruction dominates the small group instruction, but the few fluency lessons focus on a specific aspect of fluency such as phrasing, expression, and pacing. Students hear and see the teacher model reading the text and then practice using the same text.

A scaffolded strategies handbook is also provided, which gives teachers additional ways to teach the concepts to struggling learners and English language learners. In addition, throughout the teacher’s guide there are "if/then" sections which provide the teachers with concrete things to do when students do not understand the concept.

Criterion 1.2: Alignment to the Standards with Tasks and Questions Grounded in Evidence

15 / 16

Materials provide opportunities for rich and rigorous evidence-based discussions and writing about texts to build strong literacy skills.

The Grade 4 instructional materials meet expectations for alignment to the standards with tasks and questions grounded in evidence. Most questions, tasks, and assignments are text-dependent and build towards a culminating tasks to integrates skills. The instructional materials provide multiple opportunities for evidence-based discussion that encourage the modeling and use of academic vocabulary and support student listening and speaking about what they are reading and researching. The materials include frequent opportunities for different genres and modes of writing. Materials meet the expectations for materials including explicit instruction of the grammar and conventions standards for grade level as applied in increasingly sophisticated contexts, with opportunities for application both in and out of context. Materials reviewed provide many tasks and opportunities for evidence-based discussions and writing using evidence from texts to build strong literacy skills.

Indicator 1g

2 / 2

Most questions, tasks, and assignments are text-dependent, requiring students to engage with the text directly (drawing on textual evidence to support both what is explicit as well as valid inferences from the text).

The instructional materials reviewed for Grade 4 meet the expectations of most questions, tasks, and assignments being text-specific and requiring students to engage with the text directly (drawing on textual evidence to support both what is explicit as well as valid inferences from the text).

Some explicit question examples include:

  • "What details from the text support the idea that men and women had different roles among the people of the Northwest Coast?” (Unit 2, Module B, Lesson 7)
  • Where can you find information about how scientists classify volcanoes? What are the three classifications? What detail is discussed in each classification?” (Unit 3, Module B, Lesson 3)

Some implicit question examples include:

  • "What does Mary think about at the seacoast? How does she feel about working with her father?” (Unit 1, Module A, Lesson 9)
  • "How do the events in these last two chapters help you answer the question: Why is the sea salty?” (Unit 2, Module A, Lesson 4)

Many lessons have a Reading Analysis section where students are working toward a specific standard and engaging in either independent work or small group work to complete a task involving the text. The majority of lessons have a turn and talk after the students read, which requires the students to discuss something from the text. Some of the questions are about the text itself while some are questions that focus on author’s craft, but the majority of them require students to be engaging with the text.

  • For example, in Unit 2, Module A, Lesson 14 students identify the motivations of characters and complete the Web B Chart along with answering text-specific questions regarding the characters’ motivation.

Each lesson has small group options which include several options for students to answer text-dependent questions.

  • For example, some options are extensions of the Close Reading or Reading Analysis sections. Students will read pieces of text, find evidence in order to answer specific questions, ask questions related to what they have read, and prove their case with evidence from the text. Depending on students’ readiness, questions are modified to meet students’ needs still addressing the standards.

All lessons have a Close Reading section that includes 3-4 text-dependent questions.

  • For example, “What conclusion can you draw about compound interest from the chart on page 44 and the text on page 45? What conclusion can you draw about the advantage of saving your money in a commercial bank, rather than a piggy bank?” (Unit 4 Module B Lesson 8)

Additional materials that support students engaging with the text include:

  • In the Sleuth materials (close reading texts), there is a gather evidence section for each close read which requires students to find evidence from the text.
  • The Reader's and Writer's Notebook provides evidence-based questions.
  • The Baseline Assessment also includes evidence-based questions.

There is the Reader/Writer Journal which asks students to answer text-dependent questions in writing for each lesson.

Indicator 1h

1 / 2

Sets of high-quality sequences of text-dependent questions and tasks build to a culminating task that integrates skills (may be writing, speaking, or a combination).

