2023
Eureka Math²

4th Grade - Gateway 3

Back to 4th Grade Overview
Cover for Eureka Math²
Note on review tool versions

See the series overview page to confirm the review tool version used to create this report.

Loading navigation...

Gateway Ratings Summary

Usability

Gateway 3 - Meets Expectations
88%
Criterion 3.1: Teacher Supports
9 / 9
Criterion 3.2: Assessment
7 / 10
Criterion 3.3: Student Supports
8 / 8
Criterion 3.4: Intentional Design
Narrative Only

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math² Grade 4 meet expectations for Usability. The materials meet expectations for Criterion 1, Teacher Supports; partially meet expectations for Criterion 2, Assessment; and meet expectations for Criterion 3, Student Supports.

Criterion 3.1: Teacher Supports

9 / 9

The program includes opportunities for teachers to effectively plan and utilize materials with integrity and to further develop their own understanding of the content.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math² Grade 4 meet expectations for Teacher Supports. The materials: provide teacher guidance with useful annotations and suggestions for enacting the student and ancillary materials; contain adult-level explanations and examples of the more complex grade-level concepts and concepts beyond the current grade so that teachers can improve their own knowledge of the subject; include standards correlation information that explains the role of the standards in the context of the overall series; provide explanations of the instructional approaches of the program and identification of the research-based strategies; and provide a comprehensive list of supplies needed to support instructional activities. 

Narrative Only
Narrative Only
Narrative Only

Indicator 3a

2 / 2

Materials provide teacher guidance with useful annotations and suggestions for how to enact the student materials and ancillary materials, with specific attention to engaging students in order to guide their mathematical development.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math2 Grade 4 meet expectations for providing teacher guidance with useful annotations and suggestions for how to enact the student materials and ancillary materials, with specific attention to engaging students in order to guide their mathematical development.

Materials provide comprehensive guidance that will assist teachers in presenting the student and ancillary materials. These are found in a variety of sections within the Implementation Guide, including the Overview, Why, Achievement Descriptors Overview, and Lesson Structure. Examples include:

  • Grade 3-5 Implementation Guide, Inside Teach, Module-Level Components, Overview, “Your Teach book begins with the Overview, a topic-by-topic summary that shows the development of learning throughout the module. It also provides connections to work done before and after the module, helping you understand the module’s place in the overall development of learning in and across the grade levels.”

  • Grade 3-5 Implementation Guide, Inside Teach, Module-Level Components, Why, “The Why section gives insight into the decisions made during the writing of the module. This insight helps you understand the underlying structure of the module, flow of the content, and coherence of the different parts of the curriculum.”

  • Grade 3-5 Implementation Guide, Inside Teach, Module-Level Components, Achievement Descriptors, “The Achievement Descriptors: Overview section is a helpful guide that describes what Achievement Descriptors (ADs) are and briefly explains how to use them. It identifies specific ADs for the module, with more guidance provided in the Achievement Descriptors: Proficiency Indicators resource at the end of each Teach book.”

  • Grade 3-5 Implementation Guide, Inside Teach, Lesson Structure, “Each lesson is structured in four sections: Fluency, Launch, Learn, and Land. Lessons are designed for one 60-minute instructional period. Fluency provides distributed practice with previously learned material. Launch creates an accessible entry point to the day’s learning through activities that build context and often create productive struggle that leads to a need for the learning that follows. Learn presents new learning related to the lesson objective, usually through a series of instructional segments. This lesson component takes most of the instructional time. Land helps you facilitate a brief discussion to close the lesson and provides students with an opportunity to complete the Exit Ticket.”

Materials include sufficient and useful annotations and suggestions that are presented within the context of the specific lessons. This guidance can be found for teachers within boxes called Differentiation, UDL, and Teacher Notes. The Implementation Guide states, “There are six types of instructional guidance that appear in the margin notes. These notes provide information about facilitation, differentiation, and coherence. Teacher Notes may enhance mathematical understanding, explain pedagogical choices, five background information, or help identify common misconceptions. Universal Design for Learning (UDL) suggestions offer strategies and scaffolds that address learner variance. These suggestions promote flexibility with engagement, representation, and action and expression, the three UDL principles described by CAST. These strategies and scaffolds are additional suggestions to complement the curriculum’s overall alignment with the UDL Guidelines.” Examples include:

  • Module 3, Topic B, Lesson 4: Apply place value strategies to divide hundreds, tens, and ones, Learn, Draw on the Place Value Chart to Divide, UDL: Action & Expression, “Consider providing equations with blanks for students to use. This can help reduce the fine-motor demands of writing. Students draw on a place value chart and write an equation to divide hundreds, tens, and ones. Direct students to remove Place Value Chart to Hundreds from their books and insert it in their whiteboards. Write 846\div2= ____.”

  • Module 4, Topic A, Lesson 6: Rename mixed numbers as fractions greater than 1, Learn, Choose a Model, UDL: Representation, “Consider activating background knowledge of different models students can use to represent whole numbers and fractions. Create a list students can refer to when they rename mixed numbers as fractions greater than 1. Area model, Tape diagram, Number bond, Number line, Equations.”

  • Module 5, Topic A, Lesson 4: Write mixed numbers in decimal form with tenths, Learn, Mixed Numbers and Decimal Form on a Number Line, Differentiation: Support, “Consider using the following questions to support students as they represent the given number on a number line: What whole numbers is the number between? How does that help you draw and label a number line? What fractional unit do you need to partition each whole number into? How do you know? How can you use the unit form to help you locate the number on the number line? How can you use the number line to help you write the number as a mixed number and in decimal form?”

  • Module 6, Topic A, Lesson 6: Relate geometric figures to a real-world context, Fluency, Show Me Geometric Figures: Lines and Line Segments, Teacher Notes, “Consider asking students to whisper to their partner how each gesture represents the geometric figure.” For example, after “Show me parallel lines, say, How do you think our arms show parallel lines? Whisper your idea to your partner.”

Indicator 3b

2 / 2

Materials contain adult-level explanations and examples of the more complex grade-level/course-level concepts and concepts beyond the current course so that teachers can improve their own knowledge of the subject.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math2 Grade 4 meet expectations for containing adult-level explanations and examples of the more complex grade/course-level concepts and concepts beyond the current course so that teachers can improve their own knowledge of the subject.

Materials consistently contain adult-level explanations, examples of the more complex grade/ course-level concepts, and concepts beyond the course within Topic Overviews and/or Module Overviews. According to page 5 of the Grade 3-5  Implementation Guide, “Your Teach book begins with the Overview, a topic-by-topic summary that shows the development of learning throughout the module. It also provides connections to work done before and after the module, helping you understand the module’s place in the overall development of learning in and across the grade levels.” Page 7 outlines the purpose of the Topic Overview, “Each topic begins with a Topic Overview that is a summary of the development of learning in that topic. It typically includes information about how learning connects to previous or upcoming content.” Examples include:

  • Module 1: Place Value Concepts for Addition and Subtraction, Module Overview, Why, “Why is the vertical number line used for rounding numbers? The vertical number line is used to help support conceptual understanding of rounding. In grade 3, students first see the vertical number line as an extension of reading a vertical measurement scale. Using the context of temperature, students identify the tens (i.e., benchmarks) between which a temperature falls, the halfway mark between the benchmark temperatures, and the benchmark temperature the actual temperature is closer to. Students then generalize to round numbers to the nearest ten and hundred. In grade 4, students round numbers with up to 6 digits to any place. They continue to use the vertical number line as a supportive model. Labeling the benchmark numbers and halfway tick mark in both standard form and unit form helps emphasize the unit to which a number is being rounded. This way, the place values line up vertically, helping students see the relationship between the numbers. The pictorial support of the vertical number line when rounding is eventually removed, but the conceptual understanding of place value remains as students round mentally. These experiences with the vertical number line prepare students for representing ratios with vertical double number lines and graphing pairs of values in the coordinate plane.”

  • Module 2: Place Value Concepts for Multiplication and Division, Module Overview, Why, “Why is the distributive property used in reference to multiplication and the break apart and distribute strategy used in reference to division? In grade 3, students use the break apart and distribute strategy \times with multiplication and division. In grade 4, the distributive property is formally named, and students recognize that the distributive property relates multiplication and addition. For example, 7\times23=7\times(20+3)=(7\times20)+(7\times3). The distributive property is more formally the distributive property of multiplication over addition. Thus, the distributive property does not apply to division. With division, the break apart and distribute strategy continues to be referenced and describes how students approach a division problem. They break apart the total into smaller parts and then divide each part by the divisor. For example, 72\div8=(40\div8)+(32\div8). In grade 5, students learn that dividing by n is equivalent to multiplying by \frac{1}{n}, so the distributive property can be applied. For example, 

72\div8=72\times\frac{1}{8}=(40+32)\times\frac{1}{8}=(40\times\frac{1}{8})+(32\times\frac{1}{8})=(40\div8)+(32\div8).”