The materials reviewed for Grade 4 partially meet the expectations for the indicator of providing sets of high-quality sequences of text-dependent questions and tasks build to a culminating task that integrates skills (may be writing, speaking, or a combination). The text dependent questions in the close reading section as well as some of the reading analysis sections should help students in completing the end of unit assessment successfully. However, not all Performance Based Assessments (PBAs) or end- of- unit assessments require text evidence. In addition, not all of the lessons leading up to the PBA will support the student's ability to successfully complete it.

Units are designed in themes. Most questions allow for students to develop an understanding of the theme in the text and build toward the culminating task.

  • For example, Unit 3, Module A, Lesson 2 the Close Reading section asks students to identify where the majority of earthquakes occur, locate the plates and faults near North America, and identify patterns observed based on maps provided. The theme for this particular unit is Exploring Impact and Effect.
  • The performance based task at the end of Unit 3, Module A requires students to use text evidence over the course of the module to complete the task. Students are required to analyze two of the texts and state which one is more effective in portraying the impact of earthquakes.
  • In Unit 3, Module B, students research and use text evidence to write a news report that explains the effects of a natural event. There are lessons throughout the unit that teach students research skills to help them successfully complete this Performance Based Assessment, though the lessons are writing lessons and not reading lessons.

Not all lessons include text based questions that will lead students to successfully completing the Performance Based Assessment. In some sections, the task is not concretely connected to the texts that precede it. For example, in Unit 1, Module A the Performance Based Assessment has students write a biography about a scientist or researcher who has made a difference, though there are no biography texts in the unit as a model; therefore, students are not provided questions to help them understand this genre in order to successfully write a biography

Indicator 1i

2 / 2

Materials provide frequent opportunities and protocols for evidencebased discussions that encourage the modeling and use of academic vocabulary and syntax. (May be small group and all-class.)

The materials reviewed for Grade 4 meet the expectation for providing frequent opportunities and protocols for evidence-based discussions that encourage the modeling and use of academic vocabulary and syntax. Students are given opportunities for evidence-based discussions as they work with other students in pairs and small groups.

Opportunities for discussion include:

  • In Unit 3, Module A, Lesson 16 the teacher models the academic language of text structure for students. Students are reminded to use the examples in Text Talk discussion.
  • In Unit 4, Module A, Lesson 17 structures are provided for students to work in pairs or small groups to complete a graphic organizer and discuss their responses using evidence from the text.
  • In the Performance Based Assessment in Unit 3, Module B students read texts and write to share their opinion as to which article reflects the impact of earthquakes. Then they present their writing with the class as a speech and are given the opportunity to respond to questions and receive constructive comments from their peers.
  • Close reading structures are included with discussion questions where students respond to questions with evidence from the text. (Implementation Guide p. 41)
  • Many of the questions are evidence based (i.e. How does the physical setting make it difficult for the islanders to get the salt they need Unit 2 Module A Lesson 1 or What details in the text explain how the Northwest Coast people have tried to preserve their cultures? Unit 2 Module B Lesson 8), and some are about the writing craft.

In each unit there are protocols for discussions including protocols for Think–Pair–Share Routine, Small Group Discussion Routine, and Whole Class Discussion Routine.

  • Each routine includes steps, a rationale, implementation for success, and going deeper. In each protocol there is also a suggestion about how to model it.
    • For example, the Think–Pair–Share Routine suggests modeling how you would prepare for discussions by modeling thinking through ideas to express them clearly and supporting ideas with text evidence.
  • In the small group section of each daily lesson in the Teacher's Guide, there are additional opportunities for evidence – based discussions such as the extend in the reading analysis section of the lesson and having students do additional Think–Pair–Shares for those who need extra support.

Indicator 1j

2 / 2

Materials support students' listening and speaking about what they are reading and researching (including presentation opportunities) with relevant follow-up questions and supports.

The instructional materials reviewed for Grade 4 meet indicator 1j for supporting students listening and speaking about what they are reading and researching with relevant follow-up questions and evidence.

The materials reviewed provide opportunities for speaking and listening that include whole group discussions and small group discussions. There are protocols in the Teacher's Guide that explain how to implement all of these discussions and how to model best practices for speaking and listening.

  • For example, the Small Group Discussion Routine modeling includes referring to the text or topic in the discussion and posing and responding to questions to check and clarify understanding.
  • Routines are provided for teachers on how to summarize the texts and topics discussed. This also correlates to many of the Common Core Speaking and Listening Standards, including SL 4.3 (identifying the reasons and evidence a speaker provides).