  • Module 4: Foundations for Fraction Operations, Module Overview, Why, “Why are so many addition and subtraction strategies used? The strategies used for adding and subtracting fractions and mixed numbers in topics D and E reflect the strategies students use in grades 1, 2, and 3 to add and subtract whole numbers. These strategies reinforce the idea of fractions as numbers—we can perform operations with fractions similar to the way we perform operations with whole numbers. Because fractions are numbers, they can be composed and decomposed. Students apply the part total relationship found in addition and subtraction problems to compose and decompose the units of the parts and total. Fluency means being accurate and efficient and flexibly applying strategies to solve problems. A strategy may be efficient for solving one problem but time consuming for another. Students analyze problems and select efficient strategies, many of which develop into mental math over time. They select a model to record their work in a way that makes sense to them. Students are not expected to master all the strategies and models taught in module 4 topics D and E. Rather, they are expected to make informed decisions about which strategy to use on a problem-by-problem basis.”

Indicator 3c

2 / 2

Materials include standards correlation information that explains the role of the standards in the context of the overall series.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math2 Grade 4 meet expectations for including standards correlation information that explains the role of the standards in the context of the overall series. 

Correlation information and explanations of standards are present for the mathematics addressed throughout the grade level. The Overview section includes Achievement Descriptors and these serve to identify, describe, and explain how to use the standards. Each module, topic, and lesson overview includes content standards and achievement descriptors addressed. Examples include:

  • Module 3: Multiplication and Division of Multi-Digit Numbers, Module Overview, Achievement Descriptors, Proficiency Indicator, “4.Mod3.AD2, Multiply whole numbers of up to four digits by one-digit whole numbers. (4.NBT.B.5)” 

  • Module 4, Topic B, Equivalent Fractions, Description, “Students generate equivalent fractions and equivalent mixed numbers. They decompose fractional units to find an equivalent fraction with smaller units and record their work with multiplication. They compose fractional units to find an equivalent fraction with larger units and record their work with division. Students use area models, as well as tape diagrams and number lines, to represent fractions and compose or decompose fractional units to generate equivalent fractions.” Achievement Descriptors and Standards are listed for the module in the tab labeled, “Standards."

  • Module 5, Topic C, Lesson 10: Use pictorial representations to compare decimal numbers. Achievement Descriptors and Standards, “4.Mod5.AD4 Compare two decimal numbers to hundredths and justify the conclusions (4.NF.C.7).”

  • Module 6, Topic C, Determine Unknown Angle Measures, Description, “Students recognize and apply the additive nature of angle measure to find the unknown measures of angles within figures without using a protractor. They use what is known and the part–total relationship to determine an unknown angle measure when right angles, straight angles, and angles of known measures are decomposed. Students extend the strategy to find the measures of multiple unknown angle measures around a point.” Achievement Descriptors and Standards are listed for the module in the tab labeled, “Standards."

Indicator 3d

Narrative Only

Materials provide strategies for informing all stakeholders, including students, parents, or caregivers about the program and suggestions for how they can help support student progress and achievement.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math² Grade 4 provide strategies for informing stakeholders including students, parents or caregivers about the program and suggestions for how they can help support student progress and achievement. 

The program provides a Eureka Math² Family Resources webpage, Eureka Math² | Family Resources (greatminds.org), that families can use to find a variety of information about the program. Additionally, another webpage, Support For Students And Families (greatminds.org), provides support for families using Eureka Math². Examples include: 

  • Letters for each unit are available for the teacher to share with families. Family Math Letters (Levels K–5) states, “Our Family Math letters provide a topic overview that includes a content narrative, images of models and strategies, and key terminology. It also includes ideas for topic-related math activities that may be done at home or in school. Family Math letters are only included for levels K–5. In levels 3–5, they are found in the Apply book.” 

  • Families also have access to the online program, allowing them to see lessons and assignments. Access Your Student’s Eureka Math² Materials via the Great Minds Digital Platform states, “There’s more to Eureka Math² than can fit on a printed page. Your student's teacher will be sending a username and password home to access Eureka Math² online. On this platform, students will have the ability to do the following: View their virtual ‘to-do’ list of assignments and assessments, Participate in live digital lessons during class View past work, including teacher feedback, in their online student locker, Access virtual manipulatives, The Family Math letters, Practice, Practice Partners, and Recaps are only available in the student experience when those pages are assigned by the teacher.”

  • Families can support students with a resource that includes additional grade-level problems aligned to lessons. Practice (Level 1–Algebra I) states, “Practice problems for each lesson include mixed practice of related skills. This helps students solidify their conceptual understanding and procedural skills, transfer knowledge to new applications, and build fluency. Each Practice is structured as two pages. The front page includes problems that represent learning from class that day. The second page includes Remember problems. These problems help students recall previously learned concepts and skills. While Practice problems related to the day’s lesson help solidify new learning, Remember problems keep students sharp with familiar concepts. In level 6–Algebra I, Practice is included in the Learn book.”

  • Home support, “Practice Partners (Levels 1–5), is also available.Each Practice has a parallel supporting Practice Partner that shows problems like those worked in class and an example of the thinking that helps students solve those problems. Practice Partners serve as a useful tool for students to solve the Practice and Remember problems, as well as a guide for families who may be supporting their student with the Practice and Remember problems at home.”

Indicator 3e

2 / 2

Materials provide explanations of the instructional approaches of the program and identification of the research-based strategies.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math² Grade 4 meet expectations for providing explanations of the instructional approaches of the program and identification of the research-based strategies. 

The Grade 3-5 Implementation Guide includes a variety of references to both the instructional approaches and research-based strategies. Examples include:

  • Grade 3-5 Implementation Guide, What’s Included, “Eureka Math2 is a comprehensive math program built on the foundational idea that math is best understood as an unfolding story where students learn by connecting new learning to prior knowledge. Consistent math models, content that engages students in productive struggle, and coherence across lessons, modules, and grades provide entry points for all learners to access grade-level mathematics.”

  • Grade 3-5 Implementation Guide, Lesson Facilitation, “Eureka Math2 lessons are designed to let students drive the learning through sharing their thinking and work. Varied activities and suggested styles of facilitation blend guided discovery with direct instruction. The result allows teachers to systematically develop concepts, skills, models, and discipline-specific language while maximizing student engagement.”

  • Implement, Suggested Resources, Instructional Routines, “Eureka Math2 features a set of instructional routines that optimize equity by increasing access, engagement, confidence, and students’ sense of belonging. The following is true about Eureka Math2 instructional routines: Each routine presents a set of teachable steps so students can develop as much ownership over the routine as the teacher. The routines are flexible and may be used in additional math lessons or in other subject areas. Each routine aligns to the Stanford Language Design Principles (see Works Cited): support sense-making, optimize output, cultivate conversation, maximize linguistic and cognitive meta awareness.” Works Cited, “Smith, Margaret S., Victoria Bill, and Miriam Gamoran Sherin. The 5 Practices in Practice: Successfully Orchestrating Mathematics Discussions in Your Elementary Classroom. 2nd ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Mathematics; Reston, VA: National Council of Teachers of Mathematics, 2018. Zwiers, Jeff, Jack Dieckmann, Sara Rutherford-Quach, Vinci Daro, Renae Skarin, Steven Weiss, and James Malamut. Principles for the Design of Mathematics Curricula: Promoting Language and Content Development. Retrieved from Stanford University, UL/SCALE website: http://ell.stanford.edu/content/mathematics-resources additional-resources, 2017.”

Each Module Overview includes an explanation of instructional approaches and reference to the research. For example, the Why section explains module writing decisions. According to the Implementation Guide for Grade 4, “The Why section gives insight into the decisions made during the writing of the module. This insight helps you understand the underlying structure of the module, flow of the content, and coherence of the different parts of the curriculum.” The Implementation Guide also states, “Works Cited, A robust knowledge base underpins the structure and content framework of Eureka Math². A listing of the key research appears in the Works Cited for each module.” Examples include:

  • Module 1: Place Value Concepts for Addition and Subtraction, Module Overview, Why, “Why does the place value module begin with a topic on multiplicative comparisons? Beginning with multiplicative comparison enables students to build on their prior knowledge of multiplication from grade 3 and provides a foundation upon which students can explore the relationships between numbers and place value units. This placement also activates grade 3 knowledge of multiplication and division facts within 100 and provides students with opportunities to continue building fluency with the facts in preparation for multiplication and division in modules 2 and 3. Students are familiar with additive comparison—relating numbers in terms of how many more or how many less. Multiplicative comparison—relating numbers as times as many—is a new way to compare numbers. Students use multiplicative comparison throughout the year to relate measurement units, whole numbers, and fractions. This important relationship between factors, where one factor tells how much larger the product is compared to the other factor, is foundational to ratios and proportional relationships in later grades. Taking time to develop this understanding across the grade 4 modules sets students up for success with interpreting multiplication as scaling in grade 5 and applying or finding a scale factor in scale drawings, dilations, and similar figures.”

  • Module 3: Multiplication and Division of Multi-Digit Numbers, Module Overview, Why, “Why is vertical form introduced alongside the place value chart for multiplication and division? Similar to what students experience with addition and subtraction, vertical form is introduced alongside the place value chart for multiplication and division to support conceptual understanding and the transition from a pictorial representation to a written representation. Each action represented in the place value chart (e.g., renaming units, adding or subtracting like units, distributing units, finding the total quantity of each unit) has a direct connection to a recording within vertical form. As students become proficient with recording in vertical form, they internalize the process and no longer require drawing on the place value chart to find the unknown or explain their work. Additionally, students not yet fluent with multiplication and division facts may find the place value chart helpful in keeping track of their calculations within vertical form.”

Indicator 3f

1 / 1

Materials provide a comprehensive list of supplies needed to support instructional activities.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math2 Grade 4 meet expectations for providing a comprehensive list of supplies needed to support instructional activities. 

Each module includes a tab, “Materials” where directions state, “The following materials are needed to implement this module. The suggested quantities are based on a class of 24 students and one teacher.” Additionally, each lesson includes a section, “Lesson at a Glance” where supplies are listed for the teacher and students. Examples include:

  • Module 2: Place Value Concepts for Multiplication and Division, Module Overview, Materials, “1 Chart paper, tablet, 25 Personal whiteboards, 25 Colored pencils (red and blue), 25 Personal whiteboard erasers, 25 Crayons (red, green, and blue), 25 Eureka Math2™ place value disks set, ones to millions, 25 Dry-erase markers, 1 Projection device, 24 Learn books, 25 Rulers, 1 Meter stick, 1 Teach book, 27 Paper strips, 1"\times12", 1 Teacher computer or device, 25 Pencils.”

  • Module 4, Topic B, Lesson 7: Write mixed numbers in decimal form with hundredths,  Materials, “Teacher: Open Number Line (in the teacher edition). Students: Open Number Line (in the student book), Deci-disks set (1 per student pair). Lesson Preparation: Consider whether to remove Open Number Line from the student books and place inside whiteboards in advance or have students prepare them during the lesson. Gather at least 5 ones disks, 6 tenths disks, and 7 hundredths disks for each student pair. Review the Math Past resource to support delivery of Land.”

  • Module 6, Topic B, Lesson 8: Use a circular protractor to recognize a 1° angle as a turn through \frac{1}{360}​​ of a circle, Materials, “Teacher: Circular Protractor, Angle-maker tool. Students: Circular Protractor, Angle-maker tool. Lesson Preparation:Consider whether to remove Circular Protractor from the student books in advance or have students tear them out during the lesson. Gather the angle-maker tools created in lesson 7.”

Indicator 3g

Narrative Only

This is not an assessed indicator in Mathematics.

Indicator 3h

Narrative Only

This is not an assessed indicator in Mathematics.

Criterion 3.2: Assessment

7 / 10

The program includes a system of assessments identifying how materials provide tools, guidance, and support for teachers to collect, interpret, and act on data about student progress towards the standards.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math² Grade 4 partially meet expectations for Assessment. The materials identify the content standards assessed in formal assessments, but do not identify the mathematical practices for some of the formal assessments. The materials provide multiple opportunities to determine students' learning and sufficient guidance to teachers for interpreting student performance, but do not provide specific suggestions for following-up with students. The materials include opportunities for students to demonstrate the full intent of grade-level standards and mathematical practices across the series.

Narrative Only

Indicator 3i

1 / 2

Assessment information is included in the materials to indicate which standards are assessed.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math2 Grade 4 partially meet expectations for having assessment information included in the materials to indicate which standards are assessed. The materials identify the standards assessed for all of the formal assessments, but the materials do not identify the practices assessed for some of the formal assessments.

According to the Grade 3-5 Implementation Guide, Core Assessment Components, Exit Tickets (p. 47), “Exit Tickets are short, paper-based assessments that close lessons. These assessments use at least one problem, question, or writing prompt to assess whether a student has learned the basic skills and concepts needed for success in upcoming lessons. Items reflect the minimum that students must demonstrate to meet the lesson objective. You may look for evidence of the Standard for Mathematical Practice (MP) identified as the focus MP for the lesson in student work on the Exit Ticket.” Topic Quizzes (p. 48), “Typical Topic Quizzes consist of 4–6 items that assess proficiency with the major concepts from the topic. Many items allow students to show evidence of one or more of the Standards for Mathematical Practice (MPs). You may use the Standards and Achievement Descriptors at a Glance charts to find which MPs you may be more likely to see from your students on a given assessment item in relation to the content that is assessed. For example, you may be likely to see evidence of MP2, MP4, MP6, and MP7 on the Level 3 Module 1 Topic A Quiz as those are the MPs explicitly identified in the lessons of that topic.” 

Additionally, within the Grade 3-5 Implementation Guide (pp. 51-52), Achievement Descriptors, Standards and Achievement Descriptors at a Glance, “Every module in grades 3–5 has a Standards and Achievement Descriptors at a Glance chart. These charts identify the location and show the frequency of the content standards, Standards for Mathematical Practice, and Achievement Descriptors (ADs) in each module. Within the Proficiency Indicators section (p. 52), “Each AD has its own set of proficiency indicators. Proficiency indicators are more detailed than ADs and help you analyze and evaluate what you see or hear in the classroom as well as what you see in students’ written work. Each AD has up to three indicators that align with a category of proficiency: Partially Proficient, Proficient, or Highly Proficient. Proficiency Indicators use language that offers insights about which MPs may be observed as students engage with assessment items. For example, Proficiency Indicators that begin with justify, explain, or analyze likely invite students to show evidence of MP3: Construct viable arguments and critique the reasoning of others. Proficiency Indicators that begin with create or represent likely invite students to show evidence of MP2: Reason abstractly and quantitatively.” 

The Standards and Achievement Descriptors at a Glance chart is provided within each grade level’s Implementation Resources, within the Maps section. “How to use the Standards and Achievement Descriptors at a Glance; Identity Where Content is Taught before Teaching” states, “The Standards and Achievement Descriptors at a Glance charts identify the location and show the frequency of the content standards, Standards for Mathematical Practice, and Achievement Descriptors (ADs) in each module.” While these documents align the MPs to specific lessons and corresponding Exit Tickets, the MPs are not identified within Topic Quizzes. Examples include but are not limited to:

  • Module 2: Place Value Concepts for Multiplication and Division, Topic B Quiz version 1, Item 2, “A restaurant sells 51 hot dogs. It sells 3 times as many burgers as hot dogs. It sells 5 more milkshakes than burgers. How many milkshakes does the restaurant sell?  a. 59; b. 148; c. 158; d. 765.” Achievement Descriptors and Standards identified as 4.Mod2.AD1.HP, which correlates to 4.OA.2. There is no identification of the Mathematical Practices.

  • Module 4: Foundations for Fraction Operations, Topic D Quiz version 1, Item 2, “Ray rides his bike \frac{2}{6} miles in the morning. He rides \frac{3}{6} miles in the evening. How many miles does Ray ride altogether? Ryan rides ___ miles altogether.” Achievement Descriptors and Standards identified as 4.Mod4.AD7.P, which correlates to 4.NF.3d. There is no identification of the Mathematical Practices.

According to the Grade 3-5 Implementation Guide, Module Assessments (p.48), “Typical Module Assessments consist of 6–10 items that assess proficiency with the major concepts, skills, and applications taught in the module. Many items allow students to show evidence of one or more of the Standards for Mathematical Practice (MPs). You may use the Standards and Achievement Descriptors at a Glance charts to find which MPs you may be more likely to see from your students on a given assessment item in relation to the content that is assessed. Module Assessments represent the most important content, but they may not assess all the strategies and standards taught in the module.” While these documents align the MPs to specific lessons and corresponding Exit Tickets, the MPs are not identified within Module Assessments. Examples include but are not limited to:

  • Module 3: Multiplication and Division of Multi-Digit Numbers, Module Assessment 2, Item 2, “Multiply 4,962\times3=_____; 57\times63=_____.” Achievement Descriptors and Standards identified as 4.Mod3.AD2.P, which correlates to 4.NBT.5. There is no identification of the Mathematical Practices.

  • Module 5: Place Value Concepts for Decimal Fractions, Module Assessment 2, Item 1, “Complete each equation, 1. \frac{4}{10}=\frac{}{100}; 2. \frac{7}{10}=\frac{}{100}”. Achievement Descriptors and Standards identified as 4.Mod5.AD1.P, which correlates to 4.NF.5. There is no identification of the Mathematical Practices.

Indicator 3j

2 / 4

Assessment system provides multiple opportunities throughout the grade, course, and/or series to determine students' learning and sufficient guidance to teachers for interpreting student performance and suggestions for follow-up.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math2 Grade 4 partially meet expectations for including an assessment system that provides multiple opportunities throughout the grade, course, and/or series to determine students’ learning and sufficient guidance to teachers for interpreting student performance and suggestions for follow-up.