In Sleuth (Close Reading materials), structures are included for students to gather evidence, ask questions regarding the text, use evidence to make a case, and prove their case to other students within their team, with all team members having a voice. For example, in Unit 4, Module A, Lesson 17 students work in pairs or small groups to complete a graphic organizer and discuss their responses using evidence from the text.

In the writing workshop component, students are asked to share their writings. There are directions for both the speaker and the listener.

  • For example, in Unit 2, Module A, Lesson 1 students are asked to share their writing, and the audience is asked to identify the situation established in the opening paragraph.

Although students have opportunities for discussing posed questions, students have fewer opportunities to pose their own questions (SL.4.1c) and explain their own ideas (SL.4.1d).

Indicator 1k

2 / 2

Materials include a mix of on-demand and process writing (e.g. multiple drafts, revisions over time) and short, focused projects, incorporating digital resources where appropriate.

The instructional materials for Grade 4 meet the expectations of this indicator. Materials include a mix of on-demand and process writing (e.g., multiple drafts, revisions over time) and short, focused projects incorporating digital resources where appropriate.

Explicit instruction guides students through the writing process, requiring them to analyze good writing models from the text sets they read. There are 4 units and two modules (A & B) within each unit. The 18 lessons within each module focus on one type of writing.

Each Module’s writing lessons are based on text(s) and offer a model for students as they write. On-demand writing occurs each day when students write to what they have read in various formats. Examples of writing include taking notes, short answer, or paragraph construction. Lessons have been structures, so that by the end of the Module, students have addressed all components of the writing process.

Each module is structured the same way regarding process and on-demand writing. Representative examples of process writing include, but are not limited to, the following:

  • In Unit 1, Module A, Lesson 13 (Narrative Writing Component): Using the text as a model, students are taught how Thunder Cake includes the necessary elements for a narrative. Students are instructed to read specific pieces at the beginning and end of the text to see what the author did to provide a sense of closure. Students are then given an opportunity to choose a problem to write about and a solution to that problem that creates closure. During independent writing practice, students are to write a brief narrative that provides a sense of closure.
  • In Unit 2, Module B, Lesson 1 (Informative Writing): Students write informative/explanatory paragraphs that express views and provide factual information. Students are reminded to have a main idea and details to support it. Students will use the text, City Homes, as a model for how to write an informative/explanatory text. Students are to write their paragraphs in their Reader’s and Writer’s Journal and are encouraged to add a digital component where they are to find pictures with details to support their main idea. Scaffolds are provided as well as specific examples from the text to support students. Many of the tasks listed are preparing students for process writing.

On-demand writing occurs each day and vary from short answers to paragraph instruction. On-demand writing occurs in high stakes environments (e.g. assessments) as well as frequent low-stakes writing (e.g. Sample writing tasks that are on-demand include, but are not limited to, the following focused work

In Unit 2, Module B, students read various texts and use evidence to support text-based opinions. Portions of the texts will serve as writing models and students will have opportunities to practice writing tasks independently after seeing text models. The on-demand writing tasks in this Unit and Module include short writing activities in which students:

  • Form, state and support an opinion, including text evidence
  • Organize and group related ideas
  • Practice quoting accurately from text in short writes
  • Use linking words and phrases in short responses
  • Summarize the texts

Other examples of on-demand and process writing are evident throughout the materials. On-demand tasks often connect to the larger process assignment, such as the writing performance-based assessment in Unit 4: “Students will analyze two of the texts they have read in this module – Earthquakes and Quake! –and state and support an opinion about which text more effectively portrays the impact of earthquakes on human beings.”

To complete this task, students will read texts and understand that both literary and informational texts can be analyzed for ideas and information, and then use the test to complete on-demand tasks which are later synthesized into process pieces. Some shorter writing tasks have students complete:

  • Link opinions to reasons in paragraphs
  • State and support an opinion, using facts and details from the text
  • Research and draw evidence
  • List opinions and reasons

Indicator 1l

2 / 2

Materials provide opportunities for students to address different text types of writing that reflect the distribution required by the standards.