The assessment system provides multiple opportunities to determine students' learning, and sufficient guidance for teachers to interpret student performance is reinforced by the Proficiency Indicators. However, suggestions to teachers for following up with students are general and minimal, for example, “Look back at those lessons to select guidance and practice problems that best meet your students’ needs.” While teachers can refer back to specific lessons, it is incumbent on the teacher to determine which guidance and practice problems meet the needs of their individual students. Examples include:

  • Grade 3-5 Implementation Guide, Resources, Achievement Descriptors: Proficiency Indicators (p. 16), “Achievement Descriptors (ADs) are standards-aligned descriptions that detail what students should know and be able to do based on instruction they receive. The number of ADs addressed in each lesson varies depending on the content. This resource includes proficiency indicators for each AD. Proficiency indicators are descriptions of work that is partially proficient, proficient, or highly proficient. Proficiency indicators help you assess your students’ level of proficiency.”

  • Grade 3-5 Implementation Guide, Assessment, Standards and Achievement Descriptors at a Glance (pp. 51-52), “Every module in grades 3–5 has a Standards and Achievement Descriptors at a Glance chart. These charts identify the location and show the frequency of the content standards, Standards for Mathematical Practice, and Achievement Descriptors (ADs) in each module. Use these charts to quickly determine where and when standards and ADs are taught within and across modules to help you target observations. You may also use these charts in conjunction with assessment data to identify targeted ways to help meet the needs of specific learners. Use assessment data to determine which ADs and Proficiency Indicators to revisit with students. Use the examples provided with the Proficiency Indicator(s) as the basis for responsive teaching or use the modules’ Standards and Achievement Descriptors at a Glance chart to identify lessons that contain guidance and practice problems to support student follow up.”

  • Grade 3-5 Implementation Guide, Assessment, Respond to Student Assessment Performance (p. 59), “After administering an assessment, use the assessment reports in the Analyze space of the Great Minds Digital Platform to view student performance by Achievement Descriptor (AD). Analyze the student-performance data and select one or both of the following methods to address learning needs.” Proficiency Indicators: “Proficiency indicators increase in cognitive complexity from partially proficient (PP) to proficient (P) to highly proficient (HP). If a student has difficulty with content of the P indicator of a given AD, follow-up with the student by revisiting the content at the PP indicator of the same AD as shown in the AD proficiency indicator charts. Select the Student Performance report in the Analyze space of the Great Minds Digital Platform. Filter by proficiency indicator and any individual or group of assessments. When the report indicates proficiency of an AD has not been met, refer to the module’s Achievement Descriptors: Proficiency Indicator resource and use the lower-complexity task to build toward full understanding. Use the examples provided with the Proficiency Indicator(s) as the basis for responsive teaching. Example: For students who do not meet the Proficient indicator (4.Mod1.AD1.P), consider focusing on the Partially Proficient indicator (4.Mod1.AD1.PP). In this case, strengthen student foundational understanding of creating one comparison statement to build towards proficient understanding with two comparison statements.”

  • Grades 3-5 Implementation Guide, Assessment, The Standards and Achievement Descriptors at a Glance Charts (p. 60), “Select the Student Performance report in the Analyze space of the Great Minds Digital Platform. Filter by proficiency indicator and any individual or group of assessments. When the report indicates proficiency of an AD has not been met, refer to the Standards and Achievement Descriptors at a Glance charts to identify lessons that teach the concepts of that AD. Navigate to those lessons to find guidance and practice problems to follow up with students. Example: If students struggle with 4.Mod1.AD1, use the Standards and Achievement Descriptors at a Glance chart to find that lessons 1, 2, 3, 4, and 6 address the AD. Look back at those lessons to select guidance and practice problems that best meet your students’ needs.”

The assessment system provides guidance to teachers for interpreting student performance within Scoring Guides for Module Assessments and Topic Quizzes. Examples include:

  • Module 2: Place Value Concepts for Multiplication and Division, Module Assessment 1, Item 9, “Liz starts at the number 3. She creates a pattern by using the rule: Add 3. Part A, Complete the first six terms in Liz's pattern. 3, ___, ___, ___, ___, ___. Part B, Will the 80th term in the pattern be even or odd? Explain how you know.” Correct Answers are 1) 6, 2) 9, 3) 12, 4) 15, 5) 18. “Part A, Achievement Descriptor, 4.Mod2.AD5; Proficiency Indicator, P; Possible Points, 1\times2=2; Scoring Type, Dichotomous; Scoring Notes, All five responses must be correct to earn 2 points. Part B; Achievement Descriptor, 4.Mod2.AD5; Proficiency Indicator, P; Possible Points, 1\times2=2; Scoring Type, Dichotomous; Scoring Notes, Use the scoring notes in the answer key to determine how many points a student earns. After the scale factor is applied, a student can earn 0 or 2 points.”  

  • Module 4: Foundations for Fraction Operations, Topic C Quiz Scoring Guide, “The scoring guide uses a scale factor to weight items differently. The scale factor is determined by the item’s target level of proficiency. Items that target high proficiency carry less weight because it is likely that the least number of students will answer them correctly. Items that target partial proficiency carry more weight because it is likely that the greatest number of students will answer them correctly. When a single item aligns to multiple proficiency indicators, the scale factor of the highest proficiency indicator is used. Target Performance Indicator: Highly Proficient (HP), Scale Factor 1; Proficient (P), Scale Factor 2; Partially Proficient (PP), Scale Factor 3.” The assessment contains five items with no partial credit given unless otherwise indicated in the notes.

Indicator 3k

4 / 4

Assessments include opportunities for students to demonstrate the full intent of grade-level/course-level standards and practices across the series.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math2 Grade 4 meet expectations for providing assessments that include opportunities for students to demonstrate the full intent of grade-level standards and practices across the series.

According to the 3-5 Implementation Guide, “The assessment system in grades 3 through 5 helps you understand student learning by generating data from many perspectives. The system includes Lesson-embedded Exit Tickets, Topic Quizzes, Module Assessments, Pre-Module Assessment in Eureka Math 2 Equip, and Benchmark Assessments. These assessments use a variety of question types, such as constructed response, multiple select, multiple choice, single answer, and multi-part. Module Assessments.” These assessments consistently list grade-level content standards for each item. While Mathematical Practices are not explicitly identified on assessments, they are regularly assessed. Students have opportunities to demonstrate the full intent of the standards using a variety of modalities (e.g., oral responses, writing, modeling, etc.). Examples include:

  • Module 1: Place Value Concepts for Addition and Subtraction, Topic E Quiz 2, Metric Measurement Conversion Tables, Item 3, “Decide whether each equation is true or false. 1 km = 100 m, 3 kg = 3,000 g, 4 L = 4,000 mL, 2 m = 2,000 cm.” Students engage with the full intent of 4.MD.1 (Know relative sizes of measurement units within one system of units including km, m, cm, kg, g… Within a single system of measurement, express measurements in a larger unit in terms of the smaller unit…).

  • Module 3: Multiplication and Division of Multi-Digit Numbers, Topic A, Lesson 1, Divide Multiples of 100 and 1000, Land, Exit Ticket, supports the full intent of MP8 (Look for and express regularity in repeated reasoning) as students divide by using unit form and basic division facts. “Divide. Use unit form to help you. a. 800\div2=___ hundreds \div ___; =___ hundreds; =___.  b. 1200\div4=____.”

Module 5, Place Value Concepts for Decimal Fractions, Module Assessment 2, Item 2, “Add. \frac{3}{10}+\frac{25}{100}=1___, \frac{81}{100}+\frac{5}{10}=2___, 2\frac{17}{100}+1\frac{6}{10}=3___” Students engage with the full intent of 4.NF.5 (Express a fraction with denominator 10 as an equivalent fraction with denominator 100, and use this technique to add two fractions with respective denominators 10 and 100).

Indicator 3l

Narrative Only

Assessments offer accommodations that allow students to demonstrate their knowledge and skills without changing the content of the assessment.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math2 Grade 4 partially provide assessments which offer accommodations that allow students to demonstrate their knowledge and skills without changing the content of the assessment.

While few in nature, some suggestions for accommodations are included within the Grade 1-2 Implementation Guide. Examples include:

  • Grade 3-5 Implementation Guide, Inside the Digital Platform describes digital assessments available within the program. “Access the Great Minds Library of digital assessments, where you can duplicate and adjust assessments. You can also assign several assessments at once from this space.” Teachers could make decisions about accommodations for different learners but no specific guidance is provided for them.

  • Grade 3-5 Implementation Guide, Assessment, Exit Tickets describes accommodations for time. “In a typical classroom, most students with basic understanding can finish within 3–5 minutes. In some settings, honoring the timeframe is more important than requiring students to finish. For example, a student’s inability to finish within 5 minutes may be valuable information. In other settings, you may extend the time to allow all students to finish as appropriate.”

  • Grade 3-5 Implementation Guide, Assessment, Topic Quizzes assess proficiency with the major concepts from the topic. “There are three analogous versions of each Topic Quiz available digitally. Analogous versions target the same material at the same level of cognitive complexity. However, typical items on analogous versions are not clones of the original version. Use the analogous versions to give retakes, with reteaching or additional practice between takes, until students score proficient or above.” Teachers could make decisions about accommodations for different learners but no specific guidance is provided for them.

  • Grade 3-5 Implementation Guide, Assessment, Module Assessments describes the use of read aloud as a possible accommodation. “Typical Module Assessments consist of 6–10 items that assess proficiency with the major concepts, skills, and applications taught in the module. There are two analogous versions of each Module Assessment available digitally. Analogous versions target the same material at the same level of cognitive complexity. However, typical items on analogous versions are not clones of the original version. Use the analogous versions to give retakes, with reteaching or additional practice between takes, until students score proficient or above.” Teachers could make decisions about accommodations for different learners but no specific guidance is provided for them.

Criterion 3.3: Student Supports

8 / 8

The program includes materials designed for each student’s regular and active participation in grade-level/grade-band/series content.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math² Grade 4 meet expectations for Student Supports. The materials provide: strategies and supports for students in special populations and for students who read, write, and/or speak in a language other than English to support their regular and active participation in learning grade-level mathematics; multiple extensions and/or opportunities for students to engage with grade-level mathematics at higher levels of complexity; and manipulatives, both virtual and physical, that are accurate representations of the mathematical objects they represent and, when appropriate, are connected to written methods.

Narrative Only
Narrative Only
Narrative Only
Narrative Only
Narrative Only
Narrative Only

Indicator 3m

2 / 2

Materials provide strategies and supports for students in special populations to support their regular and active participation in learning grade-level/series mathematics.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math² Grade 4 meet expectations for providing strategies and supports for students in special populations to support their regular and active participation in learning grade-level mathematics.

Suggestions are outlined within Teacher Notes for each lesson. Specific recommendations are routinely provided for implementing Universal Design for Learning (UDL), Differentiation: Support, and Differentiation: Challenge, as well as supports for multilingual learners. According to the Grade 3-5 Implementation Guide, Page 46, “Universal Design for Learning (UDL) is a framework based on current research from cognitive neuroscience that recognizes learner variance as the norm rather than the exception. The guiding principles of the UDL framework are based on the three primary networks of the brain. Although the concept of UDL has roots in special education, UDL is for all students. When instruction is designed to meet the needs of the widest range of learners, all students benefit. Eureka Math2 lessons are designed with these principles in mind. Lessons throughout the curriculum provide additional suggestions for Engagement, Representation, and Action & Expression.” Examples of supports for special populations include:

  • Module 2, Topic A, Lesson 2: Divide two- and three-digit multiples of 10 by one-digit numbers, Launch, “Language Support: Encourage students to use precise language such as factor, unknown factor, and total as they describe the categories they identified. Rephrase student responses as necessary to include the precise language in the discussion.” Learn, Divide by Using Unit Form, “UDL: Action & Expression: Support students in expressing learning in flexible ways. Encourage students to skip-count by tens rather than use place value disks to support the use of mental math in this segment.” Learn, Multiplicative Comparison with Unknown Factors, “UDL: Representation Consider pausing and providing additional think time as students begin to represent the problem with a tape diagram. Ask questions such as the following: What information is known? What information is unknown? What letter could you use to represent the unknown information? Pausing provides time for processing of information and signifies its importance.” Land, Debrief, “UDL: Action & Expression Consider reserving time for students to reflect on their overall experiences multiplying one-digit numbers by multiples of 10 and dividing two- and three-digit multiples of 10 by a one-digit number. What strategies work well for me? Which methods do I need more practice using to become confident? What is still confusing? What can I do to help myself?”

  • Module 3, Topic C, Lesson 10: Apply place value strategies to multiply four-digit numbers by one-digit numbers, Learn, Multi-Digit Multiplication on the Place Value Chart, “UDL: Action & Expression: Revisit Liz’s thinking in Launch. Ask students if, after completing the work on the place value chart, they can confirm whether Liz’s thinking was correct. After the class comes to consensus that Liz’s thinking was correct, support students in reflecting by posing the following prompts: If you agreed with Liz, what about your thinking was confirmed? If you disagreed with Liz, what about your thinking has changed?” Learn, Three Methods, “UDL: Action & Expression Consider supporting students in planning their method to multiply the four-digit number. Have students turn to a group member and summarize the steps of one method they can apply before getting started. Language Support: Encourage the use of the Ask for Reasoning section of the Talking Tool to support students with asking their group members clarifying questions.”

  • Module 5, Topic D, Lesson 12: Apply fraction equivalence to add tenths and hundredths, Launch, “UDL: Action & Expression: Consider providing tools to support students with renaming tenths as hundredths. For example, students may wish to use Blank Tape Diagram, Area Models, and Number Line from lesson 9.” Learn, Choose a Strategy to Add, “UDL: Representation: Consider engaging the class in brainstorming what they already know about making equivalent fractions to activate prior knowledge.” Learn, Share, Compare, and Connect, “Language Support: Consider inviting students to refer to the Talking Tool as they share strategies and ask questions about their peers’ strategies. UDL: Engagement: Consider presenting a real-world application of adding tenths and hundredths anchored in a context that may be of interest, or familiar, to students. For example,a snake is \frac{48}{100} meters long. It grows another \frac{3}{10} meters. How long is the snake now?” Learn, Add Tenths and Hundredths, “Language Support Consider supporting students with the phrases like units, related units, and unlike units by providing examples. Like units: \frac{1}{4} and \frac{3}{4}, tenths and tenths Related units: \frac{1}{2} and \frac{1}{4}, tenths and hundredths Unlike units: \frac{1}{2} and \frac{1}{3, tenths and thirds.”

Indicator 3n

2 / 2

Materials provide extensions and/or opportunities for students to engage with grade-level/course-level mathematics at higher levels of complexity.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math² Grade 4 meet expectations for providing extensions and/or opportunities for students to engage with grade-level/course-level mathematics at higher levels of complexity.

Materials do not require advanced students to do more assignments than their classmates. Instead, students have opportunities to think differently about learning with alternative questioning, or extension activities. Specific recommendations are routinely highlighted as Teacher Notes within parts of each lesson, as noted in the following examples: 

  • Module 2, Topic A, Lesson 2: Divide two- and three-digit multiples of 10 by one-digit numbers, Learn, Differentiation: Challenge, “Consider providing students with more challenging numbers. Invite students to think about whether they could use a similar strategy to interpret the expression 600\div3 or 6,000\div3. What is similar and different about each of the quotients? Why?”

  • Module 3, Topic C, Lesson 11: Represent multiplication by using partial products, Learn, Partial Products in Vertical Form, Differentiation: Challenge, “Consider inviting students to work independently or with a partner to find 273\times5 and  3\times4,128. Direct students to articulate the process of recording partial products with vertical form.”

  • Module 5, Topic B, Lesson 6: Represent hundredths as a place value unit, Learn, Hundredths as a Fractional Unit and a Place Value Unit, Differentiation: Challenge, “Consider inviting students to shade 100 hundredths in an area model. Then ask the following questions: How can you represent the shaded amount as a fraction with a denominator of 100? How can you represent the shaded amount as a fraction with a denominator of 10? How can you represent the shaded amount as a decimal number?”

Indicator 3o

Narrative Only

Materials provide varied approaches to learning tasks over time and variety in how students are expected to demonstrate their learning with opportunities for students to monitor their learning.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math² Grade 4 provide various approaches to learning tasks over time and variety in how students are expected to demonstrate their learning with opportunities for students to monitor their learning.

Students engage with problem-solving in a variety of ways within a consistent lesson structure: Fluency, Launch, Learn, Land. According to the Implementation Guide, Lesson Structure, “Each lesson is structured in four sections: Fluency, Launch, Learn, and Land. Lessons are designed for one 60-minute instructional period. Fluency provides distributed practice with previously learned material. It is designed to prepare students for new learning by activating prior knowledge and bridging small learning gaps. Launch creates an accessible entry point to the day’s learning through activities that build context and often create productive struggle that leads to a need for the learning that follows. Every Launch ends with a transition statement that sets the goal for the day’s learning. Learn presents new learning related to the lesson objective, usually through a series of instructional segments. This lesson component takes most of the instructional time. Suggested facilitation styles vary and may include direct instruction, guided instruction, group work, partner activities, interactive video, and digital elements. The Problem Set, an opportunity for independent practice, is included in Learn. Land helps you facilitate a brief discussion to close the lesson and provides students with an opportunity to complete the Exit Ticket. In the Debrief portion of Land, suggested questions, including key questions related to the objective, help students synthesize the day’s learning. The Exit Ticket provides a window into what students understand so that you can make instructional decisions.”

Examples of varied approaches across the consistent lesson structure include:

  • Module 1, Topic B, Lesson 5: Organize, count, and represent a collection of objects, Launch, “Students examine charts and discuss composing place value units.” Teachers, “Introduce the Which One Doesn’t Belong? routine. Display the picture of the four charts. Invite students to study the picture of the charts. Give students 1 minute to find a category in which three of the items belong, but a fourth item does not. When time is up, invite students to explain their chosen categories and to defend why one item does not fit. Highlight responses that emphasize reasoning about place value units, about composing units, and about place value representations. Ask questions that invite students to use precise language, to make connections, and to ask questions of their own.” Sample questions include: “Which one doesn’t belong? How many more hundreds does chart D need to rename to the next largest unit? How do you know? What larger unit can be composed with 10 ones? 10 tens? How can the one in chart C be renamed as tens and ones? How can the tens in chart A be renamed as hundreds and tens?”