The instructional materials reviewed for Grade 4 meet the criteria for indicator 1l. Materials provide opportunities for students to address different genres/modes of writing that reflect the distribution by the standards. Students are given opportunities for instruction and practice in a variety of genres addressed in the standards over the course of the school year. Examples of text types practiced include informational, opinion, and narrative tasks such as research projects, tall tales, and opinion essays.

Performance Based Assessments can be found at the end of each unit. The assessments provide a variety of writing opportunities that reflect the distribution by the standards. In the examples below, students are engaged in narratives, informative/explanatory and opinion writing.

  • Unit 1, Module A- Informational - Research Paper
  • Unit 1, Module B- Informational - Investigation Project
  • Unit 2, Module A- Narrative - Write a tall tale
  • Unit 2, Module B- Opinion - Essay on Native Americans
  • Unit 3, Module A- Opinion - Essay on impact of Earthquakes
  • Unit 3, Module B- Informational - Research a Natural Event
  • Unit 4, Module A- Narrative - Write a short story
  • Unit 4, Module B- Opinion - Essay on impact of innovation

Other genres/modes of writing are found throughout the materials reviewed. They include tall tales, short stories, summaries, biographies, brochures, interviews, news reports, as well as with opinion and informative essays. There were no noted opportunities for students to write poetry.

Indicator 1m

2 / 2

Materials include frequent opportunities for evidence-based writing to support careful analyses, well-defended claims, and clear information.

The instructional materials reviewed for Grade 4 meet the expectations for the materials including frequent opportunities for evidence-based writing to support careful analyses, well-defended claims, and clear information.

Students are taught each day to carefully analyze and synthesize sources, write to sources, and defend claims as part of Whole Group Writing instruction. Each writing lesson focuses on a writing mode that is specified in the Common Core Standards

The Reading/Writing Journal provides on-demand writing tasks that require students to produce evidence based responses.

Some examples of opportunities for evidence-based writing in the instructional materials include:

  • In Unit 1, Module A, Lesson 1, students “Read about a person and write an introductory paragraph about the achievements of that person using evidence from the text.” Other tasks within that lesson include answering questions using evidence such as “What key details does the author provide…?” and “What do the characters learn…?”
  • In Unit 1, Module A, Lesson 2, students will reread p. 22 of Porpoises in Peril. A snorkeler tells the squad that the porpoises look thin and hungry. The question asks, “What key details does the author provide that might help explain this? Support your answer using text evidence."
  • In Unit 2, Module A, Lesson 6, students read How the Stars Fell Into the Sky, and answer the following questions:
    • What evidence from the text shows that First Woman trusts Coyote?
    • What details from the text indicate that First Woman is precise in how she places the stars? Show me where the text says so.
    • How does Coyote feel about First Woman “tacking up the night sky” with her jewels? What text evidence can you find that supports this?
    • Later in the lesson, students will use this information to write about how the author establishes tone.
  • In Unit 3, Module B, Lesson 8, students are told to use pages from the text to help them write facts and quotations on what life is like living in the shadow of a volcano.

Performance-Based Assessments (PBA) are assigned at the end of each module. These include writing projects where students use the anchor text and the major writing skill from the module in order to respond to questions to synthesize learning. These projects lead students to analyze and synthesize the texts they have read.

  • For example, students will revisit the text, The Boy Who Invented TV, and how different inventions affected other peoples’ lives. As students revisit the text, they are to take notes on the innovations and their effects so they can use the notes to help them write an opinion task that includes a main idea and details to support their opinion. (Unit 4, Module B)

Indicator 1n

2 / 2

Materials include explicit instruction of the grammar and conventions standards for grade level as applied in increasingly sophisticated contexts, with opportunities for application both in and out of context.

The instructional materials reviewed for Grade 4 meet the expectations for materials including explicit instruction of the grammar and conventions standards for grade level as applied in increasingly sophisticated contexts, with opportunities for application both in and out of context.