  • Module 4, Topic D, Lesson 18: Estimate sums and differences of fractions by using benchmarks, Fluency, Choral Response: Closer to \frac{1}{2} or 1? “Students decide whether a fraction is closer to \frac{1}{2} or 1 to prepare for estimating sums and differences by using benchmarks. Display \frac{1}{3} and the number line labeled with 0, \frac{1}{2}, and 1. Think about where \frac{1}{3} is located on the number line. Is \frac{1}{3} closer to \frac{1}{2} or 1? Raise your hand when you know. Wait until most students raise their hands, and then signal for students to respond. Display \frac{1}{3} on the number line.” 

  • Module 6, Topic D, Lesson 20: Sort polygons based on a given rule, Learn, Learn the Guess My Rule Game, “Students learn how to play the Guess My Rule game.” Teachers, “Introduce the Guess My Rule game. We are going to sort polygons based on whether they follow a given rule. Read the rules from the Rules Page chorally with the class. Then explain the directions for the Guess My Rule game. As you explain the directions to students, model the actions you describe and play a round of the game with students, providing them with the opportunity to guess the rule. The example given is a sample chart for the rule: Shapes with at least 1 pair of parallel sides.” 

Indicator 3p

Narrative Only

Materials provide opportunities for teachers to use a variety of grouping strategies.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math² Grade 4 provide opportunities for teachers to use a variety of grouping strategies.  

The materials provide opportunities for teachers to use a variety of grouping strategies. Teacher suggestions include guidance for a variety of groupings, including whole group, small group, pairs, or individual. Examples include:

  • Module 2, Topic, Lesson 21: Find factor pairs for numbers up to 100 and use factors to identify numbers as prime or composite, Launch, “Students make arrays to help them reason about the number of factors for a given number. Write the equation l\times w=24 Invite students to turn and talk about numbers that make the equation true. Direct students to work with a partner to draw as many arrays with an area of 24 square units as possible. As they create each array, have them sketch the array and record the equation that represents the area. Provide students with 2 minutes to find all possible arrays, sketch the arrays, and record the equations. After students record the equations, direct them to work with another group to compare their equations and to discuss the factors of 24 based on the equations they recorded. Invite students to think–pair–share about how they know that they have found all the factors of 24. ​​Invite students to turn and talk about how they might find all the factors of a number such as 96. Transition to the next segment by framing the work.”

  • Module 3, Topic C, Lesson 15: Multiply with four partial products. Learn, Explain the Calculation, “Use the Numbered Heads routine. Organize students into groups of 3 and assign each student a number, 1 through 3. Present the problem: 83 times as much as 52. Give students 2 minutes to find the product as a group. Remind students any one of them could be the spokesperson for the group, so they should be prepared to answer. Groups should be prepared to share the following information: their group’s process for finding the partial products; the product; and how place value supports determining the partial products and product.”

  • Module 6, Topic B, Lesson 9: Identify and measure angles as turns and recognize them in various contexts. Learn, Degree of Turning, “Students use degrees in relation to directions. Display the directional signs (i.e., North, East, South, West) on the correct walls in the classroom. Have students stand and face north. Turn 90⁢° to the right. What direction are you facing? Look at the sign to see. Repeat the process until students see each of the directions posted around the room. Direct students to face north. Display the following instructions and say them aloud one at a time to students. Walk four small steps forward. Make a quarter turn counterclockwise. Walk five small steps forward. Make a half turn clockwise. Then ask what direction students are facing and how many degrees they need to turn to face south. Pair students and invite them to give three or four walking and turning instructions to a partner. Invite students to write the instructions on their whiteboards before saying them to their partners.”

Indicator 3q

2 / 2

Materials provide strategies and supports for students who read, write, and/or speak in a language other than English to regularly participate in learning grade-level mathematics.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math² Grade 4 meet expectations for providing strategies and supports for students who read, write, and/or speak in a language other than English to regularly participate in learning grade-level mathematics. 

Support for active participation in grade-level mathematics is consistently included within a Language Support Box embedded within parts of lessons. According to the Grade 3-5 Implementation Guide, “Multilingual Learner Support, Multilingual learners, or learners who speak a language other than English at home, require specific learning supports for gaining proficiency with the English needed to access the mathematics. Research suggests that best practices for these learners include opportunities and supports for student discourse and for using precise terminology. In addition to precise domain-specific terminology, high-impact academic terminology that supports learners across learning domains is explicitly introduced and used repeatedly in various contexts to build familiarity and fluency across the grade levels. Eureka Math² is designed to promote student discourse through classroom discussions, partner or group talk, and rich questions in every lesson.” According to Eureka Math² How To Support Multilingual Learners In Engaging In Math Conversations In The Classroom, “Eureka Math² supports MLLs through the instructional design, or how the plan for each lesson was created from the ground up. With the goal of supporting the clear, concise, and precise use of reading, writing, speaking, and listening in English, Eureka Math² lessons include the following embedded supports for students. 1. Activate prior knowledge  (mathematics content, terminology, contexts). 2. Provide multiple entry points to the mathematics. 3. Use clear, concise student-facing language. 4. Provide strategic active processing time. 5. Illustrate multiple modes and formats. 6. Provide opportunities for strategic review. In addition to the strong, built-in supports for all learners including MLLs outlined above, the teacher–writers of Eureka Math² also intentionally planned to support MLLs with mathematical discourse and the three tiers of terminology in every lesson. Language Support margin boxes provide these just-in-time, targeted instructional recommendations to support MLLs.” Examples include:

  • Module 1, Topic E, Lesson 23: Express metric measurements of length in terms of smaller units, Learn, Relative Size of Units, MLL students are provided the support to participate in grade-level mathematics as described in the UDL: Representation, “The context video Running Meters and Kilometers is available to provide another format to illustrate the relationship between meters and kilometers. It may be used to remove language or cultural barriers and provide student engagement. Consider showing the video and facilitating a discussion about what students notice and wonder. This supports students in visualizing the situation before being asked to interpret it mathematically. Ask students how it feels to run 1 meter. Invite students who have experience with running longer distances to compare how it feels to run 1 kilometer, or 2 and 12 laps on a track. Invite students to count the number of steps they take in 1 meter and estimate how many steps they take in 1 kilometer.”

  • Module 4, Topic A, Lesson 1: Decompose whole numbers into a sum of unit fractions, Fluency, Counting on the Number Line by Halves, Language Support, “Consider using strategic, flexible grouping throughout the module. Pair students who have different levels of mathematical proficiency. Pair students who have different levels of English language proficiency. Join pairs to form small groups of four. As applicable, complement any of these groupings by pairing students who speak the same native language.”

  • Module 6, Topic B, Lesson 9: Identify and measure angles as turns and recognize them in various contexts, Learn, Problem Set, MLL students are provided the support to participate in grade-level mathematics as described in the Teacher Note box, “A context video for problem 5 in the Problem Set is available. It may be used to remove language or cultural barriers and provide student engagement. Before providing the problem to students, consider showing the video and facilitating a discussion about what students notice and wonder. This supports students in visualizing the situation before being asked to interpret it mathematically. Alternatively, consider showing the video during Land to facilitate students confirming their solutions. Consider inviting students to reflect on how the video helped them see how the parts of the scene are related. Invite them to describe how this helped them solve the problem and how they can apply the thinking to other situations.”

Indicator 3r

Narrative Only

Materials provide a balance of images or information about people, representing various demographic and physical characteristics.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math² Grade 4 provide a balance of images or information about people, representing various demographic and physical characteristics. 

Images are included in the student materials as clip art. These images represent different races and portray people from many ethnicities in a positive, respectful manner, with no demographic bias for who achieves success based on the problem contexts and grade-level mathematics. There are also a variety of people captured in video clips that accompany the Launch portion of lessons. Examples include: 

  • Module 1, Topic A, Lesson 3: Describe relationships between measurements by using multiplicative comparison, Fluency, Counting the Math Way by Ones and Tens, “Students construct a number line with their fingers while counting aloud and model compositions to prepare for place value concepts beginning in lesson 5. For each skip-count, show the math way on your own fingers while students count, but do not count aloud. Have students count the math way by ones from 0 to 10. Ask students to model bundling 10 ones to make 1 ten by clasping their hands together. Now let’s count the math way by tens. Each finger represents 10.” An image of clasped hands is shown.

  • Module 2, Topic B, Lesson 7: Multiply by using an area model and the distributive property,  Launch, “Students discuss strategies for finding the total number of tiles in an array. Display the picture of the square tiles, Zara, and Luke. Zara and Luke want to know how many square tiles are on the wall. What do you notice about their strategies? How can Zara use her strategy to find the total number of tiles? How can Zara use her strategy to find the total number of tiles?” Images of a female with a light-brown complexion and a male with brown complexion are shown.

  • Module 4, Topic E, Lesson 24: Add a mixed number to a mixed number, Learn, Add Mixed Numbers in Context, “Students draw a tape diagram and add mixed numbers to solve a word problem. Mr. Endo gathers 2\frac{7}{12} dozen eggs from his hens in 1 day. He gathers 3\frac{9}{12} dozen eggs the next day. How many dozen eggs does he gather in the 2 days?” An image of a tape diagram is shown.

Indicator 3s

Narrative Only

Materials provide guidance to encourage teachers to draw upon student home language to facilitate learning.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math² Grade 4 provide guidance to encourage teachers to draw upon student home language to facilitate learning. 

In the 3-5 Implementation Guide, Multilingual Learner English Support provides a link to Eureka Math² “How to Support Multilingual Learners in Engaging in Math Conversation in the Classroom,” provides teachers with literature on research-based supports for Multilingual Learners. The section, Research Focusing on How to Support MLLs with Terminology Acquisition states, “In addition to supporting and fostering authentic mathematical discourse, language-rich classrooms must systematically develop the terminology needed to communicate mathematical concepts. This means that educators must consider multiple tiers of terminology support at any one time. Beck, McKeown, and Kucan (2013) organize terminology into a three-tiered model: tier 1 terms (conversational terms), tier 2 terms (academic terms), and tier 3 terms (domain-specific terms). Because each tier of terminology is used differently in communicating in math class, each must be supported differently. However, in supporting each tier of terminology, instruction must center around honoring and acknowledging the funds of knowledge students bring to the class, instead of assuming that a student doesn’t know the meaning of a term simply because they are a MLL. Adopting a funds of knowledge approach to terminology acquisition helps teachers move away from a simplified view of language and shift toward recognizing and supporting the complexity of language in mathematics (Moschkovich 2010).” Another section, Supporting Mathematical Discourse in Eureka Math2, states, “Authentically engaging in mathematical discourse can present a unique challenge for MLLs. They are constantly managing a large cognitive load by attempting to understand mathematics while also thinking—often in their native language—about how to communicate ideas and results in English. Additionally, everyday classroom interactions are heavily focused on listening and speaking rather than on reading and writing. To lighten the cognitive load of MLLs, Eureka Math2 provides ample opportunities for students to engage in a balanced way with all four aspects of language—reading, writing, speaking, and listening—while engaging with mathematics. Eureka Math2 supports teachers to create language-rich classrooms by modeling teacher–student discourse and by providing suggestions for supported student-to-student discourse. Since curricula in general have an abundance of receptive language experiences (reading and listening), Eureka Math2 focuses specific supports on language production (speaking and writing) in mathematics. The most all-encompassing Language Support margin box appears in the first lesson of every module in Eureka Math2 prompting teachers to consider using strategic, flexible grouping in each activity of the entire module to support MLLs. These grouping suggestions invite teachers to leverage students’ funds of knowledge and native language by assembling pairs of students in different ways. Each of these different ways of pairing students has different benefits for MLLs. Pairing students who have different levels of English language proficiency allows MLLs time for oral rehearsal before speaking or writing about mathematics. It also can provide a language model for MLLs new to the US. Pairing students who have the same native language can provide MLLs time to process in their native language, lowering their affective filter and allowing them to use their native language to solidify the math concept at hand.”

Implementation Resources, Community, Eureka Math² Family Math page, Family Support Resources, Teachers and/or Families are provided a link to the following Eureka Math² materials in Spanish:

  • Family Support: “Family Math is a letter to families that describes the major concepts in the current topic. Each letter uses words and phrases that should be familiar to the student from the lessons in the topic. It includes visual supports that students can use to explain the concepts or strategies to their family, or that can help adults at home understand or unpack a concept. Family Math also includes simple and practical at-home activities to extend learning and help students see mathematics in their world.”

  • Practice: “Practice problems interleave and distribute practice. Interleaving practice means mixing different types of problems together in the same set. The mixture requires learners to discern and recall which knowledge, concepts, and strategies are appropriate. Distributing practice spaces out practice with a given concept or skill over time. This periodic practice helps students solidify their conceptual understanding and procedural skills, transfer knowledge to new applications, and build fluency. Each Practice is structured as two pages. The front page includes problems that represent learning from class that day. These problems are organized similarly to those in the Problem Set, with the final problem being no more complex than those on the Exit Ticket. The second page includes Remember problems. These problems help students recall previously learned concepts and skills. While Practice problems related to the day’s lesson help solidify new learning, Remember problems keep students sharp with familiar concepts. If there is no Problem Set in the day’s lesson, the Practice only includes Remember problems. The Remember problems match the complexity of the proficiency indicators of the relevant Achievement Descriptors.”

  • Practice Partners: “Practice Partners provide a unique kind of support. They take students through the thinking of a ‘partner’ who is solving problems like those in the Practice. The partner represents the thinking required to approach and unpack the problem, using steps that are like those named and described in the lesson. If a term is formally introduced in a lesson, it appears on the Practice Partner in the partner’s thinking.”

In addition, the resources section of each lesson includes slides and/or student pages that are translated into the Spanish language.

Indicator 3t

Narrative Only

Materials provide guidance to encourage teachers to draw upon student cultural and social backgrounds to facilitate learning.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math² Grade 4 partially provide guidance to encourage teachers to draw upon student cultural and social backgrounds to facilitate learning. 

While Spanish materials are accessible within lessons and within the Family Support Materials, there are few specific examples of drawing upon student cultural and social backgrounds. Examples include: 

  • Module 1, Topic B, Lesson 8: Write numbers to 1,000,000 in standard form and word form, Launch, Math Past, “The Math Past resource includes further explanation of each hieroglyph and more information about how Egyptians used hieroglyphs to represent numbers. Display the Egyptian hieroglyphic numerals. Explain that ancient Egyptians used hieroglyphs to write numbers and each hieroglyph has the value shown. Invite students to think–pair–share about how Egyptian numerals and our numerals are similar and different.”

  • Module 2, Topic E, Lesson 25: Explore properties of prime and composite numbers up to 100 by using multiples, Launch, Math Past, “The Math Past resource includes more information about sieves and Eratosthenes. The resource also provides more information about how the Sieve of Eratosthenes works to identify prime and composite numbers. Display the picture of a sieve. What do you know about the object? Have you ever used this or something like it before? What have you used it for? One name for the object is a sieve. We will be using a mathematical sieve today. Invite students to turn and talk about what they think a mathematical sieve might do or how it might be used. Display the picture of Eratosthenes.”

Indicator 3u

Narrative Only

Materials provide supports for different reading levels to ensure accessibility for students.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math² Grade 4 partially provide support for different reading levels to ensure accessibility for students.

The Grade 3-5 Implementation Guide states, “A student’s relationship with reading should not affect their relationship with math. All students should see themselves as mathematicians and have opportunities to independently engage with math text. Readability and accessibility tools empower students to embrace the mathematics in every problem. Lessons are designed to remove reading barriers for students while maintaining content rigor. Some ways that Eureka Math² clears these barriers are by including wordless context videos, providing picture support for specific words, and limiting the use of new, non-content-related vocabulary, multisyllabic words, and unfamiliar phonetic patterns.” Examples include:

  • Module 2, Topic B, Lesson 8: Multiply by applying the distributive property and write equations, Learn, Record with Equations, UDL: Engagement, “Consider promoting the value of the work and supporting students in relating the work to the area model by adding context to the problems. Relate a rectangular area context to the numbers by talking about a context such as a garden, mural, or playground.” 

  • Module 5, Topic A, Lesson 2: Decompose 1 one and express tenths in fraction form and decimal form, Learn, Tenths on a Number Line, Teacher Note, “The term decimal is sometimes used as a shortened way to refer to a decimal point or to a number written in decimal form. Model precision by using the more specific terms, decimal point and decimal form, and support students as they make sense of these terms with familiar phrasing.”

  • Module 6, Topic C, Lesson 13: Decompose angles by using pattern blocks, Launch, Language Support, “Consider creating a word bank of pattern block names and descriptions for students to reference when giving explanations in the lesson. Consider using color-coding in the word bank to connect the picture and term: orange square, blue rhombus, tan rhombus, yellow hexagon, green triangle.”

Indicator 3v

2 / 2

Manipulatives, both virtual and physical, are accurate representations of the mathematical objects they represent and, when appropriate, are connected to written methods.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math² Grade 4 meet expectations for providing manipulatives, both virtual and physical, that are accurate representations of the mathematical objects they represent and, when appropriate, are connected to written methods.

Each lesson includes a list of materials for the Teacher and the Students. As explained in the Grade 3-5 Implementation Guide, “Materials lists the items that you and your students need for the lesson. If not otherwise indicated, each student needs one of each listed material.” Examples include:

  • Module 1, Topic B, Lesson 8: Write numbers to 1,000,000 in standard form and word form, Learn, Write Numbers in Standard and Word Forms, Materials, Teacher and Student: Place Value Chart to Millions. “Students group thousands to write numbers in word form and standard form.” Teacher Note, “To support students in writing numbers in standard form, a place value chart is used throughout the lesson. Students express a number in standard form by writing the digits on the place value chart. This scaffold helps them keep track of the place value of each digit, see where commas should be placed, and read the number. Consider removing the scaffold of the place value chart as students are ready.”