In each lesson, there are materials that include explicit instruction of grammar and conventions. Conventions are included in the writing rubrics within each Unit (Writing Rubric) as well. Language (grammar) lessons are included in each lesson and meet the standards for 4th grade. Skills include, but are not limited to:

  • Unit 1: nouns, pronouns, simple verb tenses, adverbs, adjectives, prepositional phrases, capitalization, punctuation
  • Unit 2: sentence structures, adjectives, quotation marks, prepositional phrases, relative pronouns, adverbs, progressive verb tenses, capitalization, dialogue, commas, coordinating conjunctions, nouns
  • Unit 3: verb tenses, adjectives, capitalization, prepositional phrases, commas, quotation marks, compound sentences, relative adverbs, relative pronouns, fragments, run-on sentences, progressive tenses, coordinating conjunctions
  • Unit 4: adjectives, subject-verb agreement, progressive verb tenses, modal auxiliaries, relative adverbs, prepositional phrases

In the lessons, the teacher provides instruction and models the skill, then offers practice. Some of the practice includes using the text of the day and other practice comes in the Reader's and Writer's Journal. There is a guided practice section where the student practices on the board and discusses it with students before they engage in the independent practice.

The Reading/Writing Journal, found online, includes lessons specific to the conventions of writing, as well as providing students with on-demand writing tasks.

Note: Unit 1, Module 1 includes a review of skills addressed in Grade 3 standards.

Criterion 1.3: Tasks and Questions: Foundational Skills Development

5 / 6

This criterion is non-negotiable. Materials must achieve a specified minimum score in this criterion to advance to the next gateway.

Materials in reading, writing, speaking, listening, and language targeted to support foundational reading development are aligned to the standards.

The materials reviewed for Grade 4 meet the criteria for materials, questions, and tasks addressing grade-level CCSS for foundational skills to build comprehension by providing instruction in phonics, word recognition, morphology, vocabulary, syntax, and reading fluency in a research-based and transparent progression. Materials provide questions and tasks that guide students to read with purpose and understanding and to make frequent connections between acquisition of foundation skills and making meaning from reading while providing students ample opportunity to increase oral and silent reading fluency across the grade level.

Indicator 1o

2 / 2

Materials, questions, and tasks address grade-level CCSS for foundational skills by providing explicit instruction and assessment in phonics and word recognition that demonstrate a research-based progression.

The materials reviewed for Grade 4 meet the criteria for materials, questions, and tasks addressing grade-level CCSS for foundational skills to build comprehension by providing instruction in phonics, word recognition, morphology, vocabulary, syntax, and reading fluency in a research-based and transparent progression.

Lessons include grade-appropriate foundational skills including phonics, word recognition, morphology, vocabulary, syntax, and fluency. Each lesson provides a teacher-directed mini-lesson related to foundational skills. These lessons include isolated reading and reading the words in context. The reading in context is not from the Unit anchor texts but additional short passages for students to practice reading in context.

Word analysis mini lessons are found within each lesson and include introductions to isolated foundational skills, practice with the skill, and application of the skill with specific words/sentences/phrases.

The following is the progression of foundational skills taught.

  • Unit 1 skills focus on –ed and -ing; -er and -est; -or; -er; compound words; –ist, -ive, and -ess; synonyms and antonyms; un- and in -; and words from other languages.
  • Unit 2 skills focus on Latin prefixes dis–, re–, and non-; compound words; the suffix –ly; unknown words; words from Latin; Greek roots; related words; and Latin roots struct, scrib, and scrip.
  • Unit 3 skills focus on multiple meaning words; suffixes –ian, -ist, and - ism; Latin roots aqua and dict; prefixes I'm– and in–; Greek & Latin prefixes trans – and tele-, Greek prefixes amphi- and anti-; synonyms and antonyms, words from French, and suffixes –ous, -able, and -ible.
  • Unit 4 skills focus on related words; the suffix –ion; words from German; homographs; Latin roots gener, port, dur, and ject; words from French; Greek roots; and Greek and Latin suffixes.

Lessons include direct and explicit instruction of how to decode unknown words.

  • For example in Unit 2, Module A, Lesson 16 students are taught how to break up the word endure by breaking it up into two syllables.

Lessons are provided for the teacher that can be used for whole group instruction, as well as optional small group tasks.