  • Module 5, Topic A, Lesson 2: Decompose 1 one and express tenths in fraction form and decimal form, Learn, Tenths on a Number Line, Materials, Teacher: Meter stick. “Students decompose 1 meter and write tenths in decimal form and fraction form. Trace along the edge of a meter stick to create a number line with a length of 1 meter. Draw and label tick marks to represent 0 and 1. Let’s represent tenths another way. How can we use the meter stick to partition the number line into tenths?”

  • Module 6, Topic C, Lesson 13: Decompose angles by using pattern blocks, Learn, Decompose and Angle, Materials, Student: Pattern blocks. “Students use pattern blocks to decompose an angle and find the measure.” After students use pattern blocks to decompose an obtuse angle, the teacher directs students to discuss their decompositions and equations with a partner. “Circulate and listen as they talk. Identify two or three students to share their thinking. Purposefully choose work that allows for rich discussion about connections between strategies used to find the measure of \angle{L}.”

Criterion 3.4: Intentional Design

Narrative Only

The program includes a visual design that is engaging and references or integrates digital technology, when applicable, with guidance for teachers.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math² Grade 5 integrate technology such as interactive tools, virtual manipulatives/objects, and/or dynamic mathematics software in ways that engage students in the grade-level standards; include or reference digital technology that provides opportunities for teachers and/or students to collaborate with each other; have a visual design that supports students in engaging thoughtfully with the subject that is neither distracting nor chaotic; and provide teacher guidance for the use of embedded technology to support and enhance student learning.

Narrative Only
Narrative Only
Narrative Only
Narrative Only

Indicator 3w

Narrative Only

Materials integrate technology such as interactive tools, virtual manipulatives/objects, and/or dynamic mathematics software in ways that engage students in the grade-level/series standards, when applicable.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math² Grade 4 integrate technology such as interactive tools, virtual manipulatives/objects, and/or dynamic mathematics software in ways that engage students in the grade-level standards, when applicable.

According to the Grades 3-5 Implementation Guide, “Each Eureka Math² lesson provides projectable slides that have media and content required to facilitate the lesson…” Examples include: 

  • Fluency activities

  • Digital experiences such as videos, teacher-led interactives, and demonstrations

  • Images and text from Teach or Learn cued for display by prompts such as display, show, present, or draw students’ attention to 

  • Pages from Learn including Classwork, removables, Problem Sets, and Exit Tickets. 

Additionally, Inside the Digital Platform, “Lessons that include digital interactives are authored so that while you demonstrate the digital interactive, students engage with the demonstrations as a class. Eureka Math² digital interactives help students see and experience mathematical concepts interactively. You can send slides to student devices in classroom settings where it feels appropriate to do so. Use Teacher View to present, send slides to students, monitor student progress, and create student discussions. If you send interactive slides to students from this view, you can choose to view all students’ screens at once or view each student’s activity individually.”

Indicator 3x

Narrative Only

Materials include or reference digital technology that provides opportunities for teachers and/or students to collaborate with each other, when applicable.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math² Grade 4 include or reference digital technology that provides some opportunities for teachers and/or students to collaborate with each other, when applicable. 

According to the Grade 3-5 Implementation Guide, Inside the Digital Platform, Teacher View, “Lessons that include digital interactives are authored so that while you demonstrate the digital interactive, students engage with the demonstration as a class. Eureka Math² digital interactives help students see and experience mathematical concepts interactively. You can send slides to student devices in classroom settings where it feels appropriate to do so. Use Teacher View to present, send slides to students, monitor student progress, and create student discussions. If you send interactive slides to students from this view, you can choose to view all students’ screens at once or view each student’s activity individually.” Additionally, Inside the Digital Platform, Student View, “Teacher demonstration slides contain interactives that you can send to student devices. Students use the interactives to engage directly with the mathematical concepts and receive immediate feedback.”

Indicator 3y

Narrative Only

The visual design (whether in print or digital) supports students in engaging thoughtfully with the subject, and is neither distracting nor chaotic.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math² Grade 4 have a visual design (whether in print or digital) that supports students in engaging thoughtfully with the subject, and is neither distracting nor chaotic. 

There is a consistent design across modules, topics and lessons that support student understanding of the mathematics. Student materials, in printed consumable format, include appropriate font size, amount and placement of directions, and space on the page for students to show their mathematical thinking. Teacher digital format is easy to navigate and engaging. There is ample space in the printable Student Task Statements, Assessment PDFs, and workbooks for students to capture calculations and write answers. According to the Grade 3-5 Implementation Guide, visual design includes:

  • Lesson Overview, “Each lesson begins with two pages of information to help you prepare to teach the lesson. The Lesson at a Glance is a snapshot of the lesson framed through what students should know, understand, and do while engaging with the lesson. It includes information about the tools, representations, and terminology used in the lesson. Key Questions help focus your instruction and classroom discourse. They encapsulate the key learning of the lesson and may help develop coherence and connections to other concepts or a deeper understanding of a strategy or model. Students discuss these questions as part of the Debrief to synthesize learning during the Land section of the lesson. Achievement Descriptors (ADs) are standards-aligned descriptions that detail what students should know and be able to do based on instruction. The number of ADs addressed in each lesson varies depending on the content. Turn to the Resources section at the end of the Teach book to see the proficiency indicators for each AD. Proficiency indicators help you assess your students’ level of proficiency. The Exit Ticket is a formative assessment that is given at the end of the lesson. Use it to monitor student progress toward proficiency on the Achievement Descriptors and to make instructional choices for upcoming lessons.”

  • Lesson Structure, “Each lesson is structured in four sections: Fluency, Launch, Learn, and Land. Lessons are designed for one 60-minute instructional period.”  The consistent structure includes a layout that is user-friendly as each component is included in order from top to bottom on the page.

  • Visual Design, “In the Teach book, color coding and other types of text formatting are used to highlight facilitation recommendations and possible statements, questions, and student responses. These are always suggestions and not a script. Each section includes a bold line of text that gives the purpose for that section. These purpose statements, taken together, support the overall objective of the lesson. Dark blue text shows suggested language for questions and statements that are essential to the lesson. Light blue text shows sample student responses. Text that resembles handwriting indicates what you might write on the board. Different colors signal that you will add to the recording at different times during the discussion. Bulleted lists provide suggested advancing and assessing questions to guide learning as needed.” 

  • Inside Learn, “Learn is students’ companion text to the instruction in Teach. It contains all the pages your students need as you implement each lesson. The components that go with each lesson are indicated by icons in the student book. The magnifying glass icon indicates a lesson page that students use during the guided or directed portion of the lesson. The gears icon indicates the Problem Set. This is a carefully crafted set of problems or activities meant for independent practice during the lesson. Items from the Problem Set may be debriefed in Land, or you may use the items as formative assessment or for deeper discussion about a specific aspect of the instruction. The checked ticket icon indicates the Exit Ticket. The Exit Ticket is a brief, formative assessment of key learning in the lesson. An orange bar on the side of a page indicates a removable, a student page that should be removed from the Learn book. A removable may be used inside a personal whiteboard so students can practice skills several times in different ways, or it may be cut, assembled, or rearranged for an activity during a lesson or across multiple lessons.”

Indicator 3z

Narrative Only

Materials provide teacher guidance for the use of embedded technology to support and enhance student learning, when applicable.

The materials reviewed for Eureka Math² Grade 4 provide teacher guidance for the use of embedded technology to support and enhance student learning, when applicable.  

The Digital Platform provides an additional format for student engagement and enhancement of grade-level mathematics content. According to the Grade 3-5 Implementation Guide, Inside the Digital Platform, “The Great Minds Digital Platform is organized into five key curriculum spaces: Teach, Assign, Assess, Analyze, and Manage. On the digital platform, lessons include the same features as in the Teach book, as well as a few more elements that are unique to the digital space. For example, on the digital platform, the side navigation panel previews digital presentation tools, such as slides, that accompany lessons. Each space within the digital platform supports you to maximize the features that Eureka Math² offers. Teach, Teach contains all the information in the print version, as well as digital curriculum components such as assessments, digital interactives, and slides to project for students. Use this space to access the curriculum components you need for daily instruction. Assign, Create assignments for your students by using any artifact in the Eureka Math² resource library, such as Exit Tickets, Module Assessments, Classwork, removables, or problems for practice. You can launch assessments, view and monitor progress on assigned assessments, and score and analyze completed assessments. Assess, Access the Great Minds Library of digital assessments, where you can duplicate and adjust assessments. You can also assign several assessments at once from this space. Analyze, Generate reports and view data about students’ progress toward proficiency. Assessment reports provide insights, summaries of class performance, and student proficiency by item. Manage, The Manage space allows administrators and teachers to view rostering data for their schools or classes. It is also where you can set or reset a student’s password.”