  • Word Work suggestions are provided as small group options in the Implementation Guide.
  • There are a series of foundational skill lessons that include opportunities to practice in and out of context with practice applying the skills reading in the Practice Reader.
    • In Unit 3, Module A Lesson 15 the Practice Reader 20A-20C tasks include instruction regarding the word roots aqua and dict, write the meaning of the root, describing the use of roots in words in context, using a dictionary to confirm the meaning of the roots, and reading.

There is also a printable foundational skills page that includes additional practice of the foundational skills, with a focus on the spelling of the words as well as the definitions.

Indicator 1p

1 / 2

Materials, lessons, and questions provide instruction in and practice of word analysis skills in a research-based progression in connected text and tasks.

The materials reviewed for Grade 4 partially meet the criteria for materials, questions, and tasks guiding students to read with purpose and understanding and to make frequent connections between acquisition of foundation skills and making meaning from reading. There are limited opportunities for students to apply what they are learning in the context of their reading.

Materials include Language Analysis mini lessons as a part of some lessons. Language Analysis mini lessons are sometimes about word analysis, and Language Analysis lessons are not in every lesson. In Unit 3, Module A, Lesson 6, there is a Language Analysis mini lesson for Word Meanings. In the teacher’s edition instructs the teacher to model how to determine the a meaning of open area on p. 32. The teacher asks, “What is the topic of the paragraph in which this word appears?” The teacher invites the students to determine the meaning of the word calm.

Materials include Word Analysis Foundational Skill mini lessons. Students have opportunities to read words in context, however, these passages are not from the anchor text or supporting texts that students will read in the reading lesson. For example, tasks include instruction regarding the word roots aqua and dict. Students are to write the meaning of the root, describe the use of roots in words in context, use a dictionary to confirm the meaning of the roots, and read Practice Readers 20A, 20B, and 20C (Unit 3 Module A Lesson 15). In Unit 4, Module B, Lesson 12 of Foundational Skills lessons, students learn related words. Students look at mixture and unmixed and look for commonalities. In the Practice step, students write respectable, respectful, and disrespectful and identify common base words. In Apply, partners identify how words are related and determine the meaning of the base word. There is a missed opportunity to practice related word analysis with the anchor or supporting texts, although some word analysis lessons can be practiced with Practice Readers.

In the Teacher Materials for helping students with Benchmark Vocabulary in Close Reading Lessons, the teacher is reminded to use the Benchmark Vocabulary Routine for Literary or Informational Text. This protocol lists steps to help students pronounce unknown words, read the paragraph in which the word is found, discuss the meaning of the word in context, have the students use the word in a sentence, and discuss synonyms and antonyms. A Tips and Tools section suggests helping students recognize context clues and make word webs (Unit 1, TR30).

During Close Reading instruction, the teacher’s edition contains Scaffolded Instruction to help students use context clues. For example in Unit 1, Module A, Lesson 4, the instructional materials direct the teacher to remind students to use visuals as clues to help them understand what words mean as they read stories.

Indicator 1q

2 / 2

Instructional opportunities are frequently built into the materials for students to practice and achieve reading fluency in oral and silent reading, that is, to read on-level prose and poetry with accuracy, rate appropriate to the text, and expression.

The materials reviewed for Grade 4 meet the expectations for providing students ample opportunity to increase oral and silent reading fluency across the grade level.

Instructional opportunities are frequently built into the materials for students to practice and achieve reading fluency in oral and silent reading, that is, to read on-level prose and poetry with accuracy, rate appropriate to the text, and expression.

Fluency practice is included as a section within the small group options portion of the materials.
Several lessons in small group time are devoted to fluency.

  • In Unit 1, Module A, Lesson 14, the fluency lesson uses the Oral Reading Fluency Quick Check. The teacher models and points out how to read with appropriate phrasing and then students are asked to read the same passage.
  • In Unit 2, Module A, Lesson 2, students are reading from Why the Sea is Salty and then students focus on accuracy.
  • In Unit 1 Module A Lesson 6 Fluency tasks include model fluent reading aloud with expression from Porpoises in Peril and students practice reading aloud from the same text.

Fluency assessments are included in the Assessment Book and include scoring guides. There are benchmark fluency passages to be administered in the beginning, middle, and end of the year. There is also a great deal of information for teachers on how to administer fluency assessments and a class record chart is provided.